The 3 Reasons eBay Wants to Keep PayPal

There was a time, back in the 1980s and 1990s when Carl Icahn enjoyed the reputation of "corporate raider," and the mere announcement of his interest in a company was responsible for many a spilled coffee cup in the handsomely appointed corporate boardrooms of the era. While Icahn's preferred method of value creation has shifted from leveraged corporate buyouts to playing the role of "activist investor" when he takes a stake in a company, he still plays to win. Having acquired a less than 1% stake in Internet commerce company eBay  (NASDAQ: EBAY  ) , the feisty billionaire investor is advocating for a spinoff of its fast growing PayPal payments platform.

"PayPal Car," Paris. Courtesy: LeWeb13, under Creative Commons License.

Thanks but everything's fine over here
eBay, understandably, thinks PayPal's potential will be best reached by remaining within its operations.The company asserts that it has considered spinning off its payments arm, but it believes that PayPal and eBay are "far more valuable together." The major themes behind this belief were outlined recently via PayPal's blog (you can read the post, now on eBay's site, here). The company presented three reasons why it believes that a spinoff isn't an appropriate way forward. These reasons were also articulated during its fourth-quarter 2013 earnings call with analysts. Let's look at the arguments one by one. 

1. eBay accelerates PayPal's success
The first argument -- that eBay accelerates PayPal's success -- is eBay's most cogent point. As part of eBay, PayPal gets a built-in customer base from transactions conducted on the company's Marketplaces platform, which includes the auction and sales properties, online event ticket venue StubHub, and various advertising services businesses. The sum total of all payment transactions that PayPal facilitates is referred to by eBay as "total payments volume." Last year, PayPal facilitated $179.6 billion of TPV. Of this total, fully $54.4 billion of TPV came from eBay's Marketplaces platform. In its blog post, the company refers to eBay's "enormously valuable global customer base," and as far as PayPal is concerned, that's not an understatement.

Would spinning off PayPal mean foregoing a $54 billion transaction pool? Not immediately. eBay has spent the last 10 years since acquiring PayPal making it the preferred payment option for its customers, so even if eBay wanted to, it's not likely that it could or would make a quick transition to another payments platform should PayPal depart for the public markets. But the uncertainty over this 30% of PayPal revenue should be carefully considered by shareholders in evaluating the merits of a spin-off.

2. eBay data makes PayPal smarter
It's true that eBay data "makes PayPal smarter," but this thought process is most applicable to that 30% of transaction volume provided by eBay's customers. Sharing of data enhances PayPal's risk management, a selling point to merchants which CEO John Donahoe recently called "PayPal's secret sauce." Outside of this 30% base, however, eBay's data becomes less relevant. In fact, PayPal's robust risk management is seen by some as too cumbersome. Recently, upstart competitor Square eliminated holds and deposit limits in the U.S. and Canada for manually entered transactions, promising to deposit funds into merchants' accounts within 1-2 business days.  This directly challenges the risk management rationale behind PayPal's often long holds on merchants' funds, and appeals to companies that want their transactions funded immediately.

3. eBay funds PayPal's growth
While this statement is literally correct, it shouldn't concern the investor who's trying to decide whether he or she will benefit from a spin-off. eBay states that it provides a source of low-cost capital to PayPal. But PayPal has grown over the years to presently account for more than 41% of eBay's revenues. It's a significant contributor to cash on the company's balance sheet, so to some extent, eBay "provides" PayPal's own money back to it when it funds growth. As for debt capital, eBay's credit ratings, which determine its net debt cost of capital, are also partially a function of PayPal's success and contribution to the company financials.

If spun off, PayPal should generate adequate cash to fund its own growth if it approaches anywhere near the profitability of comparable transaction leaders Visa  (NYSE: V  )  and MasterCard  (NYSE: MA  ) , which both enjoy quarterly profit margins north of 30%. As for equity capital, if PayPal finds success in life after eBay, it can float secondary stock offerings in future years to raise cash for acquisitions, should it see fit.

To give due credit to eBay, it does help fund PayPal's growth via profitability. While eBay Marketplace transactions account for 30% of PayPal's TPV, these transactions provide 50% of PayPal's profitability. This is likely due to the fact that PayPal has zero acquisition costs for Marketplace customers. eBay essentially provides the customers for free, dramatically reducing associated selling and general and administrative costs. My colleague Eric Volkman makes the case that this profitability is one of the major reasons eBay should keep PayPal under its wing. Still, if PayPal can grow its volume significantly as a dedicated stand-alone company, it can negate the outsized benefit of the higher-margin volume it currently enjoys from its eBay association.

Why eBay wants to keep PayPal
One of the eBay's strengths that investors undoubtedly find appealing is the company's strong and increasing cash flows:

EBAY Cash from Operations (Quarterly) Chart

eBay Cash From Operations (Quarterly) data by YCharts.

As you can tell, cash flow per quarter has been trending upward, which coincides with the rapid growth of PayPal relative to the rest of the company. In the last two years, PayPal's revenue has risen by 50%, to bring it to the overall 41% of total company revenues mentioned above. Management understandably doesn't want to spin off its fastest-growing segment, especially one in which the total market is colossal. After all, while the $179.6 billion of transaction volume PayPal sees in a year may seem like a large figure, as I wrote last year, competitor Visa enables $1 trillion of electronic commerce every business quarter.

The presence of strong cash flows associated with PayPal likely inform Icahn's thinking. Stable and increasing cash flows make valuing a stand-alone entity easier. Markets like streamlined business models, which are primed for long-term growth, and the visibility and potential for PayPal's future cash flows may ultimately outweigh the benefits of PayPal's current synergies with eBay.

A great recent example of a parent company letting a fast-growing segment go free is Expedia's  (NASDAQ: EXPE  )  December 2011 spinoff of TripAdvisor  (NASDAQ: TRIP  ) . At the time of that transaction, Expedia had a market value of $3.75 billion. Twenty-eight months later, the combined market capitalization of Expedia and TripAdvisor -- two separate companies that still, it should be noted, transact a lot of business together -- stands at $24.8 billion.  As we've seen above, there are persuasive reasons for both a PayPal spinoff and simply maintaining the status quo, but given the market's appreciation for simplified, high-growth, high-cash flow spinoffs like TripAdvisor, can one blame Carl Icahn for being so eager to explore such a deal?

Looking for growth? Here are three stocks not to miss
It's no secret that investors tend to be impatient with the market, but the best investment strategy is to buy shares in solid businesses and keep them for the long term. In the special free report "3 Stocks That Will Help You Retire Rich," The Motley Fool shares investment ideas and strategies that could help you build wealth for years to come. Click here to grab your free copy today.

Read/Post Comments (3) | Recommend This Article (1)

Comments from our Foolish Readers

Help us keep this a respectfully Foolish area! This is a place for our readers to discuss, debate, and learn more about the Foolish investing topic you read about above. Help us keep it clean and safe. If you believe a comment is abusive or otherwise violates our Fool's Rules, please report it via the Report this Comment Report this Comment icon found on every comment.

  • Report this Comment On March 17, 2014, at 11:26 PM, PhilipCohen wrote:

    Notwithstanding that I am otherwise a vociferous critic of eBay, this time I have to agree with Johnny Ho that eBay should not let go of “PreyPal”. Without its existing integrated relationship with the eBay marketplace, the value of the clunky “PreyPal” would be reduced greatly (eBay actually generates ~30% of PayPal new users with no customer acquisition costs for PayPal and half of PayPal's profits come from transactions on eBay where “PreyPal” is well integrated and virtually mandated); and, worse still, without “PreyPal”, the value of the eBay marketplace would be reduced by some 40% (“PreyPal” currently contributes ~42% of eBay’s profits) …

    I hate to admit it, but for once Johnny Ho has got it right; no doubt Carl Icahn is correct in many of his other criticisms of eBay but with respect to “PreyPal” he clearly has no understanding of the value of the inextricable and mutually supporting nature of the incestuous relationship between these two clunky, disingenuous, unscrupulous, commercial entities, and in particular, the precariousness of PayPal’s clunky business model …

    Notwithstanding the amount of disingenuous nonsense that constantly emanates from the eBay Dept of Spin, PayPal is a clunky middleman, in the main riding precariously, at the pleasure of the retail banks, on the backs of those retail banks’ existing payments systems. PayPal has little more than one percent (~1.1%) of the world’s total payments business (and even then much of its payers’ funds are sourced via MasterCard/Visa); the “bankcards”, MasterCard and Visa, have ~90% of this market between them and Amex has another ~8%, and both MasterCard and Visa have recently launched their own “professional” mobile/plastic POS/online digital wallets: MasterCard's "MasterPass" and Visa's ""; undoubtedly these two new professional entrants will ultimately bury most of these middlemen payments pretenders—particularly the clunky "PreyPal" ...

    The reality is that the clunky PreyPal’s “best before” date is approaching; as a “stand-alone” operation that “best before” date would simply arrive even sooner …

    Still, as long as Carl Icahn continues to dig his spurs deep into the narcissistic, sociopathic Johnny Ho’s person, for me, all is well in the world …

    Regardless, none of the above can outweigh the fact that eBay’s Johnny Ho is otherwise a talentless, destructive, narcissistic sociopath and that under his direction eBay Inc. is proceeding apace down the toilet and is ultimately going to finish up at the sewage farm …

    “Never ever hire an MBA; they will ruin your company.”—PayPal founder, Peter Thiel

  • Report this Comment On March 17, 2014, at 11:29 PM, PhilipCohen wrote:

    Finally, it’s nigh impossible to keep a track of all the deviousness, deceptiveness and unscrupulousness, or indeed, the criminal activity, of eBay Inc.; their unprincipled activities are so pervasive; one can only generalize and describe eBay as an equal opportunity fraudster: they will directly defraud, or will directly and indirectly aid and abet others to defraud, whoever they can, whenever they can, as long as they too can profit from such fraud. Indeed, eBay is probably the most unscrupulous commercial entity on the planet; eBay is—demonstrably—the greatest knowing and calculated facilitator of the most massive and endemic auction fraud on consumers that the world is ever likely to know and, doubtless, there will be a trickle down effect of similar criminal activity to their other operations. Anyone that does business with eBay Inc. does so at their peril …

  • Report this Comment On March 17, 2014, at 11:43 PM, PhilipCohen wrote:

    News Flash: Johnny Ho was responsible for eBay acquiring PayPal!

    Johnny Ho certainly has the eBay Dept of Spin working overtime to counteract Carl Icahn: yet another SEC filing …

    Love the pretty charts. But, what does the “smart money” on Wall Street really think about the progress of Johnny Ho’s delusion of converting eBay into the world’s “Westfield Mall” of online shopping? Well, in late 2007—when the Ho was already effectively in control of eBay—both eBay’s and Amazon’s stock prices were ~$40; now, with the US stock market at an all time high, eBay is still only ~$59 and Amazon is ~$370.

    Ah, but what about all the stock splits, you say? Well, there has not been a stock split by either Amazon or eBay since 2005. But let’s then be fair and look at the value of both these entities since their IPOs, taking into account their stock splits:

    eBay: 3 x 2:1 and 1 x 3:1; ie 9 x $59; equates to a current sans-splits value of ~$531

    Amazon: 2 x 2:1 and 1 x 3:1; ie 7 x $370; equates to a current sans-splits value of ~$2590

    And, in that notice to the SEC, one of the only three “What Others Are Saying” complimentary quotes that the eBay Dept of Spin had been able to find—to try lift Johnny Ho’s spirits—credits the Ho with being responsible for eBay acquiring “PreyPal” (shades of Scott Thompson’s CV). eBay acquired “PreyPal” in 2002, some years before the destructive Ho arrived on the scene. Such a fundamental error says a lot about the lack of professionalism of the people at eBay, particularly those in the eBay Dept of Spin …

Add your comment.

Sponsored Links

Leaked: Apple's Next Smart Device
(Warning, it may shock you)
The secret is out... experts are predicting 458 million of these types of devices will be sold per year. 1 hyper-growth company stands to rake in maximum profit - and it's NOT Apple. Show me Apple's new smart gizmo!

DocumentId: 2878496, ~/Articles/ArticleHandler.aspx, 8/30/2015 8:19:40 AM

Report This Comment

Use this area to report a comment that you believe is in violation of the community guidelines. Our team will review the entry and take any appropriate action.

Sending report...

Asit Sharma

Midnight oil burners, unite! A CPA and CMA with a deep interest in business strategy, I also hold a Master's degree in English Literature from NYU -- my left brain and right brain spend their days locked in epic spitball battles. Follow me on Twitter for finance & a broad range of odds & ends.

Today's Market

updated 1 day ago Sponsored by:
DOW 16,643.01 -11.76 -0.07%
S&P 500 1,988.87 1.21 0.06%
NASD 4,828.33 15.62 0.32%

Create My Watchlist

Go to My Watchlist

You don't seem to be following any stocks yet!

Better investing starts with a watchlist. Now you can create a personalized watchlist and get immediate access to the personalized information you need to make successful investing decisions.

Data delayed up to 5 minutes

Related Tickers

8/28/2015 4:00 PM
EBAY $27.25 Up +0.15 +0.55%
eBay CAPS Rating: ****
EXPE $116.51 Down -0.94 -0.80%
Expedia, Inc. CAPS Rating: ***
MA $94.08 Up +0.03 +0.03%
MasterCard CAPS Rating: *****
TRIP $70.60 Up +0.26 +0.37%
TripAdvisor CAPS Rating: ****
V $72.46 Up +0.06 +0.08%
Visa CAPS Rating: ****