Emergency on the horizon?
RadioShack did manage to increase its third-quarter net income 23% to $46 million, or $0.37 per share. Revenue increased 6.2% to $1.05 billion, and same-store sales also increased by 6.2%.
Granted, these sound like impressive figures for a company facing numerous retail rivals. RadioShack must contend with Best Buy
However, investors need to remember that RadioShack's third-quarter results were bolstered by the mobile phone market, a fairly cyclical business. Read RadioShack's press release, and you'll notice that the only stand-out category in its table of sales drivers is the wireless category, up 25.8%.
Smartphones like Apple's
This same concern flares up periodically for RadioShack. Here's how tough things can get when the phone cycle goes on the downswing, as it did in 2005, and RadioShack's fallback plan of peddling batteries, antennas, and other electronics gadgetry just isn't enough to make up for tapped-out consumers who've already upgraded their mobiles. Some Fools even saw this previous plunge coming.
Danger: Speeding train
Even more foreboding for investors, RadioShack's stock has been on a tear this year, rising about 46% despite its lack of retail strength. A lot of its positive momentum owed to weird summertime rumors that it could be a takeover candidate. But we Fools couldn't imagine who on earth would consider shacking up with The Shack, and thus far, those rumors have unsurprisingly failed to pan out.
This leaves RadioShack investors with a pricey stock with a PEG ratio of 1.64. That might not sound horribly overpriced -- until you realize that this company might currently be on a temporary sales kick, with tough times ahead and formidable rivals just waiting to eat its lunch.
Best Buy seems like a far more stable stock, and a more defensive investment; better yet, its brand doesn't bring to mind the Commodore 64 and Pong. I'd argue that Best Buy's even cheap right now, with a PEG ratio of just 1.01.
Unfortunately, plenty of retailers are on the wrong track these days, flirting with potential train wreck status. If you want to track The Shack, why not add it to our My Watchlist function? In addition, sound off in the comment boxes below about whether RadioShack is about to crash and burn. Given today's plunging stock price, that process may have already begun.