Forget about worrying about a cheery consensus -- what about a gloomy one?
When it comes to Google’s
Nexus Q. Source: Google.
The Nexus Q includes a built-in amp for high-quality audio streaming, but to a point that’s a bit unnecessary for the vast majority of consumers, who may not fully appreciate "audiophile-grade" tunes. In addition, it’s closed off to Google’s own ecosystem of Android devices that can control it, and Google Play content that it can stream, in a move that makes it a more proprietary product than anything offered even by the king of walled gardens: Apple
A gloomy consensus
Just about every review you can find so far on the device recommends avoiding it, despite a few bright spots, such as its industrial design. Here’s just a taste:
- The Verge: "With so many buggy features and functionality gaps, the biggest question about the Nexus Q is who it's intended for. Other boxes on the market offer more functionality at lower price points…"
- PCMag: "Its lack of any functionality outside of Google Play and YouTube seems a criminal underuse of a device that is both expensive and overbuilt. … As it stands, the Nexus Q is simply an overpriced toy for streaming music and, if you really like YouTube videos or buy a lot of movies and TV shows on Google Play, video."
- The New York Times: "The Google Nexus Q Is Baffling … It’s wildly overbuilt for its incredibly limited functions, and far too expensive."
- CNET: "The Google Nexus Q isn't an attractive product for consumers. It's too expensive and really doesn't do that much, even if the quirky hardware is nice."
- TechRadar: "That's a lot to pay for a device that essentially does less than competing solutions. Right now, TechRadar is hard pressed to see any reason why a regular user would plunk down that much money for a device that does... well... so little."
- Gizmodo: "Should I buy it? No."
I was only able to find one positive review on the device, from SlashGear, but that site’s buy recommendation came with a rather pricey and specific requisite to qualify: "Is it worth $299 from our perspective? If you’re the sort of person who spent $199 on your smartphone and $499 on your tablet when you bought them both in the past year, then yes, the Nexus Q is worth every penny."
Stacking up (poorly)
The Apple TV costs a third of the price, and taps into third-party content services like Netflix, among others, and comes with its own control so it doesn’t require a separate iOS device to work. Roku set-top boxes are available for anywhere from $50 to $100 for a high-end model.
At $299, it costs as much as a top-of-the-line Microsoft
The Nexus Q can only be controlled by an Android device. Content isn’t streamed directly from any device locally but, rather, from Google’s cloud, so the Android gadget that’s required to call the shots is little more than a remote control with a fancy screen, and it’s the only choice.
Is there a set-top sphere market?
Content sales remain insignificant to Big G, so all the effort put into the Nexus Q may not be particularly fruitful. Its miscellaneous other revenue segment was less than 4% of sales last quarter at $420 million, and even this is primarily derived from "enterprise products, as well as our display advertising management services to advertisers, ad agencies, and publishers," with no mention of content sales.
In addition, the set-top box (or sphere) market itself isn’t nearly as large as the smartphone market that Android now dominates. Google’s Nexus Q is a Nexus mistake.
Google should instead focus its efforts on international sales, which are booming at 54% of sales last quarter. Yet, the search giant isn’t the only American company dominating the world -- here are three more. These domestic heavyweights are taking lessons learned stateside, and capitalizing abroad. Grab a copy of this special free report to learn more.
Also, if you’re interested in some exclusive analysis on another tech company looking to shake up consumer living rooms, check out our new premium research report on Apple. In it, our top tech analyst goes through the most important points Apple investors have to know. Click here to learn more.