The good news: Facebook (NASDAQ:FB) turned fabulously profitable in the just-reported second quarter thanks to a redesigned ad flow on mobile Facebook apps. Revenues jumped 23% from the first quarter to the second. Last year, the same comparison yielded just an 11% seasonal gain. The year-ago quarter's net loss turned into a tidy profit.
In response, share prices jumped more than 30% overnight and sit very close to all-time highs that were set during the stock's IPO.
The ugly news: The good news may not last very long. Facebook had better dial back the ad blitz if it wants those disgruntled users to stick around.
It's a high-wire balancing act between monetization and user satisfaction. Lean too far in one direction, and you won't make any money from those billions of page views. Err too far in the other direction, and those profitable page views will melt away as unhappy users find greener pastures.
Don't think it couldn't happen. Facebook is not too big to fail. Unless the company strikes that crucial balance before it's too late, we could very well see another mass exodus from one leading social network to another.
Facebook itself killed MySpace by launching a better service in the same genre. Before that, MySpace trampled all over social pioneer Friendster in much the same way.
And there are Facebook alternatives waiting to crush the current king at the first opportunity, believe it or not.
Chief among these is Google (NASDAQ:GOOGL) and its Google+ service, which benefits from tight integration with the world's most popular search engine as well as with leading video site YouTube.
Twitter sings a somewhat different tune but can fill many of the functions of a Facebook account. LinkedIn (NYSE:LNKD) is basically Facebook for corporate users and could very well expand into the consumer side of things if it wanted to.
All of these alternatives offer fewer ads and a cleaner experience than Facebook. LinkedIn ties with Facebook at the least satisfied end of the ACSI survey; everyone else runs miles ahead. Yes, even the much-maligned Google+ "ghost town." And even LinkedIn reports fewer ad-taint complaints than Facebook.
That's why I'd take this week's Facebook share-price pop as a temporary boost, and not as a sustainable clean bill of health. The service currently leans far too heavy on the monetization side of the fence and runs a very real risk of finding out that the next era of social networking doesn't include much Facebooking.
So my bearish CAPScall on Facebook stays in place until Mark Zuckerberg and company adjust their strategy again. If you can't keep your users happy, the money will very quickly cease to matter.
Fool contributor Anders Bylund owns shares of Google. The Motley Fool recommends and owns shares of Facebook, Google, and LinkedIn. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools don't all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.