Shares of Kellogg
How it got here
The general economic malaise in the U.S. and downright disaster going on in Europe has made its way to the cereal aisle and Kellogg's results. In the most recent quarter, sales fell 1.3% to $3.4 billion and management said Europe's demand was lower than expected. Commodity prices are putting pressure on the bottom line as well and would have resulted in a decline in earnings if not for a hedge associated with the Pringles acquisition.
Unfortunately for shareholders, the underperformance is nothing new. Kellogg has been stuck in a rut for a long time now, underperforming other food giants General Mills
The underperformance isn't surprising considering Kellogg is the only one of these companies with negative sales growth in the most recent quarter. General Mills, its closest competitor, grew 13% in the most recent quarter and trades with similar valuation multiples.
Return on Assets
Source: Yahoo! Finance.
With consumers still pinching pennies around the world, there's no reason to think that sales will pick up soon, and competitors appear to be running circles around Kellogg right now.
Kellogg has a nice dividend yield and trades with the lowest forward P/E ratio of the companies I highlighted above, so it may rise from this new low, especially if Europe has any kind of turnaround. But I don't think the stock will outperform rivals that are growing more quickly, so I don't think it's a great buy.
Despite the underperformance recently, the CAPS community thinks there are some positive signs going forward. They've given the stock four stars (out of five), with 858 players saying the stock will outperform the market.
What we know for sure is that Kellogg isn't going anywhere anytime soon, so if you have a low-risk portfolio this wouldn't be a bad place to sock some money away. I think there are better buys out there, but I do know that in 10 years Kellogg will still have a major presence in the cereal aisle, so it won't stay down for long.