Value Investors Beware: Buying Cheap Can Cost You Dearly

Looking at the history of the S&P 500 index, you'll see a pretty clear trend that emerges among the best performing periods.


Performance Over Following 5 Years

Price-to-Earnings Ratio at Start Date

December 1994



July 1984



August 1982



January 1954



July 1950



July 1932




With the exception of 1994, the P/E ratio at the beginning of all of these periods was well below the market's long-term average valuation of 15.5. So the strategy seems simple: Invest when market multiples are tantalizingly low.

Not so fast, smart guy
Sure, this strategy might work for the overall market, but what if you're trying to beat the market by investing in individual stocks? If we look at some of the best performing U.S. stocks over the past five years, we may be left scratching our heads.


5-Year Price Change

P/E 5 Years Ago

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters



Arena Resources


33.0 (Nasdaq: PCLN  )



Hansen Natural (Nasdaq: HANS  )



Intuitive Surgical (Nasdaq: ISRG  )



Source: Capital IQ, a Standard & Poor's company.

While these valuations aren't all as astonishingly high as Intuitive Surgical, none would have been considered "cheap" on the basis of their P/E at the time. But it gets even more interesting when we look at some of the worst performing stocks over the same period.


5-Year Price Change

P/E 5 Years Ago

CIT Group



Ambac Financial (NYSE: ABK  )



Fannie Mae (NYSE: FNM  )



ExpressJet Holdings



Avis Budget Group



Source: Capital IQ, a Standard & Poor's company.

There's more to "cheap" than price
Leave it to good ole Warren Buffett to speak the truth: "It's far better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price."

As the stocks above suggest, getting a rock-bottom price for a stock is hardly a guarantee that you're going to bag outstanding gains. Or even avoid getting wiped out.

Five years ago, Avis' valuation may have looked attractive to some investors, but the company was slugging it out in the mature rental car industry and had operating income that didn't even cover the interest expense on its debt. Intuitive Surgical, meanwhile, had a scary-looking P/E, but sported a nearly debt-free balance sheet and was growing like a weed thanks to its revolutionary surgical systems.

But there's more ...
Going back for a second helping of Buffett wisdom, The Oracle has said on repeated occasions that with a smaller sum of money, he could produce annual returns of 50%. How? Well, part of the reason is that investing in smaller companies suddenly becomes feasible for him.

And this makes perfect sense. Of the top performers listed above, Intuitive Surgical was the largest among them in 2004, and its market cap was only $1.2 billion. Arena Resources and Green Mountain clocked in at a mere $68 million and $171 million, respectively. The small size of these companies gives them a huge advantage over the GE's (NYSE: GE  ) and Coca-Cola's (NYSE: KO  ) of the world because growing $7.8 million in profit (Green Mountain's fiscal 2004 net income) is much easier than growing $17.2 billion (GE's 2004 net income) or $4.8 billion (Coke's).

It would certainly be a bad idea to ignore valuation altogether -- after all, Buffett did say you should get a "fair" price -- but it seems that too much of a focus on finding the lowest priced stocks can actually hurt your returns. Instead, you're probably much better off focusing on the two factors I've outlined above:

  1. Quality: Make sure you're buying a company with a good business, a solid balance sheet, and a bright future.
  2. Small size: Smaller companies have a much easier time delivering knock-your-socks-off growth than their larger counterparts.

With a mandate to find the very best small cap stocks out there, the investing team at the Motley Fool Hidden Gems newsletter eats, sleeps, and breathes these concepts. If you'd like to check out what the team has added to the Hidden Gems real-money portfolio, you can take a free 30-day trial.

Green Mountain Coffee Roasters, Hansen Natural, and Intuitive Surgical are Motley Fool Rule Breakers recommendations. is a Motley Fool Stock Advisor recommendation. Coca-Cola is a Motley Fool Inside Value pick. Coca-Cola is a Motley Fool Income Investor selection. Try any of our Foolish newsletters today, free for 30 days.

Fool contributor Matt Koppenheffer owns shares of Coca-Cola, but does not own shares of any of the other companies mentioned. The Fool's disclosure policy has never once been caught with its pants down. Of course, it doesn't actually wear pants ...

Read/Post Comments (3) | Recommend This Article (19)

Comments from our Foolish Readers

Help us keep this a respectfully Foolish area! This is a place for our readers to discuss, debate, and learn more about the Foolish investing topic you read about above. Help us keep it clean and safe. If you believe a comment is abusive or otherwise violates our Fool's Rules, please report it via the Report this Comment Report this Comment icon found on every comment.

  • Report this Comment On December 05, 2009, at 5:05 PM, jlanganki wrote:

    All metrics such as P/E are really useless by themselves. It's more important to look at a couple years worth of cash flow and take a look at the balance sheet to identify trends. Also, you should never own something like a car rental company since anyone can start the same business (long term profits will always gravitate towards zero anytime you have high amounts of competition in an industry).

  • Report this Comment On December 05, 2009, at 11:24 PM, baltbear wrote:

    at some point, meaningful i/p is a bottom line consideration. if u look at buffet on burlington rr, unewrneath it all is the real estate deeds, based on the tech revolution of 150 years ago....with a body of "what works??" i/p distilled out.

    and a steady mkt for the output, which in this case is "cheaply moved coal and high weight finished goods."

    some years back buffet got out of mcd becuase he had appoached it as a real estate deal, and lost confidence in the real state pricings. later, he realised it had always been an i/p play..with 30 years of tuning the model.

    i would paraphrase and say it's better to have good execution than excellent ideas.

  • Report this Comment On December 07, 2009, at 6:42 AM, BIGJIMT wrote:

    You did leave one perfect example these last three tears to date. The stock is MDRNA INC(MRNA).

    I know you can't list all the stocks but never the less,

    from $20 dollars down to $.84 cents. And that is after change of name, new CEO, and countless news releases. All early stage pre-clinical testing, and shareholders high on the stock, while company scrambling to attain next years expenses in 2010.

    And fighting off nasdaq warning letters, of compliance,

    with year end earnings report due out in February, and stock price remaining under $1 dollar for 3 weeks or so. Like I said in December 2006, 'MRNA', *IS IN THE ICU UNIT.*

Add your comment.

Compare Brokers

Fool Disclosure

Sponsored Links

Leaked: Apple's Next Smart Device
(Warning, it may shock you)
The secret is out... experts are predicting 458 million of these types of devices will be sold per year. 1 hyper-growth company stands to rake in maximum profit - and it's NOT Apple. Show me Apple's new smart gizmo!

DocumentId: 1059665, ~/Articles/ArticleHandler.aspx, 10/22/2016 5:37:03 PM

Report This Comment

Use this area to report a comment that you believe is in violation of the community guidelines. Our team will review the entry and take any appropriate action.

Sending report...

Today's Market

updated 20 hours ago Sponsored by:
DOW 18,145.71 -16.64 -0.09%
S&P 500 2,141.16 -0.18 -0.01%
NASD 5,257.40 15.57 0.30%

Create My Watchlist

Go to My Watchlist

You don't seem to be following any stocks yet!

Better investing starts with a watchlist. Now you can create a personalized watchlist and get immediate access to the personalized information you need to make successful investing decisions.

Data delayed up to 5 minutes

Related Tickers

5/3/2013 3:59 PM
ABKFQ.DL $20.40 Down +0.00 +0.00%
Ambac Financial Gr… CAPS Rating: ***
FNMA $1.74 Down +0.00 +0.00%
Fannie Mae CAPS Rating: ***
GE $28.98 Down -0.09 -0.31%
General Electric CAPS Rating: ****
ISRG $678.02 Down -3.80 -0.56%
Intuitive Surgical CAPS Rating: ****
KO $42.13 Up +0.20 +0.48%
Coca-Cola CAPS Rating: ****
MNST $147.26 Up +0.65 +0.44%
Monster Beverage CAPS Rating: ***
PCLN $1467.39 Down -0.90 -0.06%
Priceline Group CAPS Rating: ****