Should you invest in iShares Core High Dividend ETF (HDV)?
This iShares ETF may not be the best ETF for income investors or beginner ETF investors due to its relative complexity and high turnover rate, despite offering a high yield and a low expense ratio.
One drawback is that its index methodology is not fully transparent, since it relies on qualitative scoring from analysts to select stocks. This makes it harder to evaluate why certain companies are included or excluded compared to simpler dividend ETFs that use more objective, rules-based criteria.
Additionally, this ETF is heavily concentrated in just two sectors—consumer staples and energy, which together make up more than 50% of the fund.
With only 75 holdings, diversification is more limited than in broader dividend ETFs or mutual funds.
Finally, its high turnover rate means the ETF is constantly replacing stocks, making it difficult for long-term winners to compound gains.
Investors seeking a more stable, long-term dividend growth strategy may prefer an ETF with lower turnover and broader diversification.