For retailers, falling short of last year's comps has pretty much been par for the course this earnings season. Yet J.C. Penney's (NYSE: JCP) contribution to that trend -- missing last year's numbers by more than half -- wasn't the most disturbing thing about its latest earnings release.
For the third quarter, the retailer earned $0.55, on a 10% year-over-year dip in comparable-store sales. It also issued fourth-quarter guidance that falls far short of analysts' hopes.
None of that really bothers me, though -- I'm a bit more worried about J.C. Penney's troubling margin problem.
Going beyond P/E
Though its use as a yardstick may be a tad overused at times, let's face it: Everybody loves a low price/earnings ratio. With a trailing P/E of less than 5, Penney looks attractive by that standard. But its low P/E doesn't say much about the future.
If you were considering a business venture of your own, and you were told for every $100 in sales you generated, you'd make a net profit of about $2.90, would you want to get into that business? Probably not. But that 2.9% profit margin is all J.C. Penney managed last quarter.
It's not doomsday -- net margins are notoriously paper-thin in retail -- but 2.9%? Just for comparison, Nordstrom's (NYSE: JWN) profits fell 57% last quarter, but its margin remained closer to 4%. Kohl's (NYSE: KSS) cleared about 4.2% of its revenue.
More importantly, the numbers are way down from Penney's historical averages, which have typically run closer to 4% for the third quarter. And even though a one-percentage-point different may seem microscopic, by retail standards, the disparity is reaching scary levels for J.C. Penney.
Higher margins for Christmas?
I'm not saying Penney's is on the verge of a loss. In fact, it's looking for a profit somewhere in the neighborhood of $1.00 per share for the current quarter, which I consider highly likely. If the economy worsens before it improves, though -- and forces heavy markdowns -- the fourth quarter could be especially nerve-racking for J.C. Penney. Let's just hope its thin margins don't become a habit.
If your holiday spirit has overridden the effects of October's retail sales slump, and you're determined to invest in retail stocks, I think you might be better served by investigating Kohl's or TJX (NYSE: TJX). Both combine reasonable stock prices with less worrisome margins. In fact, TJX enjoyed net margins of almost 5% last quarter, thanks to a healthy top-line boost.
Meanwhile, Penney's investors should hope for a Christmas gift of better times -- even if they won't actually get it until next year.
Try on some further Foolishness:
Follow along with the Global Gains team as they travel to key business centers in China to uncover the very best investing opportunities! Sign up here to receive their FREE dispatches from the road.
Terms & Conditions
RSS Headlines
Fool UK