In May 2005, a Goldman Sachs
"We believe oil markets may have entered the early stages of what we have referred to as a 'super spike' period -- a multiyear trading band of oil prices high enough to meaningfully reduce energy consumption and re-create a spare capacity cushion, only after which will lower energy prices return."
How high did Goldman think was "high enough?" His mark was $105 per barrel. To date, we haven't yet hit that peak, but with oil prices now subsiding toward the $70-per-barrel range, voices are already emerging to challenge Goldman's doomsday scenario. The source of one of those voices: oil majorBP
In a recent interview with Germany's Der Spiegel, BP CEO Lord Browne implicitly challenged Goldman's year-old assertion, saying it "is very likely that oil prices will range in the medium term around an average of $40, and in the long run it could even be $25 to $30." Lord Browne cited such price-depressing catalysts as new oil finds in the Caspian Sea, untapped fields in Russia and West Africa, and improved rates of extraction from existing fields, all of which could act to increase supply even as high fuel costs depress consumer demand.
So is it time to short ExxonMobil
Even so, investors who believe that a CEO with decades of experience in the oil industry might know a thing or two about the cyclicality of the business should take heed of Lord Browne's words -- especially if their portfolios are overweighted in companies involved in expensive production projects like the Canadian oil sands. As my Foolish colleague Robert Aronen has mentioned, these projects will require oil to sell for at least $30 per barrel to remain profitable with existing technologies. With Lord Browne now warning that $30 is not inevitable, it's a race against time to see how quickly firms like Suncor
Further highly refined Foolishness:
Interested in discovering great international stock ideas? Pick up a copy of our Motley Fool International Report .
Fool contributor Rich Smith does not own shares of any company named above.