You know the old adage buy low and sell high? When it comes to corporations, sometimes they like to buy low and keep buying even after the stock has increased in value. The company in question here is Walt Disney (NYSE:DIS), which just announced a $6 to $8 billion stock repurchase plan for fiscal year 2014. While a large stock buyback should be seen as a big positive, there are several reasons investors should question the move.
Want to increase your stock price? Announce a buyback!
One of the problems with a company pre-announcing a stock repurchase plan is investors immediately bid up the shares. All things being equal, fewer shares means the remaining shares should be more valuable. However, on this announcement, Disney stock added over $3 billion in market value on a day when the overall market was basically flat.
It would be one thing if Disney operated a virtual monopoly and its earnings growth was essentially guaranteed. However, Disney faces stiff competition around every corner. From television shows to movie releases to theme parks Disney has to contend with several large and established competitors.
The point is the value of the stock should be determined by a combination of expected earnings growth, current price, and announcements. The bottom line is the stock buyback should be a good thing for investors, but it's not a guarantee of future returns.
The power of the mouse
It would be crazy to suggest that Disney isn't a strong company. In fact, stock buybacks are nothing new to the Mouse House. Disney has repurchased between $1.5 and $3.8 billion in shares each of the last three years.
In addition, Disney sports the best operating margin of its peers without a cable business. Disney competes against the likes of Time Warner (NYSE:TWX), Comcast (NASDAQ:CMCSA), and CBS (NYSE:CBS). The biggest difference between these four companies is Comcast is the only one that owns the pipes (cable) as well as the content.
Since Comcast operates a high-margin cable business, its operating margin is higher than the rest at 33.34% in the last quarter. By comparison, Disney managed an operating margin of 28.94%, while CBS came in at 19.47% and Time Warner reported a margin of 20.32%. As you can see, without the benefit of a high-margin cable business, Disney is crushing its competition when it comes to the efficiency of its business.
On top of carrying a high margin, Disney also has the lowest debt-to-equity ratio of the group at just 0.28. When you consider that CBS' ratio is 0.62, Time Warner is at 0.64, and Comcast is at 0.89, you can see the relative strength of Disney's balance sheet. So if Disney can afford to leverage its balance sheet and make huge share repurchases, why is that a bad thing?
This business is far from perfect
One of the issues with announcing a large share buyback is the increase in the value of the stock can immediately mean less bang for the company's buck. A perfect example is last fiscal year, when Disney bought back about $2 billion in stock. However, in its current earnings, the company's diluted share count is actually 0.61% higher than the previous year.
When you look at Disney's peers, they all have better records of reducing their overall shares in the last year. CBS' commitment to share repurchases has meant the company's diluted shares are down by 5.6% versus last year. While not as impressive, Comcast and Time Warner have also reduced their share counts by 1.88% and 2.4%, respectively.
There are also two big questions at Disney, namely its filmed entertainment division and its ABC broadcasting unit. Filmed entertainment should do better in the second half of the year with Planes looking like a hit, and Thor: The Dark World on tap. However, it has to be a little disappointing that strong releases like Iron Man 3 and Monsters University weren't enough to save the unit from a 2% decline in revenue. Given that Time Warner reported a 12.5% increase and Comcast reported a 12.8% increase in their respective film divisions, Disney's results leave something to be desired.
In addition, Disney's ABC network is failing miserably compared to the others. CBS reported revenue up 4% (without the NCAA tournament) and Comcast's NBC network reported revenue up 7.7%. Even Time Warner's TNT and TBS properties reported revenue up 6.75%. Contrary to these strong results, ABC's revenue was essentially flat.
The point is Disney is a great company with a bright future. However, with the stock up about 25% in the last year, the shares already reflect this optimism. The fact that Disney is planning on borrowing money to fund this repurchase will mean higher interest costs in the future. The pop in the stock not only means the company may get less of a deal, but it's likely that investors are overpaying as well. The increase in share price should give investors about 3 billion reasons to question this move.
Chad Henage owns shares of Comcast. The Motley Fool recommends Walt Disney. The Motley Fool owns shares of Walt Disney. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.