Roth IRA as Emergency Fund?

This article was originally published on July 23, 2003.

My wife and I are crazy. We're thinking of having another kid, maybe two more.

While having kids is challenging enough, we have special circumstances. During our first pregnancy, Elizabeth -- because of a risk of preterm labor -- was put on "bed rest" for two months. She was allowed to go to the bathroom and take a shower, that was it. We sometimes cheated by driving a mile to the nearest Starbucks (Nasdaq: SBUX  ) , but my wife was otherwise homebound. For our second pregnancy, Elizabeth was in bed for four months. At this rate, if we have another kid, Elizabeth will be bedridden by the morning after.

If we want to have Baby Bro #3, we have to plan ahead. We have to be prepared for her lost income and our increased expenses, including medical bills and child care. So we've set aside $12,000 in our "propagate the species" fund.

Conventional wisdom says we should keep this money somewhere safe and liquid, such as a money market account. After all, this is like an emergency fund, and we shouldn't take risks with such things.

Except that we may not need all that money. What if we decide not to have any more children? Or what if we decide to enlarge our family some other way, through adoption or Overstock (Nasdaq: OSTK  ) ? Or what if we don't end up needing the whole 12 grand? That money will have been twiddling its thumbs for years, earning paltry interest in a bank account.

One possible solution: Deposit some of the money in a Roth Individual Retirement Arrangement.

"What?!" you're thinking. "Use a Roth IRA for an emergency fund?! Call the child protective services people -- this man is unfit for parenting and should be sterilized!"

Kids today
It's not as crazy as it sounds (using a Roth as an emergency fund, that is -- not my sterilization). Unlike the money in a traditional IRA or an employer-sponsored retirement account -- which is taxed and penalized if withdrawn before the account owner turns 59 1/2 in most cases -- contributions to a Roth IRA can be withdrawn anytime and for any reason, penalty- and tax-free. However, the earnings will be taxed and penalized if withdrawn before that magic age (with some exceptions).

"But money in an IRA is for retirement only," you're saying. "And I'm still calling the child protective services people because your son swallowed a penny last weekend!"

Yes, it's true. During a joint sorting/financial educational moment, my son swallowed a penny. As many of you fellow irresponsible parents know, such an event is followed by days of looking for the penny in the child's... well, you know. The penny was recovered, and you should have seen the look on Abe Lincoln's face. Thus, your children are not a good place for your emergency fund, because the money is not easily or pleasantly accessible.

It is also true that money in an IRA is generally meant for retirement. My wife and I contribute to other retirement accounts, so we'll be fine if we end up needing the entire $12,000 during the next pregnancy. But if we don't, the money we put in a Roth will be a nice addition to our nest egg.

"Well, why not keep the emergency money aside and contribute to a Roth IRA?" you're thinking.

Because we can't do everything. Financial planning is the fine art of apportioning limited resources among various goals. Should you pay off the mortgage or acquire a rental property? Pay off the credit card or build an emergency fund? Save for college or save for retirement? It's a fine, and imperfect, balancing act.

Regarding that final question, some people use the Roth IRA to save for both. Money in a Roth can be used for higher-education expenses. The contributions can, as previously mentioned, be withdrawn without consequence. The earnings can be withdrawn penalty-free as long as the account has been open for five years, but you'll still have to pay taxes. So if Junior needs the money, it's there. But if he doesn't -- because he doesn't go to college or because he got a scholarship -- your retirement looks that much better.

The pitfalls
There are many pitfalls to thinking of a Roth IRA as a source of funds for something other than retirement. First of all, most people use their IRAs for long-term assets such as stocks. However, if you use the money for short-term purposes, you either (1) have to be more conservative and therefore sacrifice potential growth, or (2) risk selling assets at inopportune times, such as when they're down 25%.

Secondly, and perhaps most importantly, thinking of your Roth as a potential source of preretirement funds creates a dangerous mind-set. It's a slippery slope from genuine emergency (disability) or stated goal (college) to excuses for compromising your retirement (vacation, new car, or nose job). This strategy should be employed only with money that has a good chance of not being used until you kiss or spank your boss goodbye.

Want eight great ideas ways to improve the quality and security of your retirement? Give theMotley Fool Rule Your Retirementnewsletter service a free 30-day trial, and receive the "8 Ways to Supercharge Your Retirement" special report.

Since the first publication of this article, Robert Brokamp, the editor ofRule Your Retirement, and his wife have begun the process of adopting a child, which is just as expensive as being on bed rest but allows for more trips to Starbucks.

Read/Post Comments (2) | Recommend This Article (10)

Comments from our Foolish Readers

Help us keep this a respectfully Foolish area! This is a place for our readers to discuss, debate, and learn more about the Foolish investing topic you read about above. Help us keep it clean and safe. If you believe a comment is abusive or otherwise violates our Fool's Rules, please report it via the Report this Comment Report this Comment icon found on every comment.

  • Report this Comment On July 26, 2015, at 3:23 PM, coffeedoc1 wrote:

    I designate the excess cash value in my blended whole life insurance policies to be my emergency fund. I can have the money sent to me in 5 business days (any more urgent need can be floated on a credit card until the Insurance check arrives and then paid off before interest accrues). If the emergency is of a short term nature, I can take the insurance money as a loan to be paid back after the emergency has passed (with a differential interest rate of only 0.7% between what the insurance company charges me and what they pay me on the cash value in my policy). If the emergency is permanent, I can take the money out of the policy as a withdrawal, which lowers the total death benefit but does not have to be paid back. Meanwhile, the cash value in my policy can never go down with the market and earns 3.5% per year, year in and year out while I am not having emergencies - beats any bank savings account or CD and even beats the safety and returns of most bond funds or even the dividend funds mentioned above (which yield less than 3.5% and can go down with market fluctuations.) Safe, secure, liquid and has the added advantage of providing death benefit to my family. In my opinion it is the perfect place to hold emergency fund money. coffeedoc1

  • Report this Comment On July 26, 2015, at 3:38 PM, coffeedoc1 wrote:

    There is another way for "people subject to income limits to get the benefits of this retirement vehicle," or at least one very like it. Stashing cash as overpaid premium in a blended cash value life insurance policy actually functions very similarly to a Roth IRA. Contributions to the policy are made after taxes and grow tax free within the policy. The money stored as cash value cannot be invested in the market, but does act as good alternative to bonds for the fixed income portion of your portfolio, with returns of 6-7% per year and no risk of your principle to the vagaries of the market. The money can be withdrawn at any time (you do not have to wait until age 59.5) and the withdrawal does not trigger a taxable event - as long as you have not exceeded your contribution limits (which run in the $50,000-$100,000+/yr range rather than the $5,500-$6,500/yr cap placed on Roth contributions). Withdrawals are made on a FIFO basis and do not have to be reported as income (it's like taking money out of your own savings account). The cash value in the policy can be used to supplement your retirement income from SS and other taxable vehicles like 401K, 403b, pensions or traditional IRAs, and any money left in the policy when your retirement "ends" is left to your heirs as the remaining death benefit of the policy. The policy cash value can also be used in the years prior to entering retirement to finance kids' college educations, weddings, cars, etc. and can serve as the "emergency fund" money that we all should have squirreled away (but frequently don't). A properly designed cash value life insurance policy is a good solution to a number of financial problems and can be a very beneficial portion of your retirement planning strategy. coffeedoc1

Add your comment.

Compare Brokers

Fool Disclosure

Sponsored Links

Leaked: Apple's Next Smart Device
(Warning, it may shock you)
The secret is out... experts are predicting 458 million of these types of devices will be sold per year. 1 hyper-growth company stands to rake in maximum profit - and it's NOT Apple. Show me Apple's new smart gizmo!

DocumentId: 493556, ~/Articles/ArticleHandler.aspx, 6/27/2017 1:31:17 PM

Report This Comment

Use this area to report a comment that you believe is in violation of the community guidelines. Our team will review the entry and take any appropriate action.

Sending report...

Today's Market

updated Moments ago Sponsored by:
Change down DOW 21385.7 -23.9 -0.1%
Change down S&P 500 2434.0 -5.1 -0.2%
Change down NASD 6194.2 -52.9 -0.9%

Create My Watchlist

Go to My Watchlist

You don't seem to be following any stocks yet!

Better investing starts with a watchlist. Now you can create a personalized watchlist and get immediate access to the personalized information you need to make successful investing decisions.

Data delayed up to 5 minutes

Related Tickers

6/27/2017 1:15 PM
OSTK $16.25 Down -0.05 -0.31% CAPS Rating: *
SBUX $59.09 Down -0.55 -0.92%
Starbucks CAPS Rating: ****