Last week, Nintendo (NASDAQOTH: NTDOY ) made the unsurprising announcement that its Wii U had flopped and its 3DS sales were on the ropes.
Nintendo slashed its original full-year Wii U sales forecast by nearly 70% to 2.8 million units, and also reduced its full-year forecast for the handheld 3DS by 25% to 13.5 million units.
The Wii U has sold 5.3 million units since its launch in November 2012, compared to the 4.4 million Sony (NYSE: SNE ) PS4s and 3.1 million Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT ) Xbox Ones that have been sold since November 2013.
These sales declines are expected to cause Nintendo to incur an operating loss of 35 billion yen ($340 million) and cause it to miss its prior forecast for a 100 billion yen ($960 million) profit. This will also mark Nintendo's third consecutive annual operating loss.
Following that bleak announcement, Nintendo's Japanese shares plunged 11% while its U.S.-traded ADRs fell 17%. Despite the year's disastrous results, Nintendo President and CEO Satoru Iwata still intends to remain at the helm of the troubled gaming giant.
While it's too early to tell what Nintendo's next move will be, we should take a closer look at three major reasons that the Wii U failed, and if Nintendo still has a chance to bounce back from these mistakes.
1. The naming and marketing of the Wii U
The biggest mistake was the simplest one -- Nintendo completely dropped the ball when it named and introduced the Wii U.
The original Wii, which sold 101 million units, blew away Sony's PS3 (82 million units) and Microsoft's Xbox 360 (81 million units) because it drew sales from the previously untapped market of casual gamers. This was due to the simplicity of the Wii's motion controls and the universal appeal of titles such as Wii Sports, the best-selling game in history.
But therein lies the problem -- many Wii owners are not hardcore gamers who keep up with the latest gaming headlines. Therefore, when the Wii U was launched in November 2012, retailers and customers were baffled as to what the console actually was.
Sears (NASDAQ: SHLD ) , for example, mislabeled Wii U titles as original Wii games and grouped Wii and Wii U hardware into the same category. That kind of confusion, which occurred in other retailers as well, trickled down to customers, who thought that the Wii U was just another upgrade of the original Wii, similar to the Wii Balance Board and Wii Motion Plus in 2009.
To make matters worse, Nintendo discontinued the original Wii last October in Japan, which led to worldwide headlines proclaiming "the end of the Wii." Yet that wasn't the case -- Nintendo continued selling the original Wii in the United States, and even introduced a smaller version, the Wii Mini (which further confused customers) in November.
Last November, Nintendo finally released a commercial explaining the differences between the two consoles.
Yet many people still can't properly explain the difference between a Wii, Wii Mini, and Wii U. All of that drama could have been avoided if Nintendo gave the console a clearer name, such as the "Wii 2", and gave it a loud and dramatic launch like Sony and Microsoft.
2. Form factor and misunderstanding Japanese sensibilities
A second major problem with the Wii U was its form factor.
The design philosophy behind the original Wii was simple -- its motion controls could help gamers stay fit, the console would be compact to fit smaller Japanese homes, and raw horsepower wouldn't be a top priority, since its games would be geared toward casual gamers.
While not everyone agreed with Nintendo's original Wii strategy, it worked.
By comparison, the design philosophy behind the Wii U was chaotic. The Wii U's main controller, the Wii U GamePad, has an embedded touchscreen that can either be used as a secondary display for the main TV or as the main screen when the TV is turned off or in use. However, the player has to keep the Wii U console on and stay within 26 feet to remain connected.
This kind of setup would be ideal in cramped conditions, such as two roommates with a single TV in a small dorm room, but it didn't make any sense for smaller Japanese homes, which have an average of 2.3 televisions per household. The United States, by comparison, has three televisions per household.
The Wii U is also compatible with previous hardware (the Wii remote, nunchuk, balance board, classic controller) as well as software for the original Wii, which made it look more like an upgrade to the original Wii than a completely new system.
Therefore, gamers only had two real reasons to purchase a Wii U -- for second screen gaming and exclusive Wii U titles. If those two conditions weren't met, then the original Wii was a better option.
3. Lack of compelling first-party titles
Ever since many of Nintendo's third-party allies abandoned the gaming giant for Sony during the N64 era, Nintendo's first-party franchises -- Mario, Zelda, Metroid, Donkey Kong, Star Fox, and others -- have taken center stage.
Ever since the Wii era, however, Nintendo's output of first-party solo titles (featuring an individual character's franchise) has declined. Although nine out of the 10 top-selling Wii titles were published by Nintendo, only two of them -- New Super Mario Bros. Wii and Super Mario Galaxy -- are considered solo titles.
The rest of Nintendo's lauded "first-party" titles are mostly all-star racing games (Mario Kart), fighting games (Smash Bros.), or party games (Mario Party), which feature many of Nintendo's most popular characters in rehashed versions of older titles that debuted during the N64 era.
Nintendo is still pumping out Mario titles, most notably Super Mario 3D World, but its upkeep of other major franchises has faltered. During the Wii era, Nintendo released two full Zelda titles -- Twilight Princess and Skyward Sword -- although the former was a shared title with the sixth-generation GameCube.
More than a year after the Wii U's launch, a next-generation Zelda title still hasn't arrived yet. Nintendo is trying to remedy the problem with the Dynasty Warriors crossover Hyrule Warriors, but it's hardly a satisfying new chapter for true Zelda fans.
Meanwhile, Samus' latest home console adventure was Other M (Wii, 2010), Donkey Kong last appeared in Donkey Kong Country Returns (Wii, 2010), and Star Fox hasn't seen the light of day since Star Fox Assault (Gamecube, 2006).
The list doesn't stop there -- Nintendo's other core franchises have stalled out after the Wii era, in favor of remade classics (Ocarina of Time, Wind Waker) and all-star party games.
Nintendo is clearly spreading out its franchises too thin -- its 3DS, with 42.4 million units sold worldwide, has taken total priority over the Wii U. Therefore, 3DS gamers are getting better first-party titles, such as The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Two Worlds, while Wii U gamers are getting left out in the cold.
The future looks bleak
If Nintendo can't fix these three mistakes by 2014, the Wii U might be discontinued altogether so the company can focus on the 3DS, which remains the top selling console of the current generation.
What do you think, dear readers? Can the Wii U still bounce back after falling on its face every step of the way? Let me know in the comments section below!
Want to learn more about the video game industry?
Want to figure out how to profit on business analysis like this? The key is to learn how to turn business insights into portfolio gold by taking your first steps as an investor. Those who wait on the sidelines are missing out on huge gains and putting their financial futures in jeopardy. In our brand-new special report, "Your Essential Guide to Start Investing Today," The Motley Fool's personal finance experts show you what you need to get started, and even gives you access to some stocks to buy first. Click here to get your copy today -- it's absolutely free.