Are William Shatner and Cheap Plane Tickets Gone Forever?

The recent announcement that American Airlines (UNKNOWN: AAMRQ.DL  ) and US Airways (NYSE: LCC  ) plan to merge has sparked fears that consolidation will lead to less competition and higher airfares. Assuming the merger is approved, more than 80% of domestic capacity will be controlled by just four airlines: the new American, United Continental (NYSE: UAL  ) , Delta Air Lines (NYSE: DAL  ) , and Southwest Airlines (NYSE: LUV  ) . All four will have been created by mergers within the past five years. Delta started the most recent round of consolidation by merging with Northwest, followed several years later by the merger of United and Continental and Southwest's acquisition of AirTran.

This history of airline consolidation means we have a substantial amount of evidence about the effects of airline mergers on airfares. The days of so-cheap-you-can't-believe-it airfares are probably gone. However, that's a good thing, because irrationally priced airfares have resulted in trips to bankruptcy court by numerous airlines over the past three decades. Yet surprisingly, airfares have been quite stable in the face of rising oil prices since 2000. Airline mergers (and bankruptcies) have generated significant cost savings over time, allowing airlines to become profitable without raising fares beyond historical inflation-adjusted levels.

Stability in a sea of change
Since 1995, the average domestic airfare has risen from $288 to $367. The increase hasn't been linear: Airfares spiked from 1996 until 2000, before dropping off for much of the next decade. Since 2009, airfares have been on the rise again.

Source: U.S. Department of Transportation

However, if we adjust for inflation, it turns out that airfares have declined since 1995. Q3 2012 airfares averaged just $243 in 1995 dollars, down more than 15% since 1995 and down more than 18% from the inflation-adjusted peak in 2000.

There is a catch, though. Department of Transportation statistics include only the base airfare. Non-ticket charges such as baggage fees aren't included. Since airlines have been charging baggage fees for only about five years, the DOT statistics understate the increase in airline prices. On the other hand, the DOT also provides statistics on the percentage of airline revenue derived from ticket sales. Working backwards from this information, it appears that the average ticket price last summer including new fees was $294 in 1995 dollars, implying that fees for checked baggage, seat selection, and the like average around $50 -- roughly the cost of checking one bag for a round-trip flight on most airlines.

At $294, the average inflation-adjusted airfare is still slightly below the 2000 peak of $297, but slightly higher than the 1995 level of $288. Given the turmoil that has shaken the industry in the past decade, the long-term stability of inflation-adjusted airfares is surprising.

Rising oil: no problem
It's particularly remarkable to look at the trajectory of average airfares from 2007 to 2012. The average price of Brent crude skyrocketed over that period, from $72.44 in 2007 to $111.63 in 2012 (with a violent dip in 2009). Since jet fuel is the biggest cost item for most airlines, it wouldn't be surprising to see airfares rising in tandem with fuel prices. However, nominal airfares increased just 12% from Q3 of 2007 to Q3 of 2012, even as the price of Brent crude rose by more than 50%.

Q3 Airfares vs. Average Annual Oil Prices, 2007-2012

Oil price data courtesy of the EIA.

This data again leaves out the substantial increase in non-ticket revenues, such as baggage fees. However, even if we add approximately $50 to the average ticket price to cover baggage fees, the average fare would still have risen only half as quickly as oil prices. In other words, recent increases in airfares, including bag fees, have more to do with rising oil prices than airline mergers.

What's going on?
While airline mergers have resulted in capacity rationalization over the past few years, it hasn't caused airfares to rise. The main effect of capacity rationalization has been preventing further decreases in inflation-adjusted airfares. Airlines benefit from mergers through cost savings and new route opportunities, which can be quite substantial: American and US Airways expect to see $1 billion in merger synergies over the next few years.

However, in the old hypercompetitive airline industry, airlines would have given away these synergy benefits to customers by reducing airfares in the hope of gaining market share. Today, airline executives are being smarter about pricing. They're using cost synergies to offset fuel price increases and letting the rest flow through to the bottom line. Meanwhile, average airfares have generally remained steady, after adjusting for inflation.

Conclusion
The days of the ridiculously cheap airfare may be gone. Airline executives now realize that pricing below cost is a disastrous strategy. However, consolidation hasn't made plane tickets unaffordable. Adjusting for inflation, base fares are substantially below 1995 levels; after accounting for new fees for checked baggage and other amenities, inflation-adjusted airfares are only slightly higher than 1995 levels. Considering the substantial rise in oil prices since then, this is a very good outcome for consumers.

Oil prices have been the bane of airline stocks for the past five years. If you're looking to profit from the current high oil price environment, check out The Motley Fool's "3 Stocks for $100 Oil." For free access to this special report, simply click here now.


Read/Post Comments (2) | Recommend This Article (1)

Comments from our Foolish Readers

Help us keep this a respectfully Foolish area! This is a place for our readers to discuss, debate, and learn more about the Foolish investing topic you read about above. Help us keep it clean and safe. If you believe a comment is abusive or otherwise violates our Fool's Rules, please report it via the Report this Comment Report this Comment icon found on every comment.

  • Report this Comment On March 30, 2013, at 6:28 PM, herky46q wrote:

    Air travel is a lot of money only until you think of the alternative in time, money and safety. It is a miracle that we should never take for granted.

  • Report this Comment On March 31, 2013, at 3:58 AM, caffeinefree51 wrote:

    We, the employees of the airlines have been subsidizing cheap tickets forever. I haven't seen a raise going on 8 years. Not true, for my airline CEO, who upon the 2010 merger got a nice hefty 33% pay raise. The same goes for his top management team. Also, throw in huge merger signing bonus, and substantial bonuses and stock options, and the ones that are prospering are the fliers and the management teams of airlines.

    Look at Horton's scam on his employees at American. Took AMR into BK, slashed contracts (Frank Lorenzo ring a bell?), and then succeeded the airline to USAIR. He walks away from his post with a cool $9.5 million in cash, and another $9.5 million in stock grants. Yep, and passengers wonder why airline service is in the dumps these days. Airline personel are tired of the shams going on, just like other industries in the US.

Add your comment.

Sponsored Links

Leaked: Apple's Next Smart Device
(Warning, it may shock you)
The secret is out... experts are predicting 458 million of these types of devices will be sold per year. 1 hyper-growth company stands to rake in maximum profit - and it's NOT Apple. Show me Apple's new smart gizmo!

DocumentId: 2336939, ~/Articles/ArticleHandler.aspx, 9/17/2014 12:00:48 AM

Report This Comment

Use this area to report a comment that you believe is in violation of the community guidelines. Our team will review the entry and take any appropriate action.

Sending report...


Advertisement