Wednesday, Hewlett-Packard
The means: Cash-on-hand
Tech companies are cash-rich: The 75 technology sector companies in the S&P 500 had aggregate net cash of $168 billion at the end of last year (by net cash, I'm referring to cash less all debt). Moreover, that cash is increasingly concentrated on the balance sheets of a small number of large companies: At the end of last year, the top eight companies in the index by net cash held more than four-fifths of the total for the sector -- the comparable figure for the same set of companies three years earlier was about two-thirds.
The firms with cash burning a hole in their pockets include Cisco Systems
Company |
Net Cash (Dec. 31, 2009) |
Net Cash (Dec. 31, 2006) |
---|---|---|
Cisco Systems |
$24.4 billion |
$5.8 billion |
Oracle |
$6.0 billion |
$1.9 billion |
Top 8 Tech Companies, by net cash |
$137.7 billion |
$98.4 billion |
Source: Capital IQ, a division of Standard & Poor's.
The motive: Slowing growth
Of course, companies could return that cash to shareholders; unfortunately, as I argued recently, the tech sector is a skinflint when it comes to paying dividends (on the whole -- there are exceptions). While the trend appears to be moving in the right direction, if given the choice, executives will (nearly) always favor expanding their dominion over paying out a dividend. Returning excess cash to shareholders is an admission that one cannot find a more productive use for it and that growth opportunities may be limited.
Nevertheless, as large tech companies grow and their businesses mature, they no longer fit the secular growth story that is associated with technology shares. Instead, their growth is increasingly tied to the state of the economy. At present, expected annualized earnings-per-share growth of the Technology Select Sector Fund ETF
When organic growth is no longer the low-hanging fruit it once was, acquisitions look more attractive to executives who feel pressure to sustain high earnings growth rates. Who are the targets in this environment? Here are two in the application/systems software sector.
Potential Target No. 1: Novell
In March, Novell
Potential Target No. 2: Sybase
Along with IBM and Oracle, Sybase
Sybase was mentioned as one of nine potential acquisition targets on an internal Oracle list from April 2003 (the list was released during an antitrust case against Oracle). Sybase is one of only three companies on that list that remain independent today (the other two are Cerner and Lawson Software); in the interim, Oracle managed to snap up three of the original nine.
Opportunity and risk for shareholders
I expect a boom in technology sector M&A transactions over the next twelve to eighteen months, during which the shareholders of target companies could earn substantial premiums. Shareholders of acquiring companies, on the other hand, need to be mindful of managements that could be overeager to spend their cash and/or equity. After all, it's very rare to find a CEO that is paid less to manage a bigger company, regardless of whether or not he/she has saddled his shareholders with the "winner's curse."
If your search for "growth stock-type" returns is contained to the U.S. stocks, you're starting out at a handicap to savvy investors. Tim Hanson explains how to make more in 2010.