"It's just like cash." Investors may have heard that phrase from their investment advisors or financial planners, but as they're coming to find out, "just like" cash is still regrettably far from actual cash.
Palm (Nasdaq: PALM ) and MetroPCS (NYSE: PCS ) have been burned in recent weeks by their holdings in auction rate securities (ARS). These investments supposedly offered better rates than Treasury bills and money market accounts, and could be accessed just as readily. Chasing yields to get higher returns, these companies suddenly found that they couldn't get their money out when the credit markets seized. Just as fool's gold duped Gold Rush-era miners, ARS have tripped up modern day investors with their "fool's cash."
Auction-rate securities, as their name suggests, have their interest rates set at auction every few weeks. Until February, there had been a fairly robust market for such securities; if the occasional auction failed -- meaning no one was buying the paper -- the investment houses themselves would buy them. That all changed as credit became more dear. Now, when the auctions failed, the investment houses refused to buy them, either. Money that was supposed to be "just like cash" became worthless, at least in the near term, since the holders of these securities no longer were able to access those funds.
Like a bank that shuts its windows during a run, the credit markets slammed the door to investors who wanted their money back.
The damage done
Palm's $25 million writedown on ARS holdings inflated its third-quarter loss from $32 million to $57 million. MetroPCS took an $83 million loss on its own auction rate securities in its fourth quarter. Other companies are evaluating their own ARS situations.
Large corporations like these will probably get their money back, since the bonds underlying the securities typically have long-term maturities. Intuit (Nasdaq: INTU ) , for example, isn't taking any writedowns (as of late March), confident that the bonds carry top risk ratings, and that the auctions will eventually open. Bed Bath & Beyond (Nasdaq: BBBY ) , per its latest conference call, is taking only a minor charge for the auction rate securities it holds.
The same long-term outlook can't be said for individual investors who were put into these investments by advisors and planners. They believed that ARS were just like cash, but unlike a multimillion-dollar corporation, they don't have the same ability to wait out the credit crunch. Many of these people don't need the cash now -- they needed it yesterday.
Winners and losers
Some companies that sold their clients these investments have likely damaged their reputations. And when the thaw does occur, there will be a real run on cash from their assets under management. Firms like Nuveen Investments, BlackRock (NYSE: BLK ) , and Eaton Vance, for example, have some $40 billion tied up in ARS, all in all. Firms like Charles Schwab (Nasdaq: SCHW ) , which has practically nothing invested in the debt, might expect to benefit at those less fortunate companies' expense.
While many individuals relied upon their planners' advice to guide them, the same can't be said of Palm, Bed Bath & Beyond, and Monster Worldwide (Nasdaq: MNST ) . They should have seen this coming, but they left their money in place anyway. Now they find their expansion plans hindered, because they can't amass the resources to fund that growth.
Like the signs posted behind some registers at mom-and-pop stores note: "In God we trust; all others pay cash."
Further Foolishness that never loses value: