If the stock market were a social endeavor, Apple (NASDAQ: AAPL ) would be the nouveau riche, or new money. While the company has $137 billion in the bank, this sum has been built up in a staggeringly fast time. In the past year alone, Apple has generated more than $47 billion in free cash flow.
In an article comparing Apple with ExxonMobil, its big-oil nemesis for the crown of the world's most valuable company, I noted how Exxon is in a different category than Apple, having returned a staggering $265 billion to shareholders over the past decade. More than $75 billion of that amount was in dividends alone. Exxon's the old money, having existed in one form or another since 1882 and having a history of 30 straight years of dividend raises.
Yet with a very slight decline in earnings per share last quarter and a forecast for a larger fall-off in earnings next quarter, Apple is finding investors clamoring for it to accept its new reality of lower growth and act like its old-money peers. So let's look at Apple's recent history at giving capital back to its shareholders, and what it can do with its $137 billion across the next year.
How will Apple use its cash?
Simply put, as companies generate operating cash flow, they have five main options for how to use it.
- Spend it on capital expenditures.
- Use it for acquisitions.
- Return the money to shareholders as a dividend.
- Buy back their own shares.
- Hoard it.
How Apple's dividends stack up
Apple first announced its dividend on March 19 of last year. The company announced a dividend of $2.65 per quarter, with those dividends beginning in Apple's September quarter. Along with its dividends, Apple announced a $10 billion share-repurchase program that started last quarter. With these two programs combined, Apple anticipated returning $45 billion to shareholders across three years' time.
At the time of Apple's dividend announcement, it was a solid step in the right direction, but nothing groundbreaking. Apple's dividend of $10.60 per year was about a 1.8% yield of its then-share price of $595 per share. As Apple's share price has dropped, its yield has risen, though it still trails many big-tech peers.
|Company||Dividend Yield (%)||Payout Ratio (%)||Annual Dividend Payout|
|Intel (NASDAQ: INTC )||4.3%||42%||~$4.5 billion|
|Google (NASDAQ: GOOGL )||0||0||$0|
Apple's absolute amount of dividend payments trumps its big tech peers aside from Google, a company that has yet to institute a dividend of any kind. Because of Apple's significantly larger market cap than other tech companies, its dividend yield is much smaller. With only a 24% payout ratio, there's plenty of room left for the company to increase its payouts.
Are share repurchases the way to go?
Other than dividends, the other part of Apple's announced $45 billion plan to return capital to shareholders was a $10 billion share-repurchase program. If used correctly, share repurchases can be an effective tool.
The problem with Apple's repurchase program is that it simply isn't significant enough. If averaged over three years, the repurchase program buys back $3.3 billion per year. That's about 7.5 million out of Apple's existing 939.1 million shares outstanding.
However, Apple awarded $1.7 billion in stock-based compensation last fiscal year. That number surged from the $879 million Apple awarded in fiscal 2010. Apple still pays much less in stock-based compensation than a competitor such as Microsoft or Google. (Google has recorded $2.7 billion worth of stock-based compensation in the past year.)
Apple itself noted this situation in commencing its repurchase plan, noting its "primary objective of neutralizing the impact of dilution from future employee equity grants and employee stock purchase programs."
More repurchases on the way
The problem with Apple's announcement of its dividend and repurchase program was that the company set the timeframe over too long a period. If Apple held free cash flow around $50 billion over the coming three years and paid out its full announced $45 billion in dividends and share repurchases, it'd have more than $250 billion in the bank.
Apple surely realizes this coming "problem," however, and I think an astute investor would realize the company is already taking steps in the direction of upping its share-repurchase commitments, even if CFO Peter Oppenheimer has maintained that the company is comfortable with its current $45 billion commitment for the time being.
- Last quarter, the first quarter of Apple's $10 billion repurchase program, the company spent $1.95 billion in repurchases. That's already 20% of the purchase commitment in a single quarter. Front-loading repurchases in this fashion seems to indicate that the company will quickly blow through its $10 billion in repurchase commitments.
- In giving guidance for the coming quarter, Apple used almost every metric necessary to come up with its earnings per share (EPS) -- revenues, gross margins, operating expenses, the amount of interest its cash will collect, and a tax rate. Yet despite this trail of bread crumbs leading to its EPS, Apple didn't give an EPS. The only major area needed to calculate EPS that Apple didn't give is its share count. Simply put, Apple seems undecided on how many shares it'll purchase in the upcoming quarter.
Consider that Microsoft has been aggressively repurchasing its stock across the past decade, with little to show for it. However, it predominantly did so when the company wasn't cheap. Microsoft purchased an astounding $27.6 billion of its stock in fiscal 2007, a year when its average P/E was between 22 and 23 times earnings. The surest way to burn a cash hoard is to buy back a company's overpriced stock.
If Apple were to accelerate its share-repurchase program, it'd avoid the trap of past companies. It wouldn't start aggressively buying when the company was at 20 times earnings or more; it'd be when Apple was at a P/E of around 10 or less.
No discussion of Apple's cash hoard would be complete without noting that $94 billion of its cash is held overseas and subject to additional repatriation taxes if the company wants to get more aggressive about returning capital. Yet with Apple still getting about 40% of its sales from the United States, that could leave about $20 billion a year in cash flow from America alone. Given that Apple currently spends only about $13 billion a year between dividends and share repurchases, the path forward looks clear.
It's time for Apple to get off its wallet and start being more strategic repurchasing its shares. Let's hope the initial signs from the company lead to the right decision: increasing its share repurchase allocation and getting more strategic with its cash.
Scared by Apple's plunge? We have expert advice for you.
As traders dumped their Apple shares for a second straight day last week, will you have the resolve to hold your ground -- or will you possibly buy more? Emotions aside, Apple's growth story is far from over, and the company still has massive opportunities ahead. We've outlined them right here in The Motley Fool's premium Apple research service, and it may give you the courage to be greedy when others are fearful. If you're looking for some guidance on Apple's prospects, get started by clicking here.