Summer ought to be a time to slow down and relax, right? Not if you're Apple's
The news came in PortalPlayer's second-quarter earnings release. CEO Gary Johnson said in a statement that gains from new designs built for flash-based music players -- such as those from iRiver, Creative
Analyst estimates bear this out, too. A check of Yahoo! Finance shows the Street was expecting $0.30 per share in non-GAAP earnings for the third quarter and $51.22 million in sales. Both are at the very bottom of the company's projected ranges. Yet neither number has pleased investors. Instead, the stock trades roughly 6% lower as I write.
I think I know why: A look at the Q2 financials reveals that revenue was flat sequentially. That seems odd when Apple sold 800,000 more iPods over the same period. And even if product cycles don't quite align, sequential growth between Q1 and Q2 iPod shows similar unit growth gains. Apple's iPod revenue was also up 8.8% during its fiscal third quarter. PortalPlayer can't be expected to ape those gains precisely, of course. But it ought to get at least within spitting distance. It didn't -- and investors probably noticed.
PortalPlayer is an interesting company at the center of a remarkably popular market. Some have undoubtedly sought the shares as a way to get in on Apple's meteoric rise without paying the same premium. Sorry, but that's just plain silly. Much as I remain impressed by its growth, inventiveness, and -- even to some degree -- valuation, PortalPlayer is entirely subject to the whims of Apple and flighty consumers. And, as the numbers bear out, it doesn't always get the full benefit of the popularity of its chief customer.
Bottom line: If you really want to make money off the Pod people, Apple is still your best bet. Period.
Whistle up related Foolishness with these tidbits:
- PortalPlayer turns up the volume in its second-quarter earnings report.
- When will the rumors about a video iPod end?
- Investors caughtCreative's
(NASDAQ:CREAF)negativity like a bad cold in June.
- Is Sony's
(NYSE:SNE)new whatchamacallit an iPod killer?
Does the prospect of taking on a little extra risk in exchange for multi-bagger returns wet your whistle? Well then don your belled cap, Fool, and take a risk-free trial to Motley Fool Rule Breakers. Or sign up now and let David Gardner buy you a copy of our Blue Chip Report, which contains 10 picks from our best analysts for the decade ahead. Either way, your portfolio will thank you.
Fool contributor Tim Beyers still doesn't have an iPod. Geek. Tim didn't own shares in any of the companies mentioned in this story at the time of publication. You can find out what's in his portfolio by checking Tim's Fool profile, which is here. The Motley Fool has an ironclad disclosure policy.