The Web is abuzz with reports that Hewlett-Packard (NYSE: HPQ ) is about to dump WebOS even as it moves to keep the PC division that former CEO Leo Apotheker had hoped to spin off.
"HP objectively evaluated the strategic, financial, and operational impact of spinning off" the Personal Systems Group," new chief Meg Whitman said in a statement issued last week. "It's clear after our analysis that keeping PSG within HP is right for customers and partners, right for shareholders, and right for employees. ... HP is committed to PSG, and together we are stronger."
What she didn't say is what role WebOS would play in powering PCs, tablets, and smartphones. The Guardian newspaper and others are reporting that it won't play a role and will instead be dumped because HP can't find a buyer. Talk about a turnaround.
Can I say "I told you so"?
Last year at this time I argued that HP was worth shorting because it wouldn't be able to generate enough value from its purchase of WebOS, especially in light of competition from Apple (Nasdaq: AAPL ) and handset suppliers using the free Android operating system. A $2.1 billion commitment to wrest 3PAR from the hands of Dell (Nasdaq: DELL ) would also complicate the company's profit picture.
"In each case, HP badly overpaid. Just as it has with most every move it's made lately," I wrote at the time. The stock is down more than 38% over the past year, badly trailing the 5% gain racked up by the Dow Jones Industrial Average (INDEX: ^DJI) over the same period.
Now HP is apparently thinking about abandoning WebOS, confirming my fears and resulting what could be $1 billion or more in writeoffs related to goodwill and intangible assets. (HP recorded $879 million in goodwill, $344 million in intangible assets, and $80 million in in-process research and development on its balance sheet at the time of the Palm deal, according to SEC filings.)
Only the most Pollyanna-ish of optimists would expect short-term earnings growth knowing all this. If anything, Whitman has a huge amount of restructuring work to do.
Please bring back the "Invent" sign
More than anything else, the apparent end of WebOS means that HP has neither the time nor the resources to invest in blue-sky measures that could alter the balance of power in tech's biggest markets.
Instead, Whitman is to today's HP what Michael Dell was to his namesake company back in 2007: a cost-cutter with a purpose. The whole thing makes HP's most recent tagline, "iInvent," seem like longing for an identity lost with the passing of Bill Hewlett and David Packard.
Where the company goes from here is anyone's guess, but judging from Whitman's comments and the rumor mill we can expect two things:
- HP will continue to make computers and other consumer gear.
- Despite earlier hopes, WebOS won't power these devices.
Whose software will? Easy: Microsoft (Nasdaq: MSFT ) . Mr. Softy, which is already teaming with Nokia (NYSE: NOK ) to bring Windows smartphones to the U.S. and China, could just as easily work out a licensing deal for "Touch" brand HP handsets and tablets. The pieces are already in place for HP to sell Windows PCs as it always has.
Don't forget the "thank you" card, Mr. Ballmer
HP's loss would be Microsoft's gain, in other words. Welcome news for a company whose Windows franchise is already under attack from Google (Nasdaq: GOOG ) and a host of other cloud-computing upstarts. Do you agree? Disagree? Please let us know what you think using the comments box below.
And if you're interested in more Internet stock ideas, try this free video that digs into the details of the cloud computing revolution that's threatening both HP and Microsoft. You'll come away smarter and with a winning stock idea from our Motley Fool Rule Breakers scorecard. Watch now -- it's 100% free.