The housing recovery has boosted expectations for housing-related businesses, but perhaps none more so than those for home improvement retailers Home Depot (NYSE: HD ) and Lowe's Companies (NYSE: LOW ) . Both companies trade at rich multiples after significant stock price increases over the last two years. However, the duopolistic positioning of the companies may be enough to offset these lofty valuations.
Great competitive position
Home Depot and Lowe's are the only major players in the retail home improvement market, giving them tremendous advantages in scale over smaller chains and hardware stores. The companies' scale advantage has been key to their growth over the years. They buy products and materials at steep volume discounts and sell them to customers at prices that render smaller players unprofitable.
As Lowe's and Home Depot grow their market shares, their bargaining power with suppliers becomes even greater. As their bargaining power grows, they are able to reduce costs even further below what competitors can charge, thus creating a virtuous cycle.
The housing bust crushed demand for construction and home improvement products, which led to significant revenue headwinds and price competition between Lowe's and Home Depot. Lowe's experienced a slight revenue decline in 2008 and 2009 despite years of high growth leading up to the recession. Home Depot suffered a much more serious revenue decline, about 8% in 2008 and 7% in 2009, after having branched out into a wide variety of product categories and services in the years prior to the crash.
But as hard as the housing bust was for the duopoly, smaller competitors were hurt even more because they were already unable to compete with Lowe's and Home Depot. As a result, many of the companies' smaller competitors went out of business, leading to market share gains for both.
Conditions have since changed. Low interest rates and a recovering economy have led to a rebound in the housing market, enabling consumers to make more big-ticket home improvement purchases, thus driving top-line growth and margin expansion at home improvement retailers. The recovery has investors giddy with anticipation of a return to pre-crisis profitability -- and the stock prices reflect it.
Priced for (near) perfection
Both Lowe's and Home Depot are priced at high multiples of pre-recession earnings; Lowe's is priced at 22 times its 10-year high EPS and Home Depot trades for 23 times decade-high EPS.
Demand for home improvement products and services will continue to increase as incomes rise and unemployment falls. But higher interest rates could create a medium-term headwind for the industry, as it will make borrowing to buy a new home less attractive.
In addition, market saturation will likely cause an increased focus on price competition -- rather than store expansion -- as a means to grow earnings. Ongoing price competition is inevitable, despite the de facto duopoly, because of the lack of product differentiation. Home Depot and Lowe's derive a competitive advantage from cost efficiencies, but must continue to compete with one another based on price. This places a permanent cap on margin expansion.
So it looks as though the current environment is as good as it is going to get in the medium term, which means investors who buy Lowe's or Home Depot can expect a low return going forward.
A better alternative
Instead of buying overpriced home-improvement retailers, investors should consider buying Bed Bath & Beyond (NASDAQ: BBBY ) , a reasonably priced home-furnishings retailer. Bed Bath & Beyond benefits from a rising housing market because consumer expenditures on household items also rise, but the company's merchandise is weighted toward recession-resistant items -- like towels and cookware -- that consumers keep buying even during a sharp recession.
The company's protection from downturns in the housing market is evidenced by its continued revenue growth even during the recession; while Home Depot and Lowe's suffered revenue declines, Bed Bath & Beyond grew revenue by 6.5% and 2% in 2008 and 2009, respectively. In addition, the company routinely earns over 20% return on equity, despite having no debt on the balance sheet.
Bed Bath & Beyond is conservative, highly profitable, and selling at a reasonable 16 times earnings. Investors who want to bet on the housing recovery should buy Bed Bath & Beyond and wait for Lowe's and Home Depot to get cheaper.
The Motley Fool's chief investment officer has selected his No. 1 stock for this year. Find out which stock it is in the special free report: "The Motley Fool's Top Stock for 2013." Just click here to access the report and find out the name of this under-the-radar company.