I want my Foolish friends to buy low and sell high, or perhaps to buy high and sell higher. I just hope that those who might have joined the rush to buy homebuilding stocks on Wednesday haven't gotten ahead of themselves.
The builders' heady day was precipitated by comments surrounding Toll Brothers' (NYSE: TOL ) preliminary release of its July quarter results. The company's CEO Bob Toll has a way with a phrase, and it seems that the market glommed onto his comment that "significant pent-up demand is building, based on solid demographics, a decent economy and still-strong employment." Fine, but I'd hasten to point out that Toll also cautioned that "the pace of home sales could slow further until the credit markets settle down."
As has now become something of a custom for the builders, Toll Brothers' "preliminary" results were released on Wednesday, and a final set of numbers will be issued in two weeks. Revenue in the quarter appears to have declined to $1.21 billion, from last year's $1.53 billion. The company's quarter-end backlog was $3.67 billion -- down 34% year over year -- and its net contracts signed were valued at about $727.1 million, 31% lower than last year.
In December of last year, Toll said that he thought the housing market was dancing along the bottom, or slightly above it. That was just before "subprime" became totally entrenched in our vocabularies, while also becoming the most oft-uttered word on financial network CNBC.
But the optimistic portion of Toll's Wednesday comments -- along with a market that bounced around like a cork in a storm, only to finish up by triple digits on the day -- was enough to light a fuse under most homebuilding stocks. Centex (NYSE: CTX ) , for instance, was up about 8%, while D.R. Horton (NYSE: DHI ) climbed almost 7%, Lennar (NYSE: LEN ) moved 4.5% higher, and Beazer (NYSE: BZH ) , which had been pounded in recent weeks, recovered to the tune of nearly 25%. Toll Brothers was 6% higher.
So maybe there really is an emerging pent-up demand for houses that's about to explode and obliterate a still-sliding credit market. My inclination, nevertheless, is to side with my Foolish colleague Seth Jayson, who admittedly pulled out the housing storm shutters long before I did. With the perpetually Pollyannaish National Association of Realtors still adjusting its sales forecasts downward, I'm not yet ready to emerge from my bunker.
In that spirit, I'll repeat the warning I made a few weeks back: Fools should only assume they've found housing's bottom when it hits them in the face.
For related Foolishness:
Fool contributor David Lee Smith doesn't own shares in any of the companies mentioned. He welcomes your questions or comments. The Motley Fool's disclosure policy is superprime.