Rule Breaking ideas don't get bigger than using space to bring high-speed broadband to 86% of Americans, but that's what upstart wireless network operator LightSquared proposes. There's just one problem. Delivering on that promise could mean disrupting global positioning systems, a new report says.
According to The Wall Street Journal, LightSquared and a trade group representing the GPS industry will present test results to the Federal Communications Commission that show the carrier's LTE signals can interfere with GPS systems positioned too closely to its towers. Both General Motors (NYSE: GM ) and Deere (NYSE: DE ) contributed data to the report, after GM's OnStar and Deere's GPS systems had signals disrupted by LightSquared's signal, the Journal says.
Frequency is the issue. LightSquared is building its network using old satellite frequencies that operate near GPS bands, which leads to comingling. But that's only part of the problem. Unlike GPS, LightSquared doesn't broadcast directly from satellite. Instead, its space-based signals are amplified and then routed from some 40,000 ground-based cell towers. Comingling becomes interference around those towers, as stronger LTE signals overwhelm neighboring GPS broadcasts, the Journal reports.
The news must come as welcome relief for Clearwire (Nasdaq: CLWR ) , a land-based competitor whose CLEAR network is based largely on the embattled WiMAX standard. A cash crunch and management turmoil have hurt that business in recent months, just as the rival LTE standard is turning heads for performing at heretofore unprecedented speeds in some metro areas. Both AT&T (NYSE: T ) and Verizon (NYSE: VZ ) are building national LTE networks.
For its part, LightSquared is expected to tell the FCC that interference issues can be fixed via filtering both its network equipment and GPS devices. These filters would, in theory, differentiate signals in order to reduce interference.
LightSquared could also choose to use just a portion of the frequency assigned to its LTE network. The added spectrum distance would -- again, in theory -- reduce interference. In many ways, it's the same principle that governs your home wireless network. If you and your neighbor both operate Wi-Fi routers on channel 1, you'll likely interfere with each other. Move from channel 1 to channel 11, and the static should disappear. The downside? Such a solution would lower bandwidth.
Whatever the outcome, LightSquared's deployment could face delays and crimp plans to begin broadcasting to customers in the first half of next year. Clearwire could use the breathing room. Do you agree? Disagree? Let us know using the comments box below.
And if you're looking for more stocks poised to profit from President Obama's plan to bathe the nation in broadband, try this free report. In it, my Foolish colleagues identify a top-rated broadband equipment supplier that has yet to take off. Click here to get your copy of the report -- it's 100% free.