American Oriental Bioengineering (NYSE: AOB ) looks good on the surface. What's not to like about revenue jumping 68% year over year? China's not dead. Growth like that should be rewarded.
But dig a little deeper and look where the company is headed. You'll see why investors are being cautious about the stock, valuing the company at just less than five times last year's adjusted earnings.
In its quest to become the Johnson & Johnson (NYSE: JNJ ) of China, this purveyor of traditional Chinese medicine has been growing through acquisitions. Bolt on here, bolt on there -- it all sounds good, but American Oriental Bioengineering has had to pay for those acquisitions through dilutive stock offerings. Earnings per share, after backing out charges for acquired research & development, came in up 17%. Still not bad, but it looks like there isn't nearly as much organic growth left in those acquisitions.
The company is guiding for 30% revenue growth this year, but most of that increase will come from the distribution center it purchased in October. Organic revenue growth will be 11%, while net income before interest is expected to grow less than 4%. Interest expenses should be higher this year, because AOB sold convertible notes in the middle of last year. After taking that into account, I really don't see any growth in earnings at all this year.
How does 30% projected revenue growth line up with flat earnings? It seems likely that the company will increase R&D expenses as an investment in its future. Management indicated that the company will launch several products this year, and at least 10 new ones next year. It's also starting a clinical trial to test one of its Chinese medicine compounds for urinary incontinence -- an idea of dubious merit, in my book. Clinical trials are expensive, and while the drug may be effective, if it ever did reach approval in the U.S., American Oriental Bioengineering would have to face formidable competition. Pfizer (NYSE: PFE ) , Johnson & Johnson, GlaxoSmithKline (NYSE: GSK ) , Novartis (NYSE: NVS ) , and Procter & Gamble (NYSE: PG ) all have their own drugs for overactive bladders.
It would seem wiser to license out the drug than to invest in expensive clinical trials. Perhaps that's the company's strategy after completing a relatively cheap phase 1 trial, but AOB has never been very forthcoming with its plans.
I want to like American Oriental Bioengineering -- there's a lot of potential in China, and it's darn cheap right now. But it's going to have to show that it can translate that top-line growth into increased earnings before I'll jump on board.
Further Foolishness from the opposite side of the globe:
RSS Headlines
Fool UK