Facebook is a great service that I've been using for a while now, but it loses to Twitter for one simple reason: Whatever my friend Rick Munarriz may tell you, Facebook stinks at delivering ads.
Not quite adding it up
Some of the ads that appear on my Facebook profile page are perfectly fine. One, from Bank of America
Sadly, these are the exceptions.
Other ads ask me if I'd like "auction leather furniture" or advice for buying a fixer-upper home -- nonsense, since we've been in our current house for 10 years. Still other ads are regionally appropriate, aimed at me because I live in suburban Denver, but the content is off: I've no doubt David Byrne is a genius, but I never was and still am not much of a Talking Heads fan. You'll find none of Byrne's work in my iLike feed. So why is Facebook pitching me to buy tickets for a local appearance?
Hey! Buddy! Can you spare $4?
If it sounds like I'm asking Facebook to know me, it's because, well, I am. The brand promise of Facebook -- its raison d'etre for delivering pitches -- is that it really does know me, in a manner reminiscent of Amazon.com
Google
Socially stunted
Thus far, hopeful experiments with social search have failed. Google tried linking up with MySpace, only to abandon the deal when it fell far short of expectations. Said Google's Sergey Brin of the tie-up a year ago: "Monetization work we were doing [at MySpace] didn't pan out as well as we had hoped."
Perhaps that's an unfair comparison. News Corp.
And yet Facebook's once-vaunted valuation is collapsing, even as Twitter's is reaching for the social stratosphere. Once thought to be worth just $150 million, Twitter added $100 million to its valuation in a month, stiff-armed a $500 million bid from Facebook, and is now reported to be entertaining a $700 million cash bid from Apple
Why all the interest? Because Twitter, at a fraction of Facebook's size, is the Web's most relevant, searchable source of conversational intelligence. Entire businesses are being funded and built upon its platform.
Twitter, in other words, is already what Facebook hopes to be.
Tweet! Tweet! It's related Foolishness @ replying to you:
- Rick rebuts: Why Facebook Beats Twitter
- Back off my Twitter, Google.
- Have you tuned into the Twitter rebellion yet?
- Here's how Twitter gets rich.