Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

This device is too small

If you're on a Galaxy Fold, consider unfolding your phone or viewing it in full screen to best optimize your experience.

Skip to main content

The Best Cheap Colorado Homeowners Insurance for 2023

Updated Feb. 21, 2023
Kailey Hagen
By: Kailey Hagen

Our Insurance Expert

Many or all of the products here are from our partners that compensate us. It’s how we make money. But our editorial integrity ensures our experts’ opinions aren’t influenced by compensation. Terms may apply to offers listed on this page.

Colorado homeowners pay a pretty penny for home insurance. But it's possible to score a below-average rate by choosing the best Colorado home insurance provider. Here's a look at which companies offer the best homeowners insurance in Colorado for several common scenarios.

  • Cheapest overall for Colorado: State Auto Insurance
  • Cheapest for new home construction: State Auto Insurance
  • Cheapest for older homes: State Auto Insurance
  • Cheapest for homeowners who have filed a claim: State Auto Insurance

Cheapest overall for Colorado

The average Colorado home insurance policy costs about $2,179 per year. But homeowners who choose State Auto Insurance can get coverage for just over a quarter of that. Its average annual premium is $655.


Logo for StateAuto
Best Overall for Colorado HomeownersStateAuto
Rating image, 4.00 out of 5 stars.
4.00 stars
Circle with letter I in it. Our ratings are based on a 5 star scale. 5 stars equals Best. 4 stars equals Excellent. 3 stars equals Good. 2 stars equals Fair. 1 star equals Poor. We want your money to work harder for you. Which is why our ratings are biased toward offers that deliver versatility while cutting out-of-pocket costs.
= Best
= Excellent
= Good
= Fair
= Poor

These insurance companies also offer cheap homeowners insurance in Colorado:

  • Great Northern Insurance, part of the Chubb insurance group, which charges homeowners about $1,492 per year on average
  • Colorado Farm Bureau Insurance, which charges about $1,509 per year for Colorado home insurance

Cheapest for new home construction

New homes only cost about $1,151 per year to insure in Colorado. But once again, State Auto Insurance offers a much more competitive rate. New homeowners only pay about $413 per year.

These insurers are also some of the best homeowners insurance companies in Colorado for new construction:

  • Nationwide, where the average annual premium for new homeowners is $579
  • Auto-Owners Insurance, which charges about $732 on average for Colorado home insurance for new homes

Cheapest for older homes

State Auto Insurance also offers competitive rates on older homes in Colorado. Its average annual premium for a 50-year-old home was just $577 -- well below the state average of $1,975 per year.

These companies also offer some of the best homeowners insurance in Colorado for older homes:

  • Auto-Owners Insurance, which charges older homeowners about $994 per year
  • Farmers, where a Colorado homeowner pays about $1,282 per year on average

Cheapest for homeowners who have filed a claim

Filing a home insurance claim raises the average annual Colorado home insurance premium to $2,271. But those who choose State Auto Insurance barely see their prices change. Its average annual premium for homeowners who have filed one claim is just $646.

These companies also offer cheap Colorado home insurance to homeowners who have filed a claim:

  • Auto-Owners Insurance, which charges these homeowners about $1,025 per year
  • Colorado Farm Bureau Insurance, where these homeowners pay about $1,426 per year

Average home insurance cost in Colorado compared to the national average

Colorado home insurance rates are well above the national average for all home types. Here's a look at how its average annual premiums stack up to the national average for the categories listed above.

Average Rate Category Colorado National Average
Overall $2,179 $1,725
New home construction $1,151 $943
Older homes $1,975 $1,658
When making a claim $2,271 $1,803
Data source: Quadrant data.

Colorado homeowners insurance overview

Here are a few things Colorado homeowners ought to know when shopping for homeowners insurance:

Colorado homes are more expensive than the national average

The typical home in Colorado costs about $490,944, according to The Ascent's research on average home prices by state. This is quite a bit above the national average of $293,349. It may help explain why insurance rates are above average in the state.

More expensive homes typically cost more to insure, so it stands to reason that higher average home prices would translate to higher Colorado home insurance prices as well.

But it's important to note that home cost isn't the only significant factor. The quality of the home's fixtures, its claims history, and its location within the state also affect how much it costs to insure.

Eastern Colorado sees the highest average home insurance rates

Cities close to Colorado's eastern border tend to pay higher average rates than cities further to the west. Some of these towns even pay more than Denver residents, who have average annual premiums of $2,670 per year.

Residents of eastern Colorado will have to spend some more time comparing rates from several companies in order to find a competitive offer.

What are the most common homeowners insurance claims in Colorado?

Here's a look at some of the most common home insurance claims in Colorado:

Hail damage

Colorado has the second-highest number of hail damage claims of any state in the nation, according to the Insurance Information Institute. Severe hailstorms can cause damage to roofs, windows, and personal property. Recent years have seen record-breaking storms, which have only driven Colorado home insurance costs higher.

Many insurance companies now charge customers a separate wind and hail deductible that's often higher than the standard home insurance deductible. If a customer plans to file a claim for hail damage, they must pay the higher hail deductible before their insurer will pay out.


Like many states out west, wildfires are common in Colorado. In fact, it has the third-highest risk of wildfires in the nation, according to the Insurance Information Institute. Wildfires can easily burn an entire home to the ground, resulting in costly losses. That's why it's crucial for homeowners who live in areas prone to wildfires to ensure they purchase adequate insurance. This way, they'll have the money they need if they ever have to rebuild from scratch.

Flood damage

Floods occur in all states and Colorado is no exception. Floods can damage foundations and destroy property, and this damage actually isn't covered under a traditional home insurance policy. Homeowners who live in an area prone to floods should invest in a separate flood insurance policy.

Homeowners insurance coverage options and discounts in Colorado

Here's a look at how some popular home insurance discounts can affect Colorado premiums:

New roofs bring steep discounts

Unsurprisingly, in a state plagued by hail damage, insurers are eager to reward customers with new roofs. Having a roof replaced drops the average Colorado home insurance premium to $1,694 per year. Homeowners who get a new roof should definitely notify their insurance company or shop around to see if they can find a better rate than what they're currently paying.

Updating heating or plumbing gives you more bang for your buck than electrical systems

Many insurers give homeowners discounts for upgrading older homes. But not all system upgrades are created equal. While a new heating or plumbing system dropped the average annual Colorado home insurance premium down to $2,027 and $2,026, respectively, a new electrical system only dropped the price to $2,125 per year.

Bundling is still the best way to save

There are many ways to save on Colorado home insurance, but the largest single discount comes from bundling home and auto insurance. Colorado homeowners who are also looking to insure their vehicles should look for a single company that can insure them both. Not only does bundling car insurance make the policies easier to manage, but it also cuts the average Colorado home insurance premium to $1,675 per year.

5 cheapest cities in Colorado for homeowners insurance

The following five cities have the cheapest average Colorado home insurance rates:

City Name Average Home Insurance Rate
Orchard Mesa $1,127
Redlands $1,139
Fruita $1,139
Grand Junction $1,144
Loma $1,172
Data source: Quadrant data.

5 most expensive cities in Colorado for homeowners insurance

These five cities have the most expensive average Colorado home insurance rates:

City Name Average Home Insurance Rate
Burlington $3,259
Arapahoe $3,226
Ovid $3,222
Bethune $3,215
Stratton $3,213
Data source: Quadrant data.

Our Insurance Expert