Last year was rough for much of the restaurant industry, but fast-food giant McDonald's (NYSE: MCD ) had seen considerably tougher challenges before. It has thrived through countless recessions by focusing on its value menu to drive new and repeat customers into its restaurants, modifying its menu to suit ever-changing palates, and remodeling its restaurants to appeal to both family-oriented and younger crowds.
However, last year wasn’t a particular rough year for the overall economy, yet McDonald's turned in one of the year’s most disappointing performances on record, reporting its first same-store sales decline in nine years in November. McDonald’s blamed a weakening economy which constrained consumers' pocketbooks, increasing competition, and European weakness for the shortfall.
A lot of people believe that McDonald's struggles will only be temporary given its global appeal. McDonald's introduced healthier eating habits with salads and the McWrap, revolutionized fast-food dining with its Value Menu, and has been at the forefront of nearly every major innovation in the fast-food industry over the past three decades. But has anyone considered that maybe McDonald's is losing its innovative touch?
From innovator to emulator
McDonald’s CEO Don Thompson, who has been on the job for only a few months now, conducted an interview with CNBC on Friday, where he answered questions regarding the direction his company is headed. Thompson keyed in on some pivotal strategies that he thought would give McDonald's the opportunity to succeed including the introduction mobile payments, creating even healthier food selections to target millennials, developing a delivery service, and potentially changing its menu to serve breakfast all day.
The reaction among most investors and Wall Street analysts to Thompson's interview is that McDonald's has the plan to succeed. My reaction is that Thompson and McDonald's are on the path to emulation instead of innovation.
McDonald's has severely lagged many of its peers when it comes to the targeting of millennials, both in terms of offering mobile payments as an option and with regard to healthier eating options. While McDonald's was busy testing eBay's mobile-payment system PayPal in 30 of its French restaurants last year, Starbucks (NASDAQ: SBUX ) locked up a contract to install Square's mobile readers in 7,000 of its locations.
In terms of healthier eating options, McDonald's is finding increased competition from the likes of Starbucks and Chipotle Mexican Grill (NYSE: CMG ) . Although McDonald's is doing an admirable job of bringing salads and wraps to fast-food consumers, Starbucks and Chipotle can offer conveniently quick, organic, natural, and/or antibiotic-free sources of meat, fruits, and veggies to customers. With McDonald's content to stay the course and both Starbucks and Chipotle stepping up their game, a younger crowd of eaters has made the move away from the Golden Arches toward these two brands.
Similarly, a delivery service in the states could be a novel idea if Burger King Worldwide (NYSE: BKW ) hadn't already beaten McDonald's to the punch. In early 2012, Burger King began testing a delivery service in Washington D.C., using specialized thermal packaging that keeps hot food hot, and cold drinks cold, during the delivery process. Allowing consumers to order nearly the full gambit of items you can get in the restaurant and placing a minimum order price to ensure margins are met has allowed Burger King to one-up its peers. Since this pilot program, Burger King has expanded it to Houston, Miami, and New York, and announced just last week that Los Angeles, Chicago, and San Francisco are up next.
A more expansive menu that allowed breakfast to be served all day could mean bigger profits for McDonald's -- but let’s face it: That's really been Jack in the Box's (NASDAQ: JACK ) territory since day one. While Jack in the Box has made no qualms about emulating McDonald's interior redesigns and menu expansion in order to boost its own sales, it's been the company's promotion of its all-day breakfasts that make it one of the fastest growing fast-food restaurants in the United States.
Where's the beef, Don?
Looking back at Don Thompson's interview with CNBC, I didn't really see a CEO who brought anything new to the table. All I saw was a CEO who alluded to the fact that there are weaknesses in McDonald's stay-the-course strategy that its peers caught onto quicker than it did.
Now, don't misconstrue what I'm saying as I'm in no way predicting the end of McDonald's dominance as a large-scale restaurant chain. What I am saying is that its outperformance relative to its peers may be a thing of the past as it takes its turn in the emulator's chair and watches as its peers innovate their way to big gains.
If shareholders want McDonald's Golden Arches to shine once again, they'll need CEO Don Thompson and his board to generate unique ideas that'll set McDonald's apart from the pack. At the moment, there's not enough to differentiate McDonald's from the pack, and that's a scary scenario if you’re currently holding shares of McDonald's in your portfolio.
Can these arches stay golden?
McDonald's turned in a dismal year in 2012, underperforming the broader market by 25%. Looking ahead, can the Golden Arches reclaim its throne atop the restaurant industry, or will this unsettling trend continue? Our top analyst weighs in on McDonald's future in a recent premium report on the company. Click here now to find out whether a buying opportunity has emerged for this global juggernaut.