By Rick Aristotle Munarriz
February 22, 2008
It's the mother of all record deals, and it has nothing to do with Madonna inking a contract last year with Live Nation (NYSE: LYV).
In one of the largest transactions ever on eBay (Nasdaq: EBAY), a retiring record-shop owner has found a buyer for his collection of nearly 3 million vinyl albums, singles, eight-track tapes, and CDs. The winning bid came in a smidgeon above the $3 million starting price for the auction. The buyer has already put down a 10% deposit, so it doesn't appear to be a bogus purchase.
One could argue that a better strategy would have been to dispense with what the seller dubbed the "World's Largest Music Collection" in smaller lots. The record collector could have set up a Web page, paying pennies a click to generate leads through Google (Nasdaq: GOOG) or Yahoo! (Nasdaq: YHOO). He could have set up a merchant account through Amazon.com (Nasdaq: AMZN) and sold his wares piecemeal. Who knows -- maybe he tried these venues. If so, that only goes to prove eBay's effectiveness. Besides, those other methods may have proved too time-consuming for someone bent on cashing out and enjoying his golden years.
eBay should be shouting about this transcation from its Web-rendered rooftop, because it's a reminder that eBay works. The company has gone through a revolving door of marketing campaigns to help grow its domestic listings lately, but few things could as emotionally effective as seeing someone securing a retirement nest egg through using the service.
I already had one nasty brush with eBay's marketing arm, so I'm hesitant to even look in that direction again, but why isn't eBay riding this success? I have mixed feelings about the current "Shop Victoriously" ad campaign, which features ads such as an awards-show setting with a young lady winning some rickety telescope. Even if the items are largely unattainable, eBay would be better served by showing the exotic cars, Gulfstream jets, and this $3 million record collection in its ads to position itself as an aspirational experience. Imagine:
- "eBay, it can happen to you."
- "eBay. It works."
- "Dream an eBay dream."
Why not? eBay has tried to position itself as a fun place to shop, and it hasn't panned out. It has tried to position itself as a practical place to shop, and that hasn't panned out, either. Aim higher, eBay. There are records to be broken. Roughly 3 million of them, if this particular deal incurs a bumpy shipment.
Bid on this Foolishness:
What do the unfolding financial crisis and ongoing market volatility mean for your money? The Fool's here with answers. Get the best of our daily commentary and analysis in your inbox simply by entering your email address in the box below.