Who’s to Blame for Stores Opening on Thanksgiving?

For many, Thanksgiving is a day about family, friends, good food and football. For us all, Thanksgiving should be a day when we are grateful for those who keep us safe, and for those who bring meaning and joy to our lives. It should also be a day when we evaluate what we are doing for others, and how we can best use our gifts and talents to further the greater good.

However, like it or not, Thanksgiving is also the kick-off to the critically important holiday shopping season for retailers. Historically, this season begins at midnight on the Friday after Thanksgiving – which has come to be known as Black Friday. The term Black Friday is actually rooted from the belief that retailers would be operating at a loss, in financial terms "in the red," until the holiday shopping season begins, which would then allow them to turn a profit and "operate in the black."

While there will be much analysis of Black Friday 2013 in the weeks to come, one fact is clear – Black Friday is beginning earlier and earlier. This means that a Thursday that was once reserved for family, food, and football, is now increasingly becoming a day to storm the outlets for deep discounts.

Industry leaders are beginning to call this trend "Black Friday Creep" or even "Brown Thursday." Whatever the nickname, two conclusions seem to be emerging: this trend is causing a great deal of controversy over the workers who must now punch in, instead of sitting down for the holiday with their families; and if this day continues to bring in big business, more and more retailers will open their doors.

Who was open for business this Thanksgiving?

Leading the way for major retailers operating on Thanksgiving was Kmart, which opened at 6 a.m. Thursday, and remained open for a staggering 41 straight hours through Black Friday. Old Navy was not all that far behind, opening stores for the majority of Thanksgiving Day with operating hours from 9 a.m. to 4 p.m.

Wal-Mart (NYSE: WMT  )  opened at 6 p.m. on Thanksgiving, two hours earlier than last year, and four hours earlier than in 2011 – a telling trend from the world's largest retailer and America's largest employer. Target (NYSE: TGT  )  and Macy's (NYSE: M  )  joined a long list of big-name retailers who opened just after the last round of desserts were served, at 8 p.m. last Thursday.

Who was closed on Thanksgiving?

While it is becoming a new industry standard to open for business on Thanksgiving, some notable companies continued to buck that trend in 2013, giving their workers the holiday off. Costco (NASDAQ: COST  ) , a retailer known for its employee-friendly corporate culture stayed closed last Thursday, while opening up an hour earlier than usual at 9 a.m. on Friday.

Home Depot (NYSE: HD) stayed consistent with its 2012 holiday season strategy, and stayed closed on Thanksgiving Day, while opening its doors at 5 a.m. on Friday. BJ's Wholesale Club also continued its tradition of keeping doors closed on Thanksgiving by kicking off its end-of-year sale season at 7 a.m. on Black Friday.

Does opening on Thanksgiving make sense for the bottom line?

In a word, yes. According to the National Retail Federation, shopping on Thanksgiving Day 2013 drew nearly 45 million consumers, up 27% from 2012 when 35 million bargain hunters hit the stores. To put this trend in perspective, the 35 million consumers who shopped on Thanksgiving Day last year represented a 23% uptick from 2011, and a 58% jump from 2010.

While Black Friday continues to reign supreme, attracting more than 92 million consumers, shopping on Thanksgiving appears to be a trend that is here to stay.

In a consumer climate where the average shopper is spending $407 over the holiday weekend, down from an average of $423 last year – capturing market share is key. Retailers that opened their doors this Thanksgiving, such as Wal-Mart, were able to capture a piece of that market share that their competitors, such as Costco, could not.

In addition to the fierce competition with one another, retailers must also compete with external forces. Due to a later than usual Thanksgiving Day, retailers are fighting against a compressed calendar with the shortest holiday shopping season since 2002. Brick and mortar stores are also competing with their e-commerce rivals, who are offering equally enticing holiday deals while operating 24 hours a day, 365 days a year.

 Who's to blame for stores opening on the holiday?

With an increasing demand from consumers, still sluggish national economy, and intense competition from all sides, you can see why a retailer would choose to open on Thanksgiving Day. The bigger question however is, should they?

The problem with all of these stores opening on Thanksgiving Day is that these stores do not run themselves. Millions of employees, many of them low-wage workers, spent their holiday away from their families endlessly stocking shelves, or cashing out droves of bargain-hunting customers. Due to the nature of many positions in the retail industry, these workers had no control on whether they would work on Thanksgiving. If their store was open, they were expected to report for their shift.

So, who's to blame for stores opening on Thanksgiving? Is it the companies that are looking to maximize their profits and get an edge on the competition, or the bargain-hunting consumers with an insatiable desire for more hours of holiday shopping?

The truth is, it's a little bit of both.

As demonstrated by the big name companies that still keep their stores closed on Thanksgiving, retailers do not need to open on the holiday to keep the lights on. All of these retailers could find the strength to give their employees Thanksgiving Day off, while still opening their doors early for Black Friday sales.

Expanding the holiday shopping weekend to Thanksgiving Day is not growing overall sales, it is just shifting them earlier. If the industry reverted back to its historic norm when Thursday was a day for family, and Friday was a day for shopping, all of the retailers could compete on a level playing field for the holiday sales market share.

But all of the blame for store openings on Thanksgiving cannot be placed at the feet of the retailers alone. As in most situations, we the consumer actually have the overriding control here. If customers were not showing up in droves on Thanksgiving Day, these stores would not be open. It really is that simple.

If consumers continue to display a high demand for store openings on Thanksgiving Day, and if this demand continues to increase – the market will respond with more and more retailers opening their doors on the holiday.

So, if we really want to see retail employees have Thanksgiving Day off, we need to take a momentary break from the holiday shopping season ourselves.

Two retail investments to consider

To learn about two retailers with especially good prospects, take a look at The Motley Fool's special free report: "The Death of Wal-Mart: The Real Cash Kings Changing the Face of Retail." In it, you'll see how these two cash kings are able to consistently outperform and how they’re planning to ride the waves of retail's changing tide. You can access it by clicking here.

Read/Post Comments (6) | Recommend This Article (2)

Comments from our Foolish Readers

Help us keep this a respectfully Foolish area! This is a place for our readers to discuss, debate, and learn more about the Foolish investing topic you read about above. Help us keep it clean and safe. If you believe a comment is abusive or otherwise violates our Fool's Rules, please report it via the Report this Comment Report this Comment icon found on every comment.

  • Report this Comment On December 03, 2013, at 3:38 PM, ZAP1ROWSDOWER wrote:

    Yes, so if we use the excuse that people are away from teir families on Thaksgiving we have to shut all gas stations, bodegas and resturants on that day too. Does that make sense? Stop your bitching and realise tha you have a job and yo go to work to get paid. Don't like it? Find another job. If you work in retail you know that you will be working holidays. It happens every year, why is it a surprise?

  • Report this Comment On December 03, 2013, at 4:00 PM, wtfomglol wrote:

    I honestly do not see any difference between going to the store before 3-4pm to grab that something missing for your commercialized Thanksgiving dinner and going to the store AFTER that very same meal. The only difference I see is the time of day in which you are at the store. Also, if your family is anything like mine (don’t lie to yourself) then we rarely ever have a peaceful holiday and by the time we are done eating Thanksgiving dinner we all want to tear each other’s heads off. The way I see it, retailers are doing us a favor by being open and giving us all a place to go and escape our families on Thanksgiving.

  • Report this Comment On December 03, 2013, at 4:44 PM, BOOBOOTHEFOOL7 wrote:

    The general consensus for retail opening on Thursday is people are not spending any more money on black Friday. Rather than them question the poor deals that they are giving their customers they rather try to be the one that opens first to get access to peoples money but sears is the one who started this mess.

    on black Friday I did not buy anything all the stores did was raise the price on their goods and then put them on sale at regular price

    years ago they choose to open up early and then target copied them, then walmart being already open said why not.

  • Report this Comment On December 03, 2013, at 4:45 PM, pondee619 wrote:

    "Who's to blame for stores opening on the holiday?" The "nearly 45 million consumers, (who) hit the stores" I like a story that answers itself.

    "you can see why a retailer would choose to open on Thanksgiving Day. The bigger question however is, should they?"

    Why not, they open on Sunday, a day of rest in a religion practiced in this country, they open on Saturday, another widely recognized day of rest. There is no morality in retail.

    qwtfomglol: I am truly sorry over your family's state of affairs.

  • Report this Comment On December 04, 2013, at 8:26 AM, RedMoonAutumn wrote:

    THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU. Are we as a culture becoming so desensitized by greed and want? Yes. You know, I think I'm going to have to stop shopping at some of these places - for the whole year. I think it makes retailers who really don't have to be open look greedy and inconsiderate - the "norm" these days. And if those making the decisions to have their employees work on a holiday remain at home for Thanksgiving - then you can add hypocritical to the above list of adjectives, too. THAT'S the bottom line. I hope the employees are at least being adequately recompensed with extra for that holiday for an employers obvious lack of sensitivity. If anyone knows someone who works at such a store, I suggest working at a bank, a place of employment that is all about money yet has the decency to let their employees have 24-48 hours of family and celebration on SEVERAL holidays. Strong words? Yes... I reserve the right to my opinion as well. There just AREN'T any excuses. You'd think Scrooge runs these stores.

  • Report this Comment On December 04, 2013, at 8:43 AM, mchale207p wrote:

    12/4/2013 be sure to let us know,after you've looked up black Friday.i'm sure we're always interested in the facts.

Add your comment.

DocumentId: 2750491, ~/Articles/ArticleHandler.aspx, 4/19/2014 12:49:55 AM

Report This Comment

Use this area to report a comment that you believe is in violation of the community guidelines. Our team will review the entry and take any appropriate action.

Sending report...