New Mortgage Rules May Help More Borrowers Get Home Loans in 2021

Updated - First published on Jan. 22, 2021

Kimberly Rotter, AFC®

By: Kimberly Rotter, AFC®

Accredited Financial Counselor®

Many or all of the products here are from our partners that compensate us. It’s how we make money. But our editorial integrity ensures our experts’ opinions aren’t influenced by compensation. Terms may apply to offers listed on this page.

Think your debt means you can't qualify for a mortgage? This change might make the difference.

To promote access to responsible, affordable mortgages, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) issued two changes to mortgage standards in late 2020. The new mortgage rules will help more borrowers get home loans.

We spoke with Melissa Stegman, senior policy counsel for the Center for Responsible Lending, to find out whether the new mortgage rules are good for consumers, lenders, or both.

What is a qualified mortgage?

To understand the impact of the recent mortgage rule changes, it's important to understand what the status quo was for mortgages prior to 2021.

After the housing market crash and Great Recession, the federal government created a class of mortgage with borrower protections built in. This type of home loan is called the qualified mortgage.

A qualified mortgage has certain stable features that are designed to make the loan less risky. This helps borrowers avoid unaffordable home loans.

More: Check out our picks for the best mortgage lenders

A qualified mortgage generally can't contain these features:

  • Interest-only period (a time where you only pay down interest, not the loan principal)
  • Negative amortization (loan principal increases even though you're making payments)
  • Balloon payments (unusually large payments toward the end of the loan period)
  • Loan term longer than 30 years
  • Excess upfront points and fees

Furthermore, the lender must make an effort to determine that the borrower has the ability to repay the loan (called the ATR rule).

Mortgage DTI limits

Mortgage lenders limit the applicant's debt-to-income ratio (DTI) for most mortgages. Under old qualified mortgage rules, the borrower's DTI -- their total required debt payments plus the proposed housing payment -- could not exceed 43% of their income.

The Center for Responsible Lending says that the DTI limit unfairly excluded certain creditworthy borrowers -- and especially consumers of color.

What are the new mortgage rules?

The first change was an update to qualified mortgage standards.

Because many lenders only make qualified mortgages, if a borrower had a DTI above 43%, the application was denied. At the same time, an exemption allowed many loans to retroactively be considered qualified mortgages even when the borrower did have a DTI over 43%.

What gives?

Mortgage analysts looked back at loan performance data since the Great Recession and found that DTI is not a strong predictor of default. In fact, there is a stronger correlation between the loan's price and its performance.

Stegman explains that DTI needs to be part of holistic underwriting, but not with a strict cutoff. "Too many people were excluded" from home loans, she says. "Data shows that DTI is a limited predictor of mortgage risk. There was too much hyper-focus on this one element ."

The Center for Responsible Lending submitted a letter to the CFPB in support of the removal of the DTI limit. Several national organizations that advocate for the rights of minority and underserved borrowers also signed the letter.

The CFPB agreed with the Center for Responsible Lending and other consumer advocates. Since a loan's price is more closely correlated with the likelihood of default, the DTI limit was eliminated. The Center for Responsible Lending applauded the change.

Lenders are no longer restrained by a 43% DTI to make a qualified mortgage. Instead, a home loan is considered a qualified mortgage if it meets other qualified mortgage requirements, including price limits.

The pricing rule says that the loan's annual percentage rate (APR) must not exceed the average prime offer rate for a comparable transaction by 1.5 percentage points. Lender fees are also limited. For loans over $111,260, upfront points and fees cannot exceed 3% of the loan amount.

It may seem odd to say that a loan's price tag can tell us how likely it is that the borrower will repay the loan. In fact, pricing is not the only factor at play. The lender must also confirm the applicant's income and assets, verify the ability to repay, and otherwise qualify the applicant.

After the new mortgage rules took effect, many lenders raised their DTI limit to 50% or more.

Seasoned QM

The second new mortgage rule creates a new class of mortgage called seasoned QMs (qualified mortgages). This rule applies to non-qualified mortgages that a lender has kept in its portfolio for at least 36 months. Even if the loan didn't originally meet the requirements for qualified mortgage status, it can become a qualified mortgage after three years. To be eligible, the loan must meet QM standards and performance standards. For example, the loan may not have any 60-day delinquencies during the seasoning period.

Why QMs are important to lenders

"Most loans are in the QM space because it's safer for the lender," says Stegman. In exchange for meeting qualified mortgage standards, the lender is protected from legal challenges later on. For example, if you default on your mortgage and the lender forecloses, you might not be able to successfully claim in court that the lender was irresponsible and issued you a loan that you couldn't afford to repay.

"QM standards benefit both the borrower and the lender," adds Stegman. Without them, loan prices would be higher, and some loans would not be made at all.

"QM standards also ensure that the borrower won't be in a loan full of red flags like payment shock or excessive fees," says Stegman. "We encourage lenders to provide the safest loans to borrowers. We want people to have access to responsible, sustainable homeownership."

Our Research Expert

Kimberly Rotter, AFC®
Kimberly Rotter, AFC® icon-button-linkedin-2x icon-button-twitter-2x

Kimberly B. Rotter is a consumer credit and personal finance educator helping everyday people level up from any starting point, to make their financial situation better.

Related Articles

View All Articles Learn More Link Arrow
If You Have a Wells Fargo Savings Account, You Should Switch ASAP. Here's Why
Steven Porrello

By: Steven Porrello | Updated - First published on Nov. 7, 2023

These days, storing your savings in a Wells Fargo account pretty much serves one purpose: Quick access to cash at brick-and-mortar banks or ATMs. But if you have savings you're not spending anytime soon, a Wells Fargo Way2Save Savings account ranks high in the worst places to keep your savings. No offense if Wells Fargo is your favorite bank, but it's time to stop leaving money on the table. Here's why. Wells Fargo can't compare to today's top high-yield savings accounts As of writing this, the Wells Fargo Way2Save Savings account has a 0.15% APY, which is not only lower than the national average (0.60%) but also several times lower than today's top-paying savings accounts. At 0.15%, you'll earn about $15 annually for every $10,000 you save. Not exactly the most exciting reward for saving money. By comparison, many of today's top-paying savings accounts have rates above 5%. Case in point: the Western Alliance Bank High-Yield Savings Account via Raisin. This account has a mouth-watering APY of 5.26%, no fees, and a low opening deposit of $1. At that APY, you'll earn $526 for every $10,000 you save. That's 35 times more than the $15 you would have earned in your Wells Fargo Way2Save Savings account. Of course, the major benefit of the Wells Fargo Way2Save Savings account is that you can access your savings at Wells Fargo branches or via ATMs. That's important if you withdraw cash frequently, as online banks will make you transfer the money electronically to an account with ATM access. But even if accessing cash is important to you, there are still better options than the Wells Fargo Way2Save Savings. For example, the SoFi Checking and Savings account gives you a cash back debit card and access to over 55,000-plus fee-free ATMs. Plus, it has a decent APY of up to 4.60%. That's not the highest APY I've seen, but it's not bad for an account that combines checking and savings into one. What about the Wells Fargo Platinum Savings account?Now, the Wells Fargo Platinum Savings account does have a compelling offer right now. New savings customers can lock into a promotional APY of 4.62% when they sign up for a new Wells Fargo Platinum Savings account before Jan. 9, 2024, and maintain a daily minimum balance of $10,000. The emphasis there is on "new." According to the fine print, this offer is for new savings customers who don't currently have a Wells Fargo savings account -- whether that's Wells Fargo Platinum Savings or the Wells Fargo Way2Save Savings. So if you're already a Wells Fargo client, the bank will likely assign you the account's regular APY, which ranges from 0.25% to 2.51%, depending on balance.Again, if you're saving money at Wells Fargo, there's no question about it -- you're missing out on higher interest rates. You may have good reasons for using Wells Fargo, such as having greater access to your savings. But if you're fine with online banking, then trust me -- you deserve better than a rock-bottom APY. Take a look at today's top-paying savings accounts and see how much more you could be earning for your savings. 
Have a Chase Savings Account? You're Probably Missing Out on $400-Plus per Year
Steven Porrello

By: Steven Porrello | Updated - First published on Nov. 24, 2023

Chase is the largest bank in the U.S., and one of the largest in the world. It has over 4,700 brick-and-mortar locations, more than 15,000 ATMs, and around a couple trillion in bank deposits. But for all this banking power, there's one thing Chase doesn't have: a savings account that can compete in today's high-rate environment. Seems as if a big bank like Chase would have at least one savings account that earned high interest, right? Truth is, banks lose money when they pay high interest rates and will forgo offering them if they don't need to attract customers. As the largest bank in the U.S., Chase is doing just fine and doesn't need high rates to bring in more deposits. But that leaves Chase clients in a bit of a conundrum. Just how much money are you missing out by keeping it in a savings account at Chase? Well, when you start to crunch the numbers, it can be a lot. The average American is probably missing out on $400 per year Today's most competitive rates on savings accounts are sitting at a two-decade high of about 5.25%. Most of these savings accounts are through the company Raisin, which is essentially a marketplace for finding high-yield savings and CDs. Last I checked, the highest rate on Raisin was 5.30% on a Customers Bank High-Yield Savings Account, followed by both VyStar Credit Union and DR Bank at 5.29%. How much could you make on 5.30%? According to a recent survey of U.S. Family Finances by the Federal Reserve, the median savings in 2022 was about $8,000. If you saved $8,000 in the Customers Bank High-Yield Savings Account powered by Raisin, you would earn about $424 within a year. In contrast, a Chase Savings Account pays out at a rock-bottom APY of 0.01%. At that rate, it's almost pointless to do the math but if you like your copper Abes, you'd make about $0.80 on $8,000 in 12 months.When is a Chase savings account worth it? I'm not going to lie -- I have a Chase account. I don't keep a lot of money in it, but I do keep some. The reason is that I live four blocks from the Chase bank in downtown Portland and like the security of having some money within reach. When I need to withdraw cash (rare but it happens), I can just go in person and use the ATM. And when I need to deposit cash -- birthday money, thanks Mom -- I can do it without jumping through hoops. If you want banking convenience like this, a high-yield savings account through Raisin or any other online bank will likely frustrate you. Raisin is a case in point: When you deposit money in a Raisin-powered account, you transfer it from an external account (which could be a savings account at Chase) into a service bank (Lewis & Clark Bank), which is then transferred into a custodial account at the bank account of your choice (a Customers Bank High-Yield Savings Account or a Western Alliance Bank High-Yield Savings Account, for example). If you want to withdraw this money, you have to transfer it back to your external account, which could take a few business days. For those who need cash fast, each nail-biting day might make that high yield not worth the stress. So you might have to diversify. Truthfully, it's best to keep a little money within easy access for emergencies, but not so much that you miss out on today's high rates. If you've engorged your Chase Savings Account, take a look at some other top-paying savings accounts to see how much you could earn in interest. If your savings is anywhere near the median -- $8,000 -- you could potentially pick up at least $400 on your savings. 
Are CDs a Good Investment for 2024?
Steven Porrello

By: Steven Porrello | Updated - First published on Nov. 28, 2023

Certificates of deposit (CDs) offer high guaranteed returns in exchange for locking your money up at a bank or credit union for a term that you choose. While lackluster in previous years, CD rates have taken off in 2023, aided in large part by the Federal Reserve's continued interest rate hikes. These days, it's not rare to find a short-term CD paying out at a rate above 5%, with some paying out as high as 5.70%.With only a few weeks left in 2023, many of these CDs look like good investments going into the new year. But are they? If you're thinking about investing in one soon, let's take a look at what we know.Short-term CDs could make great investments, but don't ignore longer termsRight now, you can find the highest rates on short-term CDs, like those ranging from three to 18 months. For example, on Raisin's CD marketplace, all the CDs paying above 5% are within that short-term range.This isn't a coincidence. Rather, it reflects the expectation that interest rates will fall sometime in the future. Banks want to keep their CD rates competitive, but if they're paying 5.70% for five years, they could end up losing money.If your goal is to earn interest at a high rate, a short-term CD could be a good investment, especially if you're hesitant to lock into a longer term. Now might even be the best time to build out a CD ladder, combining short and long terms to stretch out today's high rates for longer periods.That said, I wouldn't ignore long-term CDs on the grounds that their rates are lower today. It's possible the Fed could start reversing course in 2024, hiking down rates to a more sustainable level. If that holds true, today's short term CDs could very well mature at a time when CD rates are much lower. You might lock into a 5.70% CD for six months, but a 4-year CD at 4.50% could freeze an elevated rate for a few years longer.A no-penalty CD could make a good investmentA major problem with CDs is that they come with early withdrawal penalties. These penalties are often equal to a few months worth of interest, though some could be as high as six to 12 months. If you withdraw from your CD before your term is up, you'll pay this penalty, which could sometimes result in you losing money.One way around this is to get a no-penalty CD. These CDs typically have a very brief no-withdrawal period, usually seven days or less, after which you can liquidate your CD account with no penalty. Traditionally, no-penalty CDs have low interest rates compared with regular CDs with the same term. But in today's high rate environment, you could easily pick up a no-penalty CD with an APY above 5%.For example, Raisin has several no-penalty CDs on its marketplace. As of writing this, the highest paying no-penalty CD comes from Greenwood Credit Union with a 5.37% APY and 12-month term. Other close contenders include Technology Credit Union (5.36%, five-month term) and Mission Valley Bank (5.35%, three-month term).What's great about these CDs is that you could break your contract to capture a different APY or longer term at a later date. Let's say, for instance, that the Fed indicates it's going to start lowering interest rates in 2024. You decide you're going to lock into a 4% rate on a 3-year CD. If you have your money tied up in a no-penalty CD, you could easily navigate out of the contract and open a new CD account. Likewise, if you have emergency savings, a no-penalty CD could help you earn at a higher interest rate, though I would recommend you consider a high-yield savings account first.Will CD rates stay elevated in 2024?CD rates are at a two-decade high, but they won't stay this high for much longer. Once the Fed feels confident inflation is under control, it won't be long before rates start to fall. I'd say if you're in the market for a CD, now is a great time to lock into one of today's top paying CDs. Take a look at different terms and see how much interest you could earn in 2024.
What Happens if Someone Sues You for More Than Your Car Insurance Will Pay For?
Christy Bieber

By: Christy Bieber | Updated - First published on Dec. 2, 2023

Car accidents can be extremely expensive. In fact, according to the National Safety Council, the average economic costs of a fatal crash were close to $1.78 million, while the average costs associated with a disabling car accident were $155,000.Despite these huge potential costs, drivers aren't required to buy nearly that much insurance. In fact, depending on the state, drivers may be able to get away with having just $15,000 per person and $30,000 per incident in bodily injury liability coverage.With such low auto insurance limits, it's very possible a motorist could cause an accident and do much more damage than insurance will cover. The big question then is, what happens if a motorist causes an accident and is being sued for more than the insurance policy's maximum limits?Drivers could be sued personally for any extra losses insurance won't coverIf a driver is sued for more than the limits of their liability insurance policy, their auto insurer will only cover legal fees and damages up to the amount required based on the policy terms. So a driver who caused $155,000 in disabling injuries to someone and who had $15,000 in bodily injury liability coverage would see their insurer pay just $15,000 -- leaving $140,000 in uncompensated losses for the crash victims.These losses don't just go away, and in some cases, victims will decide to pursue a lawsuit against the at-fault driver personally. In other words, they will go to court and try to get a judgment that the driver would have to pay out of their own bank account. And, depending on the circumstances, courts could potentially enforce that judgment by ordering the at-fault driver's wages be garnished (a portion of them is taken) or by putting a lien on the at-fault driver's property (asserting an ownership claim to their home or other assets).Because of the risk to personal assets, having only the minimum auto insurance coverage is a huge risk.Be sure to buy the right auto insurance coverageDrivers should think very carefully about whether they will end up regretting purchasing only minimum coverage insurance. It's true that it is cheaper not to buy a ton of liability protection, but that's only if nothing goes wrong.Switching from a car insurance policy with a $10,000 per person and $20,000 per accident limit to a policy with a $250,000 per person and $500,000 per accident limit raises premiums by around $47 per month for a 40-year-old female SUV driver in Florida with a clean record purchasing coverage from a major insurer. That's a significant bump, but it's a lot less than getting stuck with a personal lawsuit that ends up costing tens or even hundreds of thousands or millions of dollars.Being sued personally after an accident and not having enough insurance could be a really devastating, frightening experience, and the only way to prevent this from happening is to have the right insurance in place before this occurs. Drivers should review their policies today to make sure they aren't at risk of huge losses if a crash occurs. Those who find they don't have enough coverage to protect their assets may want to act quickly by increasing their insurance coverage ASAP.
The 5 Best Men's Gifts to Buy at Sam's Club
Dana George

By: Dana George | Updated - First published on Nov. 26, 2023

If you're going to pick up a sweet deal from Sam's Club this holiday season, you're going to want to order it online, as many of the items featured in its catalog are not available in all stores. And if you're going to shop for, purchase, and wrap a gift, you want it to be "just right." Here are five gift ideas for the special men in your life that may fit the bill without totally draining your checking account. Prices are accurate at time of writing, but are subject to change.1. The Ninja Woodfire™ Outdoor Grill & Smoker: $300Why we like it: This grill and smoker may be small enough to sit on a picnic table, but it packs a powerful punch. You achieve all the performance of a full-size grill (including the char and searing) without the space-gobbling size of a large grill. If you know someone who's interested in smoking meats, all this foolproof system requires is 1/2 cup of wood pellets. Electronically powered with 120 Volts, it carries a 1-year limited warranty. Oh, and it's also priced $170 lower than the same model at Walmart. That's an extra $170 to put toward something less fun, like homeowners insurance.2. Chef iQ Smart Thermometer 3 Probe + Hub: $150Why we like it: This Smart Thermometer takes the guesswork out of grilling. If a man in your life considers himself quite the gourmet chef, he's going to love having such a sophisticated thermometer at his fingertips. Chef iQ uses an advanced algorithm to calculate the precise cooking time and temperatures, getting the meat just right every time. The fact that the probe is ultra-thin means meat is left intact and better able to hold in the juices. If you were to buy it on Amazon, you would pay $30 more.3. ProForm 25 lbs. Select-a-Weight Dumbbell Set: $30Why we like it: What's great about this dumbbell set is the revolutionary Easy-Adjust Weight Selection system. It takes just a moment for the user to modify the weight so their time can be better spent working out. The durable steel set stays secure in a storage tray that clearly shows the total weight of the dumbbell at each adjustment. A similar set goes for $100 on Amazon.4. Lee Men's Workwear Vest: $20Why we like it: If you haven't shopped for men's garments at Sam's Club lately, you might be surprised to learn how many brands the warehouse carries. This vest manages to look tough and stylish at the same time and comes in three colors: tobacco, black, and chocolate. If you're interested, you might want to pick one up while sizes small to xxx-large are still available.5. MSI 31.5" FHD Curved 250 Hz 1ms FreeSync Gaming Monitor: $199Why we like it: The FreeSync Gaming Monitor is built with a speedy 250 hz refresh rate + 1ms response time VA LED panel. It's great for fast-paced games like racing, sports, and fights. In short, if a game requires fast movements, this monitor can handle it. In addition to a multi-monitor 180-degree set-up, your gamer is sure to appreciate the way it syncs the refresh rate of the monitor with their GPU to eliminate the irritation of stuttering.As we're all looking for ways to save money this holiday season, it's good to know that Sam's Club has a wide selection of gift ideas at a reasonable price.
View All Articles Learn More Link Arrow