Why GM Is Already Losing in China

October was another solid month for General Motors (NYSE: GM  ) in China. Sales were up 14.3% over year-ago numbers, enough to give GM its best October ever in the Middle Kingdom.

GM leads the Chinese auto market, though lately it has run neck-and-neck with Volkswagen (NASDAQOTH: VLKAY  ) , which has a huge presence in the country with several strong-selling models.

The race between VW and GM for Chinese sales supremacy will be interesting to watch, though it really shouldn't matter all that much to investors – both are posting big sales numbers and solid gains.

But in one respect, GM has already fallen far behind its German rival in China.

The secret to VW's big profits in China
Ponder this: While GM outsold VW in China in the first half of 2012, it sure didn't out-earn its German rival. VW earned 1.8 billion euros (about $2.3 billion) from its Chinese joint ventures through June. GM? About $700 million.

So what accounts for that huge difference?

Here's the difference: Product mix. About half of the vehicles GM sells in China are Wulings, cheap and simple minivans often used by small businesses in interior China. GM sells lots of them, but because they're cheap, profits per vehicle are small – and that's before GM splits the earnings with its joint-venture partners.

VW has joint venture partners too, but its product mix in China is much more profitable. Of particular note, VW is selling about 35,000 Audis a month in the Middle Kingdom, where the luxury brand has become the favored ride of the wealthy and powerful.

That's only around 15% of VW's total sales in China, but it's enough to deliver an outsized profit. Audi sales worldwide are dwarfed by sales of VW-branded vehicles, but Audi still accounted for 46% of VW's profit in the second quarter.

Clearly, Audi's margins – and profitability – are huge. Just as clearly, GM CEO Dan Akerson would dearly love a piece of that action. But sales of GM's own luxury brand, Cadillac, have been tiny in China – just a few thousand a month.

That's why GM is planning some big changes for Cadillac.

A new look for a very old brand
GM's market research has shown that Chinese customers are willing to consider Cadillac, but many find the company's designs to be too bold. GM's current design paradigm for Cadillac, which it calls "Art & Science," is inspired by stealth military planes – sharp lines and jagged edges. Chinese consumers seem to respond much better to cars with smoother shapes, like... well, like Audi's current designs.

Cadillac has already come a long way in recent years. Its newest models, like the small ATS sedan, have largely closed the perceived quality gap that long existed between Cadillac and the German luxury brands. That's a huge step forward: Cadillac, long treated as a tired joke, is now being taken much more seriously by sophisticated buyers. But Cadillac needs more great models – and it needs styling that will play well globally.

Those are both on the way, with the ATS (and last year's stunning Ciel concept car) showing the first hints of a softer-edged style for Cadillac. Akerson wants Cadillac's sales in China to equal its sales in the U.S. by mid-decade, and he's planning to invest heavily to get there. GM is said to have an overhauled, larger version of its midsized CTS sedan on the way, as well as a new large "flagship" to compete with cars like Audi's A8. And the brand got a new chief last month.

GM's not the only one with this idea
Like GM, rival Ford (NYSE: F  ) is investing in its own long-neglected luxury brand, Lincoln, with an eye on China's booming market for luxury cars. Ford just appointed its well-regarded marketing chief, Jim Farley, as Lincoln's new boss. And the company has a new lineup of Lincolns on the way, marked by – you guessed it – smooth-edged styling that should play quite well in China.

But the stakes are arguably bigger for GM. Ford is an up-and-comer in China, but GM is an established market leader. Its big investment in Cadillac is likely to be taken seriously in China – if the cars are good enough. We shall see.

It's true that decades of mismanagement of General Motors led to a painful bankruptcy in 2009, but it emerged a leaner, stronger company. GM's turnaround, however, is still a work in progress. Investors around the world are wondering if GM has what it takes to reclaim its former glory. I've put together a brand-new premium research report telling you what you need to know about GM and its turnaround. If you own or are thinking about owning GM, you don't want to miss this report. Click here now to get started.


Read/Post Comments (2) | Recommend This Article (1)

Comments from our Foolish Readers

Help us keep this a respectfully Foolish area! This is a place for our readers to discuss, debate, and learn more about the Foolish investing topic you read about above. Help us keep it clean and safe. If you believe a comment is abusive or otherwise violates our Fool's Rules, please report it via the Report this Comment Report this Comment icon found on every comment.

  • Report this Comment On November 13, 2012, at 2:56 PM, Jason87467 wrote:

    I find it amusing what writers say about GM. If GM has a little sputter, oops they are going to go bankrupt again. What is it, is it because people got burnt by GM years ago? The Volt has a fire three weeks after a severe crash test, oops the Volts are catching fire all over the place. Now, their is a little slow down in China, oops GM is losing in China. Man, give me a break! I'm siick and tired of hearing how bad GM is. Could it be VW is making more profits, not from it's operation in China, but from the cars sold in the rest of the world? Ah! that's the answer.

  • Report this Comment On November 14, 2012, at 12:27 PM, TMFMarlowe wrote:

    @Jason87467: I write about GM almost every day, and I don't say any of those things. The point here is that VW is making a LOT more money than GM in China, GM knows that, and GM is taking steps to try to up its game.

    I'm not down on GM. I'm critical of some of the moves they've made, because I think they could be doing a better job in some areas -- but I own GM stock and believe that the company is, broadly speaking, on the right track.

    I also own a Cadillac CTS-V, by the way, so I've put my money where my virtual mouth is in more ways than one.

    Thanks for reading.

    John Rosevear

Add your comment.

DocumentId: 2108246, ~/Articles/ArticleHandler.aspx, 4/19/2014 9:21:41 PM

Report This Comment

Use this area to report a comment that you believe is in violation of the community guidelines. Our team will review the entry and take any appropriate action.

Sending report...


Advertisement