First Solar (NASDAQ: FSLR ) has been leading the solar industry for more than a decade but it's in a tough strategic position at the moment as the industry shifts into a new growth phase. The company's panels aren't as efficient as rivals and massive project developments that have driven earnings over the past few years are now few and far between.
The company's systems backlog has fallen from $9.4 billion to end 2011 to $8.0 billion after Q1 2013, which isn't a good sign because the company is almost 100% reliant on systems. The high-margin systems that come with projects signed years ago will also likely evaporate as First Solar competes on cost per watt against SunPower (NASDAQ: SPWR ) , Canadian Solar (NASDAQ: CSIQ ) , and others. But the biggest challenge is the company's panels.
Falling behind where the growth is
First Solar's product is not as efficient as competitors and now it doesn't have the cost advantage it once had. In fact, many Chinese producers are selling panels for less than the $0.69 per watt First Solar is now producing its panels for. We can debate all day how important efficiency is in solar panels, but when cost per watt is the same a buyer will go with the more efficient panel every time.
The effect can be seen in the growth markets that have driven the industry over the past year. Canadian Solar and SunPower both reported better than expected earnings in the first quarter after seeing strong demand in Japan and the U.S. residential market. These two markets are widely viewed both as great growth markets and consistent performers that won't ebb and flow the way the market in Germany or utility-scale projects have. First Solar has virtually no exposure to either of these markets because efficiency becomes more important as balance of system costs go up and space becomes constrained, like it is in Japan or on a rooftop.
That forced First Solar to buy start-up TetraSun, which has technology it thinks will make high-efficiency panels at similar costs to Chinese panels right now. But this will take millions in investment and comes with technology and industry risk because others will be investing in new technology as well.
Foolish bottom line
There's no doubt that First Solar has one of the best balance sheets with over $1 billion in cash, but strategically its position is faltering. The company can't add enough projects to make up for what it's building and it isn't growing in areas where the market is growing. That leaves this former giant falling behind in the solar industry.
The solar industry is leading a revival in U.S. energy production but it isn't the only industry transforming energy. The Motley Fool is offering a comprehensive look at three energy companies set to soar as U.S. energy production expands. To find out which three companies are spreading their wings, check out the special free report, "3 Stocks for the American Energy Bonanza." Don't miss out on this timely opportunity; click here to access your report -- it's absolutely free.