Blockbuster's Joy-Buzzer Handshake

• Email
• Share
• Print

The patent dispute between Blockbuster (NYSE: BBI) and Netflix (Nasdaq: NFLX) is over. The two giants in home-delivered DVD rentals settled their differences outside of court on Monday, putting an end to the 14-month-old case.

Netflix was arguing that Blockbuster's entry into the online-based home delivery niche trampled on a pair of Netflix patents. According to Netflix, Blockbuster copied its queue management system and the subscription model for unlimited rentals.

Here is where things get interesting. The companies are not divulging the terms of the settlement, yet Blockbuster indicates that it won't have a material impact on its future financial performance.

Really? Netflix would have little reason to cave in here. Blockbuster's interface is nearly identical to the original. With Blockbuster's market-share-nibbling success forcing Netflix to lower its year-end subscriber targets, it just doesn't make sense for Blockbuster to escape without a scrape.

The market is as skeptical as I am. News of the confidential settlement sent Netflix shares climbing 6% higher, with Blockbuster's stock closing slightly lower.

It's no secret that Blockbuster is losing a ton of money with its Total Access plan. Earlier this month, it announced a new pricing tier that is $1 a month cheaper but nixes the free in-store DVD exchanges. The company expects to amend its offerings at least once more later this year. Could that be part of the settlement? Is this the beginning of Blockbuster's commitment to making its stores transactional havens again instead of hubs of free DVD swapping?

You can let the conspiracy theorists go dizzy with the possibilities. All I know is that Netflix is no dummy. There are too many threats on the horizon for it to settle out of court in a decision that doesn't make it stronger.

Thanks for the entertainment, Blockbuster and Netflix.

For your viewing pleasure:

• Dueling Fools: Netflix
• XM Marks the Netflix Spot
• Blockbuster: Hooray for Blu-ray

Netflix is a Stock Advisor recommendation. Take a free 30-day trial to see what Tom and David Gardner have cooking in the kitchen.

Longtime Fool contributor Rick Munarriz has been a Netflix shareholder -- and subscriber -- since 2002. He is also part of the Rule Breakers newsletter research team, seeking out tomorrow's ultimate growth stocks a day early. The Fool has a disclosure policy.