Dollar General's (NYSE:DG) stock has appreciated 35.41% over the past year, which stemmed from the discount retailer perfectly positioning itself to target value-conscious consumers, many of which are on fixed incomes. However, over the past month, the stock has only appreciated 0.15%. This might stem from a shift in Dollar General's merchandise mix. Let's take a look at the situation, as well as how Dollar General stacks up against Dollar Tree (NASDAQ:DLTR) and Family Dollar (NYSE:FDO).
Merchandise mix shift
In Dollar General's latest 10-Q, the company cited high unemployment, volatility in gas and food prices, high medical costs, weak housing (in some markets), and weak credit markets as reasons for a lack of consumer confidence. Despite these concerns, the company remains optimistic about its long-term prospects. At the same time, Dollar General concedes that consumers are shifting from purchasing high-margin non-consumables to lower-margin consumables.
For instance, in the first quarter, Dollar General's gross profit declined to 30.3% versus 30.9% in the year-ago quarter. The good news is that the company still managed to drive its top line with ease, seeing total sales jump 10.5% to $4.38 billion and comps jump 4.4%. The latter was primarily due to increased foot traffic and average customer ticket.
These are positives, but shrinking margins are a negative, especially when this is expected to continue. Fortunately, Dollar General has a specific game plan to drive growth and cut costs in order to improve the bottom line.
Dollar General's four priorities are to drive productive sales growth, increase gross margin, leverage process improvements and IT to reduce costs, and strengthen and expand the culture of serving others.
In order to drive productive sales growth, Dollar General looks to expand its consumable offerings, matching consumer demands. Additionally, Dollar General will offer more tobacco, beer, and wine products. Store remodels and relocations are also in the works.
To expand margins, or at least slow their contraction, Dollar General will aim to offer more private brands, which will reduce costs. Furthermore, Dollar General will test its pricing power--however, if sales are effected, Dollar General will likely retreat.
For the record, Dollar General isn't like Dollar Tree. While Dollar Tree sells products for $1, Dollar General sells its products for $10 or less. Therefore, Dollar General has the ability to test different price points. On the other hand, if a Dollar General and Dollar Tree are close to one another geographically, a consumer is likely to visit Dollar Tree first. After all, whether they realize it or not, today's consumers are always looking to improve their margins as well.
To reduce SG&A expenses, Dollar General won't have much choice but to look at labor costs, and to a lesser extent, procurement savings. Since demand is higher for lower-margin consumables, there really aren't many other options.
As far as expanding the culture of serving others, Dollar General aims to keep its stores clean and well-stocked while continuing to offer high-quality products at low prices.
Now let's take a look at how Dollar General stacks up against its peers in the dollar store world.
Dollar store performance comparisons
While all three of the aforementioned companies have performed well over the past four years, Dollar Tree has driven its top line the fastest:
This is interesting since Dollar Tree sells all items for just $1. This proves that pricing power isn't necessary to drive the top line. It's more about matching current consumer desires, and to that extent, Dollar Tree has hit a home run. Therefore, it shouldn't come as a surprise as to which of these companies has delivered the largest total shareholder return (stock appreciation plus dividends) over the past five years:
However, this isn't to say Dollar General and Family Dollar aren't enticing. For instance, Dollar General has logical initiatives in place, and the brand still matches consumer demands.
Family Dollar, which is more focused on consistent promotions, is enticing for several reasons. One, it's trading at just 14 times forward earnings, whereas Dollar General and Dollar Tree are trading at 16 and 17 times forward earnings, respectively. Two, it generated $471.97 million in operating cash flow over the past year, giving it fiscal strength considering its balance sheet: $145 million in cash vs. $516.47 in long-term debt. In other words, debt can be paid off with ease and isn't a concern. Three, Family Dollar yields 1.60%, whereas Dollar General and Dollar Tree don't pay dividends.
All that said, while Dollar General and Family Dollar are impressive, Dollar Tree still appears to be best of breed. Think about how Amazon does whatever it takes to please the consumer. This approach has led to stellar top-line growth and stock appreciation. By selling all items at $1 each, Dollar Tree also caters perfectly to many of today's consumers, and it should continue to attract customers regardless of what is taking place in the economy. That's a nice feeling for an investor.
Dan Moskowitz has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Amazon.com. The Motley Fool owns shares of Amazon.com. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.