Investors have been waiting for nearly a year to see American International Group's (NYSE:AIG) sale of its International Lease Finance Corp. to a Chinese consortium get to the finish line. But ever since the deal was inked last December, there has been one complication after another. During the insurer's most recent earnings conference call, CEO Robert Benmosche noted that there were some new accounting concerns putting pressure on the firm to make a decision during the fourth quarter regarding ILFC's sale or IPO.
Here's the scoop on AIG's latest dilemma.
No news was good news
The most recent developments in the sale of ILFC to the Chinese consortium will require some more time to resolve, which AIG might not have if it wants to keep the operations off its balance sheet. Since the company entered into the deal with the consortium, ILFC has been listed as a non-core asset that's being held for sale, and as such, it is held to certain accounting requirements. With the newest changes to the consortium, AIG needs to re-evaluate whether ILFC still meets those accounting requirements.
Requirement 1: Available immediately
ILFC easily met the first hurdle. AIG has the operations available for immediate sale, as-is. Check.
Requirement 2: Sale is "highly probable"
This test may trip up the accountants a bit. The general rule states that there needs to be a market for the sale of the asset, including reasonable pricing and buyers.
The pricing aspect was disappointing for AIG's management, but it was met when the deal was signed at $4.2 billion. Initially, the insurer was looking to sell ILFC for close to $9 billion. Subsequently, ILFC's recent impairment didn't affect AIG, since the company had already taken a writedown on the fair value of the operations to match its sale price.
The second part of the requirement is where the complications arise. The consortium is having difficulties with members leaving and new parties stepping forward, as well as financing. This will cause AIG to evaluate carefully whether the consortium represents true available buyers.
Requirement 3: Timing
When an asset is classified as held for sale, there is generally a one-year time limit automatically triggered. The company needs to have reasonable confidence that a sale of the asset will be completed within the one-year time frame.
It's this requirement that has placed some pressure on AIG's management to get the ILFC transaction resolved one way or the other during the fourth quarter. Though accounting rules do incorporate allowances for extensions resulting from unforeseen circumstances, the difficulties faced by the group of buyers, on top of the continued missed deadlines, must be making life just a little bit harder for the company's accountants to justify.
The sale of ILFC has been a tough puzzle for AIG. And with the leasing company representing the last huge chunk of debt obligations for the insurer, it's critical to the firm's restructuring program to divest as quickly as possible. With time running out before the end of 2013, AIG's management has some tough choices ahead of it. I've already voiced my opinion, but maybe playing some of Run-DMC's "It's Tricky" in the background will inspire the accountants enough to give the consortium the time in needs to seal the ILFC deal.
Fool contributor Jessica Alling has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends, owns shares of, and has options on AIG. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools don't all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.