Shares of E*TRADE (Nasdaq: ETFC ) fell on Thursday and Friday, shedding 8% of their value during the past two trading days.
The culprit was a secondary stock sale, in which Citadel Investment Group unloaded 172 million shares of the online discount broker. Forensic media reports, however, are dusting for the wrong fingerprints.
The common theory behind E*TRADE's sell-off is that as its largest stakeholder, Citadel may now begin unloading more of its stake. The sale wasn't dilutive -- since no new shares were issued -- but it does increase the public float. In other words, it may take a little more force on either side to move the stock in the future.
It's a fair thesis, but I think the bigger issue here is E*TRADE's diminishing viability as a buyout candidate. If Citadel felt that a buyout was coming soon at a decent premium, it wouldn't have sold off a chunk of its shares.
It's hard to buy E*TRADE as a buyout speculation now, even if it makes perfect sense for larger rivals TD AMERITRADE (Nasdaq: AMTD ) and Charles Scwhab (Nasdaq: SCHW ) to offset organic sluggishness with a timely purchase. In fact, TD AMERITRADE's CEO even hinted at sector consolidation during last month's conference call.
This doesn't mean that E*TRADE needs to be bought out. It was the only one of the three largest discounters to top Wall Street's first-quarter estimates last month. Its days of red ink appear to be ending. Analysts see E*TRADE breaking even during the second half of this year, before bouncing back with a profit of $0.07 a share come 2011.
Accounts, client assets, and margin receivables all inched sequentially higher during this year's freshman quarter.
E*TRADE also has a new CEO in former Citigroup (NYSE: C ) exec Steven Freiberg, who appears committed to turning the broker around for the long haul, instead of the short-term bonus glory of overseeing a corporate handoff.
Its recent move to gain shareholder approval for a reverse split -- following in the footsteps of AIG (NYSE: AIG ) , Coeur d'Alene Mines (NYSE: CDE ) , and Biglari Holdings (NYSE: BH ) , which have all moved higher since executing reverse splits last year -- is another sign that E*TRADE wants to give it a shot as an independent.
Citadel's partial sale is shaking out the speculators, but hopefully it creates a dinner bell for investors.