Published in: Buying Stocks | Dec. 3, 2018
TD Ameritrade vs. Robinhood: Comparing Low Cost Brokers
By: Jordan Wathen
Don’t pick a broker on costs alone. When comparing TD Ameritrade vs. Robinhood, the differences come down to more than just the price of each trade.
Image source: Getty Images.
These days it seems there are as many brokers as there are investments to buy with them, which can result in "paralysis by analysis," as the differences in brokers are numerous. But by sticking to the details that really matter to investors -- costs, investment selection, platforms, and more -- it’s easier to review which broker is better on the features that matter most.
In this face-off of TD Ameritrade vs. Robinhood below, we’ll get the heart of the difference-making features that may sway you one way or another.
Types of accounts
Investors who are on the fence about opening an account at TD Ameritrade or Robinhood may find that the types of accounts that each broker offers is reason enough to pick TD Ameritrade over Robinhood.
Currently, Robinhood only offers taxable brokerage accounts. So, if you want to get the tax benefits of using a traditional IRA, Roth IRA, SEP IRA, a health savings account (HSA), a 529 College Savings Plan, and so on, Robinhood isn’t the place for you. This is by far the biggest trade-off with Robinhood, which otherwise has a compelling value proposition because it offers so many services for free (we’ll get to that next).
TD Ameritrade offers taxable brokerage accounts, but it also offers just about any tax-advantaged account you can think of. If you’re looking to open anything other than a taxable brokerage account, then TD Ameritrade gets an easy win over Robinhood.
Trading costs and commissions
|Broker||Stocks and ETFs||Stock options||Mutual funds|
|TD Ameritrade||$6.95 per trade||$6.95 plus $0.75 per contract||$49.99 (thousands for free)|
Based entirely on price, Robinhood has a clear cut advantage for anyone who wants to trade stocks, ETFs, and stock options. That said, TD Ameritrade bridges some of the pricing gap by offering thousands of mutual funds you can buy or sell for free, as well as hundreds of commission-free ETFs that you can trade without paying its base commission of $6.95 per trade.
Commission-free funds and ETF trades
Just because a brokerage charges a commission to make a trade doesn’t mean that all trades come with a commission. Though Robinhood offers trades for free, TD Ameritrade also offers thousands of funds and ETFs you can trade without paying a transaction fee or commission.
|Fund type||Robinhood||TD Ameritrade|
|Total mutual funds||None||More than 12,500|
|No-transaction-fee mutual funds||None||More than 1,900|
|Commission-free ETFs||All ETFs are commission free||More than 300|
Of course, transaction fees and commissions are but one price you pay to actually buy a fund or ETF. Over time, a fund’s unavoidable management fee, which typically ranges from 0.05% to 1% of the amount invested each year, can easily add up to more than the cost of buying or selling a certain fund or ETF.
One of the biggest advantages to online brokers are lower investment minimums. TD Ameritrade and Robinhood are leaders here, as they have no minimum accounts. That is to say that you can open an account and deposit just $1 if you wanted to.
TD Ameritrade and Robinhood offer a very different user experience, which is the result of the fact they have two very different business models.
We’ll start first with Robinhood, which doesn’t offer a fully-featured trading platform. Robinhood’s mobile app and web browser platform are simplistic by design. Load up your account and you’ll see a simple chart for any stock and ETF, a summary of key metrics, a breakdown of analyst ratings, and a list of headlines about the stock or fund.
Robinhood’s clutter-free design makes it really easy to navigate and use, but its simplicity is also a by-product of the fact it doesn’t offer that many features. You won’t find full analyst reports, or any financial data that goes beyond a stock’s earnings per share in recent accounting periods. But, again, it’s important to remember that Robinhood doesn’t charge you anything to make a trade, and for something that costs nothing, it does offer everything you’d need, just not everything you might want.
TD Ameritrade is almost on the opposite end of the spectrum, as it offers far more features in its mobile apps and browser platforms than Robinhood. In addition, TD Ameritrade also offers a desktop trading platform, thinkorswim, which is a perennial favorite among active traders, investors, and professional reviewers alike.
From complex charting tools to live video feeds, Level II quotes, and economic data from the Federal Reserve, you can find just about anything you’d need from within the thinkorswim platform. Best of all, it’s completely customizable, so you can move windows around as you see fit so that what’s most important to you is always front and center.
And unlike many other trading platforms out there, thinkorswim is available to TD Ameritrade customers no matter how much you keep in your account, or how much you trade. Said simply, if there is one thing that separates TD Ameritrade from the pack, it’s that it offers one of the most powerful trading platforms out there, and doesn’t charge you anything to use it.
International stocks and ADRs
TD Ameritrade and Robinhood don't offer access to foreign markets. TD Ameritrade clients can purchase American depositary receipts (ADRs), which trade on U.S. stock exchanges.
Robinhood only recently introduced ADRs on its platform, and it doesn’t offer all of them. It offers “over 250” ADRs, which it says includes companies like “Tencent, Nintendo, and Adidas.” It’s seemingly moving country by country to add the largest ADRs. In a blog post, it said that it will “expand the global list with stocks from France, including most frequently searched companies Ubisoft Entertainment, LVMH, and Michelin.”
If being able to trade ADRs is important to you, TD Ameritrade is likely the better pick, since not every ADR is available on Robinhood. As for trading directly on international markets, Fidelity and Charles Schwab may be worth studying more closely, as both offer online access to foreign markets that Robinhood and TD Ameritrade do not.
Research quality and tools
TD Ameritrade offers investors access to third-party and proprietary research tools. It includes access to Morningstar, S&P Capital IQ, and Thomson Reuters research, among other third-party providers. In addition, it offers its clients access to proprietary research and tools to screen stocks and funds by fundamental performance, and it even tracks social-media sites like Twitter for investor sentiment.
Robinhood does not currently offer third-party or proprietary research to its clients. Its research suite is primarily comprised of news feeds from free publications and average sell-side research estimates. As it's a no-frills brokerage, saving on commissions does come with some trade-offs in the research department.
TD Ameritrade vs. Robinhood: How to decide
There are a few “make-or-break” features that make it easy to decide between using TD Ameritrade and Robinhood. First, if you want to open any account other than a taxable account (IRAs, health savings accounts, college savings plans, etc.) then TD Ameritrade is the best way to go. Robinhood doesn’t offer those types of accounts… yet.
Secondly, TD Ameritrade is the only broker to offer a full list of American depositary receipts and mutual funds. Robinhood only offers select ADRs and doesn’t offer any mutual funds. TD Ameritrade is the only one of the two to offer a fully-featured desktop trading platform, too.
Of course, Robinhood has its place for some investors who prioritize the cost of making a trade over everything else. Though it may not offer much in the way of research or supplemental features, it’s hard to beat its commission prices, which are exactly $0 for stocks, options, and ETFs. Investors who want to start small and place trades for a handful of shares at a time might be better off with a broker that doesn’t charge a commission per trade, making Robinhood the best choice for infrequent traders who are looking for a low-cost home for their taxable accounts.
Using the wrong broker could cost you serious money
Over the long term, there's been no better way to grow your wealth than investing in the stock market. But using the wrong broker could make a big dent in your investing returns. Our experts have ranked and reviewed the top online stock brokers - simply click here to see the results and learn how to take advantage of the free trades and cash bonuses that our top-rated brokers are offering.