London-based HSBC Holdings (NYSE: HBC ) is willing to admit what many banks may not be capable of even recognizing: U.S. housing is still weakening. HSBC's first-quarter earnings included an impairment charge of $400 million to reflect "a change to underlying assumptions" about the U.S. economy and housing market. Noting that HSBC always expected a "very slow" recovery, the CFO stated, "we expect it to be slower now."
It must be easier to fess up when North America accounts for only about 15% of revenue and 2% of pre-tax profit. That makes me want to delve into what HSBC has to say, particularly in light of the recent surprisingly large decline in home values. According to Zillow, in the first quarter, U.S. home values posted their largest decline since late 2008, falling 3% in the quarter and 1.1% in March.
It was just last month that Bank of America's (NYSE: BAC ) chief accounting officer described a 4% decline in home prices this year as a "shock" scenario. Oh, and he said such a scenario could result in another $1.5 billion in charges this year. But hey, what's another $1.5 big ones compared to the $2.9 billion pre-tax loss B of A reported for the last year?
There are more than a trillion dollars of residential mortgages sitting on the books of just a handful of large U.S. banks, including B of A, Wells Fargo (NYSE: WFC ) , Citigroup (NYSE: C ) , and JPMorgan Chase (NYSE: JPM ) . That's a lot of money susceptible to the same falling housing prices and economic conditions that convinced HSBC its mortgages are worth $400 million less than it thought just three months earlier.
Residential Mortgages ($M)
Residential Mortgages % of Total Capital
|Bank of America||$274,536||$229,094||120%|
Source: Capital IQ, a division of Standard & Poor's.
Early in 2007, HSBC was famously among the first to call the U.S. subprime crisis. That lends weight to its concern about weakness in U.S. housing. The big U.S. lenders are exposed to the same market dynamics, whether or not they'll admit it to investors or themselves. What's more, there's so much wiggle room nowadays in how banks value loans that you can't even trust their historical financials.
If you'd like some help figuring out what to do with bank stocks, you can get up-to-date news and analysis by clicking below to add companies to your Watchlist now:
- Add B of A to My Watchlist.
- Add Citigroup to My Watchlist.
- Add HSBC to My Watchlist.
- Add JPMorgan to My Watchlist.
- Add Wells Fargo to My Watchlist.
More on bank stocks: