Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Are ETFs Cutting Corners?

By Selena Maranjian – Updated Apr 6, 2017 at 12:49PM

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

This practice makes sense for funds, but could mean pain for you.

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are mutual funds that trade on the markets like stocks. Investors like them because of the easy way they supposedly offer returns that closely match their underlying indexes -- but that assumption could be wrong. It turns out that some ETFs have been delivering returns significantly different than expected.

Citing a Morgan Stanley study, Dow Jones recently reported that ETFs had an average tracking error of 1.25 percentage points, more than double 2008's 0.52-percentage-point average.

It seems that most ETFs don't completely mimic their underlying indexes -- for reasons that admittedly make sense. You'd assume that any fund intending to mimic the S&P 500 would buy all 500 companies, but some don't. The same goes for many other ETFs and their respective indexes.

The table below may help explain why:

Company

Rank by Size in the S&P 500

Weight in the S&P 500

Market Cap

ExxonMobil (NYSE: XOM)

1

3.08%

$309 billion

Microsoft (Nasdaq: MSFT)

2

2.18%

$249 billion

Apple (Nasdaq: AAPL)

3

1.87%

$191 billion

Procter & Gamble (NYSE: PG)

4

1.84%

$185 billion

Eastman Kodak (NYSE: EK)

497

0.02%

$1.6 billion

New York Times (NYSE: NYT)

498

0.01%

$1.7 billion

Meredith

499

0.01%

$1.5 billion

Titanium Metals (NYSE: TIE)

500

0.01%

$2.3 billion

Sources: Yahoo! Finance, indexArb.com. As of March 3.

As you can see, scores of companies, even powerful performers, make up only tiny fractions of the index. Fund managers can easily decide to leave some of them out, reaping the benefits of lower commission costs by not having to buy and sell them.

Big and small differences
When managed effectively, ETFs that own just a subset of their indexes can perform well, closely mirroring their supposed sources. But in recent years, some have diverged widely. According to Dow Jones:

  • In 2009, the iShares MSCI Emerging Markets Index ETF fell short of its benchmark by 6.7 percentage points.
  • Some new bond funds have posted even worse showings. The SPDR Barclays Capital High Yield Bond ETF returned 50.5%, 13 percentage points less than its index.
  • Sometimes, the discrepancies actually work in investors' favor. The Vanguard Telecom Services ETF returned 29.6%, versus just a 12.6% return for its benchmark.

In the past few years, the market has swung widely, which may have amplified otherwise small differences. In addition, over the long haul these discrepancies may even out, resulting in largely similar average returns between ETFs and their underlying indexes.

Despite these differences, you shouldn't dismiss ETFs out of hand. They're still a great way to gain easy entry into otherwise tricky sectors, including attractive foreign markets. Still, it's good to remember the potential for divergent performance between an ETF and its index. Keep an eye on your ETFs' performance to make sure they're delivering no less than they've promised.

Should ETFs be allowed to leave out some index holdings? Is that a savvy move, or a dirty trick? Sound off in the comment box below.

A free exchange of further Foolishness:

Longtime Fool contributor Selena Maranjian owns shares of Procter & Gamble, Microsoft, and Apple. Apple and Titanium Metals are Motley Fool Stock Advisor picks. Motley Fool Options has recommended a diagonal call position on Microsoft, which is a Motley Fool Inside Value recommendation. The Fool owns shares of Procter & Gamble, which is a Motley Fool Income Investor selection. Try any of our investing newsletter services free for 30 days. The Motley Fool is Fools writing for Fools.

Invest Smarter with The Motley Fool

Join Over 1 Million Premium Members Receiving…

  • New Stock Picks Each Month
  • Detailed Analysis of Companies
  • Model Portfolios
  • Live Streaming During Market Hours
  • And Much More
Get Started Now

Stocks Mentioned

Microsoft Corporation Stock Quote
Microsoft Corporation
MSFT
$237.92 (-1.27%) $-3.06
Apple Inc. Stock Quote
Apple Inc.
AAPL
$150.43 (-1.51%) $-2.31
Exxon Mobil Corporation Stock Quote
Exxon Mobil Corporation
XOM
$85.75 (-5.32%) $-4.82
The Procter & Gamble Company Stock Quote
The Procter & Gamble Company
PG
$135.58 (-0.46%) $0.63
The New York Times Company Stock Quote
The New York Times Company
NYT
$27.97 (-2.58%) $0.74
Eastman Kodak Stock Quote
Eastman Kodak
KODK
$4.84 (-1.22%) $0.06
Titanium Metals Corporation Stock Quote
Titanium Metals Corporation
TIE.DL

*Average returns of all recommendations since inception. Cost basis and return based on previous market day close.

Related Articles

Motley Fool Returns

Motley Fool Stock Advisor

Market-beating stocks from our award-winning analyst team.

Stock Advisor Returns
329%
 
S&P 500 Returns
106%

Calculated by average return of all stock recommendations since inception of the Stock Advisor service in February of 2002. Returns as of 09/24/2022.

Discounted offers are only available to new members. Stock Advisor list price is $199 per year.

Premium Investing Services

Invest better with The Motley Fool. Get stock recommendations, portfolio guidance, and more from The Motley Fool's premium services.