This series, brought to you by Yahoo! Finance, looks at which upgrades and downgrades make sense, and which ones investors should act on. Today, our headlines feature a pair of bankers -- First Horizon (NYSE: FHN ) and SunTrust (NYSE: STI ) that one analyst thinks you should buy, and also a telecom equipment maker that a second analyst thinks you should not buy. Let's start with that one.
Alcatel-Lucent: Worth more than you think, but still not a buy
Shares of Franco-American tel-equip-maker Alcatel-Lucent (NYSE: ALU ) are hopping this afternoon, up nearly 4% on news that: (1) the company has just completed testing of a potential 400 gigabyte-per-second fiber optic line in Canada for local operator SaskTel, and (2) it's received a boost in price target of more than 44% from analysts at MKM Partners.
Don't get too excited, though. In its SaskTel press release, Alcatel didn't say anything about how much money it expects to make from the project, or if indeed it expects to make any money at all (Alcatel remains deeply unprofitable).
As for the price hike, despite raising its target, even MKM still doesn't think you should actually buy Alcatel. This is more a case of an analyst acknowledging that Mr. Market has bid Alcatel's price up, forcing MKM to either maintain its $2.60 price target -- and switch its recommendation to the logical: sell -- or else stick to its advice on not buying the stock, and admit the price might rise a bit higher.
MKM chose Door No. 2 today, raising its price target to $3.75 per share, but maintaining a neutral rating on Alcatel.
If it were me, though, I'd have stuck to my guns. Burning cash, in debt to the tune of $1 billion more than cash on hand, unprofitable, and expected to still be losing money as far out as 2016 (aside from a brief period of profitability in 2015, for reasons unexplained), Alcatel stock still looks like a dog to me. The fact that the shares have nearly tripled over the past year just means it's picked up some overoptimistic fleas for the ride.
Cloudy outlook for First Horizon
And speaking of optimists, this morning we saw analysts at Compass Point turn very sunny indeed on a couple of regional bankers. Let's start with First Horizon, upgraded this morning to buy.
Compass Point notes that this Memphis-based banker has "dramatically underperformed peers over the past year," a fact the analyst attributes to "heavy run-off of the company's nonstrategic portfolio and legacy credit overhangs." Compass thinks the company will come out of its troubles just fine, however, and that it deserves to be valued at something closer to 15 times fiscal 2014 earnings -- which analysts estimate will be about $0.88 per share. Compass, therefore, posits a $13 share price for the stock.
But I think that's bunk; 15 times forward earnings is way too much to pay for a stock that most analysts agree will struggle to produce even 8% annualized profits growth over the next five years. Meanwhile, the number that 8% growth rate should be compared to -- actual, historical trailing earnings, is low enough to give the company a trailing P/E ratio of more than 18. Which is, of course, also too high.
Long story short, Compass Point may be right that investors will eventually pay more for First Horizon, and accord it a valuation multiple closer to those of its peers. But they'd be wrong to. At this valuation, and at this growth rate, First Horizon is overpriced already.
Sunnier outlook for SunTrust
On the other hand, Compass Point also likes SunTrust Banks, and gave that one a buy rating as well today -- and here, I think the analyst strikes closer to the mark. Priced at just 8.5 times earnings, paying a modest 1.2% dividend yield, and pegged for 10% annualized long-term profits growth by most analysts on Wall Street, SunTrust shares look pretty substantially undervalued.
Compass Point thinks concerns over the company's mortgage banking business explain the depressed valuation at SunTrust, but argues the concerns "are already priced into the stock," and create an opportunity to profit in the event of "a pickup in [commercial real estate] and residential lending."
I agree, and in fact, I'd even go a bit further than the analyst, here. Compass Point's projection of a $38 stock price a year from now suggests there's at least 14% profit in the shares. But if you add SunTrust's dividend yield to its projected growth rate, the total return ratio on this stock with a P/E of 8.5 is only about 0.76 -- suggesting the stock could in fact rise in price by nearly a third and still be only fairly valued.
Of the two banks Compass Point recommends today, I think SunTrust is clearly the better bargain.
Fool contributor Rich Smith has no positions in any stock mentioned.