Post of the Day
October 27, 1998

From our
Communion of Bulls Folder

Posts selected for this feature rarely stand alone. They are usually a part of an ongoing thread, and are out of context when presented here. The material should be read in that light.

Go To: Post |  Folder

Subject: Re: Will the real valuation please stand up?
Author: AngryCandy

Well just to tackle book value, my argument would simply be that book value is an important valuation tool for some companies and a meaningless valuation tool for other companies.

I want to know the book value of a brokerage or a steel company, for example. The value of such companies resides largely in the assets they currently possess.

But for a company like DELL or MSFT (or even YHOO, AOL, etc.), I don't think the book value is nearly as important. When you buy these stocks, you are buying a revenue/earnings stream, not current assets. And some of these companies are able to make MORE money by having LESS in assets. That's a strength not a weakness but trying to measure them by book value won't show you this.

If the market cap of the S&P comes to be composed in larger % by companies for whom book value is not as relevant a measure than, by common sense, the book value of the S&P as a whole becomes a less meaningful valuation tool.

If the S&P were made up of all brokerages and steel companies and other heavy industrials, OK, go and measure the book value of the S&P. But if more and more of the market cap of the S&P consists of ultra-light companies like DELL, why would you want to make an investment decision based on the book value of the S&P.

Basically, I think you shouldn't try and fit a square peg into a round hole. Different stocks need different valuation tools.


The Post of the Day may be edited for readability or length, but never for content. The opinions expressed in the Posts are those of their authors, and not necessarily The Motley Fool. We make no claim or warranty as to the veracity or accuracy of any post, and present this feature only as an example of what may be found on our message boards. Don't take the Post of the Day, or anything else here, as gospel and, as our seventh grade English teacher, Mrs. Peacock, used to say, do your own homework, and avoid run-on sentences.