These 5 Cities Have Surprisingly Affordable Car Insurance Premiums

Many or all of the products here are from our partners that compensate us. It’s how we make money. But our editorial integrity ensures our experts’ opinions aren’t influenced by compensation. Terms may apply to offers listed on this page.

KEY POINTS

  • Insurance companies consider a driver's location when setting rates.
  • Areas prone to more accidents, thefts, and vandalism usually bring higher monthly premiums.
  • There are steps all drivers can take to reduce their car insurance costs.


You wouldn't know these were some of the largest cities in the country looking at these insurance rates.

Big cities generally aren't known for being affordable, especially for those who own cars. Drivers have to pay for parking just about everywhere they go, not to mention gas and maintenance. Then, there's auto insurance, which tends to be higher in cities due to an increased risk of accidents and theft.

But this isn't true everywhere. In fact, the following five cities offer surprisingly affordable rates on car insurance premiums.

The five cities with the cheapest average car insurance premiums

These five cities have the lowest average monthly car insurance premiums out of the 50 largest cities in the U.S., according to doxo.

  1. Minneapolis, Minnesota ($102 per month)
  2. San Diego, California ($120 per month)
  3. Dallas, Texas ($122 per month)
  4. Sacramento, California ($123 per month)
  5. Saint Paul, Minnesota ($123 per month)

But it's important to note that drivers in these cities can still see premiums that are far off this average. Insurance companies don't just look at a driver's city. They also look at the specific ZIP code and the likelihood of accidents and crime in that area, along with the driver's own history of accidents, their age, marital status, education level, vehicle make and model, and other factors.

To make this even more complex, each insurer weighs these factors a little differently, which is why they all give the same driver different quotes. Some put more emphasis on a driver's location while others give more weight to whether they have any speeding tickets. Since each company's formula for calculating premiums is proprietary, the only way to know what it can offer a specific driver is to get quotes.

Three steps drivers can take to reduce their car insurance premiums

Here are three steps all drivers can take to reduce how much they pay for their auto insurance:

1. Compare quotes from several companies

Drivers should get quotes from a handful of companies before they purchase a policy. While price is an important factor, it shouldn't be the only one. Drivers also need to weigh the level of coverage they're getting, the company's financial stability, and the quality of its customer service and claims handling.

Reading car insurance reviews is a quick way to get an overview of the strengths and weaknesses of each company. Then, combine this with pricing information to decide which offers the greatest value.

2. Consider usage-based car insurance

An increasing number of insurers offer usage-based car insurance as an option to interested customers. This monitors a driver's habits via a mobile app or a small device installed in the vehicle and rewards safer and less frequent drivers with savings. Many companies that offer these programs give drivers an upfront discount just for joining.

However, it's up to each person to decide if they're comfortable having their driving habits monitored. Though most companies swear they won't use the data they gather against policyholders if it reveals unsafe habits, some may raise rates in future policy periods. It's best to talk to the insurer about what data it will collect and how it will use it before joining one of these programs.

3. Choose a higher deductible

Auto insurance deductibles are the out-of-pocket costs the policyholder pays when filing a claim before the insurance company will pay anything for the damages. Most companies offer drivers a variety of deductibles to choose from. Selecting a higher one can reduce your monthly premiums significantly.

Those who are worried about the financial strain they could face if they have to file a claim should set aside the money they're saving on premiums each month in an emergency fund until they have enough to cover the policy's deductible.

It's impossible to say what kind of savings a driver will end up with by taking these steps because car insurance is so personalized. But it's a pretty good bet that most drivers will notice a significant difference in their premiums, regardless of where they live, by taking one or more of these actions.

Our best car insurance companies for 2024

Ready to shop for car insurance? Whether you’re focused on price, claims handling, or customer service, we've researched insurers nationwide to provide our best-in-class picks for car insurance coverage. Read our free expert review today to get started.

Our Research Expert

Related Articles

View All Articles Learn More Link Arrow