Traditional or Roth? Which Is the Right IRA for You?

There are a few major differences between the two types of tax-advantaged retirement accounts. Is one better for you than the other?

Feb 15, 2014 at 12:30PM



If you're like most Americans, you have the choice between two types of Individual Retirement Accounts, or IRAs. Traditional IRAs have been around the longest (as the name implies) and Roth IRAs are available to most people, but each have their own restrictions and benefits.

The contribution limits are the same for both accounts (currently $5,500 per year), as is the age at which the account holder can begin to take distributions (59.5 years old). 

However, there are several important differences between traditional and Roth IRAs. Let's take a look at the key differences between the two, and then at a comparison of how a hypothetical investment would do in both accounts.

Traditional IRA
In a nutshell, traditional IRA's allow people to put aside money for retirement, and pay no tax on the money you contribute, provided certain criteria are met. Anyone can contribute to a traditional IRA and defer the taxation of investment earnings, regardless of income level. However, in order to qualify for the tax deduction on one's contributions, the contributor's income must be below a certain level. 

For the 2013 tax year, single filers' eligibility for a deduction begins to phase out above $59,000 if they are eligible to participate in a retirement plan at work, and married couples must make below $95,000 to qualify for the deduction . There is a chart of qualifying income amounts here, which includes partial benefits for some higher-income individuals, as well as the loss of eligibility by being covered by an employer-sponsored retirement plan.

Roth IRA
The major difference between a Roth IRA and a Traditional IRA is whether the taxes are deferred now or later. A Roth IRA allows for contributors to pay tax on their income now, then withdraw the money and investment gains tax-free later on. 

The maximum contribution to either type of IRA is $5,500 for both the 2013 and 2014 tax years ($6,500 if the contributor is over 50), but unlike traditional IRAs, if your income is above a certain level, you cannot contribute to a Roth IRA. Married couples must earn below $178,000 in order to qualify for a full contribution, but may qualify for partial eligibility with incomes up to $188,000.

Another nice perk of a Roth IRA is that you can withdraw your contributions with out penalty or taxes at any time. The logic here is that you've already paid income taxes on your contributions so you are free to do whatever you want with the money. Any gains on your investments must be left in the account, however.

The difference it makes with a high-dividend stock
For the sake of comparison, let's see what difference the two types of IRAs can make in both the immediate term and over the long-term. Let's assume that our contributor qualifies for both types of accounts and can write off the full contribution into a traditional IRA.

Let's say our investor puts the maximum contribution ($5,500) into a variety of stocks with an average dividend yield of 4% and an average share price appreciation of 6% annually, a pretty conservative estimate.  We'll assume a 30-year timeframe and that all dividends are reinvested.

To open the account, a traditional IRA investor can simply put $5,500 into an account, and is not taxed on that portion of their income. A Roth investor has to pay tax on their income, making their effective initial investment $6,875 when accounting for the initial taxation of the income if they are in the 25% tax bracket

After 30 years, with our above assumptions, both accounts would have grown the initial $5,500 investment to $95,971. Not a bad return on the original investment, right?  And this is only one year's contribution.

The difference lies in how the investment is taxed when it is withdrawn. The traditional IRA investor has to pay taxes on any distributions, so the withdrawable amount is around $72,000 assuming a 25% tax rate (which may be higher or lower in your individual situation). The Roth IRA holder is free to withdraw the entire amount tax-free, because he/she already paid taxes on their original income.

So, the traditional IRA took an investment of $5,500 and turned it into $72,000 in 30 years, an effective annual return of about 9.3%. The Roth IRA effectively cost $6,875 for the initial investment and grew to a useable $95,971, for a slightly higher 9.5% rate of return. 

So, is one better than the other? It depends...
Both accounts had similar returns over the long term, but these results can vary significantly depending on your tax rates both now and at the time you begin withdrawing the money (almost impossible to predict). Roth IRAs are designed to benefit lower-income individuals, as they get taxed less on their current income and will have no tax liability on the future earnings of their investments.

Do a little research and see exactly what your personal situation and income allow you to do, and invest all you can in one of these. You'll be glad you did later!

6 great stock picks for any retirement account
They said it couldn't be done. But David Gardner has proved them wrong time, and time, and time again with stock returns like 926%, 2,239%, and 4,371%. In fact, just recently one of his favorite stocks became a 100-bagger. And he's ready to do it again. You can uncover his scientific approach to crushing the market and his carefully chosen six picks for ultimate growth instantly, because he's making this premium report free for you today. Click here now for access.

Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

1 Key Step to Get Rich

Our mission at The Motley Fool is to help the world invest better. Whether that’s helping people overcome their fear of stocks all the way to offering clear and successful guidance on complicated-sounding options trades, we can help.

Feb 1, 2016 at 4:54PM

To be perfectly clear, this is not a get-rich action that my Foolish colleagues and I came up with. But we wouldn't argue with the approach.

A 2015 Business Insider article titled, "11 websites to bookmark if you want to get rich" rated The Motley Fool as the #1 place online to get smarter about investing.

"The Motley Fool aims to build a strong investment community, which it does by providing a variety of resources: the website, books, a newspaper column, a radio [show], and [newsletters]," wrote (the clearly insightful and talented) money reporter Kathleen Elkins. "This site has something for every type of investor, from basic lessons for beginners to investing commentary on mutual funds, stock sectors, and value for the more advanced."

Our mission at The Motley Fool is to help the world invest better, so it's nice to receive that kind of recognition. It lets us know we're doing our job.

Whether that's helping the entirely uninitiated overcome their fear of stocks all the way to offering clear and successful guidance on complicated-sounding options trades, we want to provide our readers with a boost to the next step on their journey to financial independence.

Articles and beyond

As Business Insider wrote, there are a number of resources available from the Fool for investors of all levels and styles.

In addition to the dozens of free articles we publish every day on our website, I want to highlight two must-see spots in your tour of

For the beginning investor

Investing can seem like a Big Deal to those who have yet to buy their first stock. Many investment professionals try to infuse the conversation with jargon in order to deter individual investors from tackling it on their own (and to justify their often sky-high fees).

But the individual investor can beat the market. The real secret to investing is that it doesn't take tons of money, endless hours, or super-secret formulas that only experts possess.

That's why we created a best-selling guide that walks investors-to-be through everything they need to know to get started. And because we're so dedicated to our mission, we've made that available for free.

If you're just starting out (or want to help out someone who is), go to, drop in your email address, and you'll be able to instantly access the quick-read guide ... for free.

For the listener

Whether it's on the stationary exercise bike or during my daily commute, I spend a lot of time going nowhere. But I've found a way to make that time benefit me.

The Motley Fool offers five podcasts that I refer to as "binge-worthy financial information."

Motley Fool Money features a team of our analysts discussing the week's top business and investing stories, interviews, and an inside look at the stocks on our radar. It's also featured on several dozen radio stations across the country.

The hosts of Motley Fool Answers challenge the conventional wisdom on life's biggest financial issues to reveal what you really need to know to make smart money moves.

David Gardner, co-founder of The Motley Fool, is among the most respected and trusted sources on investing. And he's the host of Rule Breaker Investing, in which he shares his insights into today's most innovative and disruptive companies ... and how to profit from them.

Market Foolery is our daily look at stocks in the news, as well as the top business and investing stories.

And Industry Focus offers a deeper dive into a specific industry and the stories making headlines. Healthcare, technology, energy, consumer goods, and other industries take turns in the spotlight.

They're all informative, entertaining, and eminently listenable ... and I don't say that simply because the hosts all sit within a Nerf-gun shot of my desk. Rule Breaker Investing and Answers contain timeless advice, so you might want to go back to the beginning with those. The other three take their cues from the market, so you'll want to listen to the most recent first. All are available at

But wait, there's more

The book and the podcasts – both free ... both awesome – also come with an ongoing benefit. If you download the book, or if you enter your email address in the magical box at the podcasts page, you'll get ongoing market coverage sent straight to your inbox.

Investor Insights is valuable and enjoyable coverage of everything from macroeconomic events to investing strategies to our analyst's travels around the world to find the next big thing. Also free.

Get the book. Listen to a podcast. Sign up for Investor Insights. I'm not saying that any of those things will make you rich ... but Business Insider seems to think so.

Compare Brokers