This commentary was first published on Nov. 19, 2003. It has been updated.
Everyone I know is looking for the next stock market star -- the one buy that makes you rich. A true hidden gem. The acorn that finds its niche, surges into an oak, and reaches to the sky for years -- like Dell Computer
Peter Lynch called these stocks 10- and 20-baggers, and they make for great adventure -- particularly when you don't have to take on much risk. And believe it or not, you don't. Yet too many investors do take on too much risk searching for the Next Big Thing. Too often, they speculate recklessly because they've never learned how to find, much less value, the most compelling companies.
The nest egg, not the shells
Here's the problem: Rather than study and emulate the strategies of the masters (Buffett, Graham, and Lynch), they gamble on low-quality story stocks. Having shunned research for whispers and rumors, they're left holding the broken eggshells of fourth-rate hyped growth stocks rather than a nest egg of great companies churning out market-punishing returns.
Let's make sure you end up with the growing nest, not the broken shells.
Over the years, I've developed a number of basic principles that have helped me do just that. These principles are part of the foundation of my Hidden Gems style of investing and guide me as I screen the universe of small-cap stocks for the most likely 10-, 20-, and 50-baggers of the next decade. Let's focus on three -- criteria first, then hidden gems.
1. Significant insider ownership
I'm always surprised at how many investors are uninterested in a company's ownership structure. Significant insider ownership is a primary driver of superior, long-term returns. After all, doesn't a neighbor take better care of his home than, say, the tenants at Delta Theta Chi fraternity?
The same is true with companies. It's no fluke that Microsoft
Criteria One: Insider ownership should exceed 20%.
2. Generous return on assets (ROA)
Too many investors are so tightly focused on earnings per share that they disregard the fundamental drivers of real value. Among the most important and least studied of these is a company's return on assets. Simply put, this measures how much profit a company creates for each dollar of assets. Divide net income by total assets and you have a basic read on management effectiveness. (ROA is a close cousin of another important metric -- ROE).
If you concentrate on companies that generate more than 10 cents of profit for every $1 of assets, you'll narrow the universe of stocks to the most adaptable and profitable companies in America. A company like Dell, with a strong competitive advantage in inventory management, boasts an ROA above 15%. Conversely, beleaguered General Motors, beset by competition and forever struggling with labor issues, returns less than 1%. Little wonder GM traded higher in 1994 than it does today.
Criteria Two: ROA north of 10%.
3. Little institutional attention
Finally, I love to find small-cap stocks followed by fewer than five analysts. I particularly like it when total institutional ownership is south of 25%. This provides us, as private investors, a chance to get in ahead of the big-money mutual fund and pension fund managers.
One of my successful Hidden Gems recommendations is Mine Safety Appliances
Criteria Three: Fewer than five analysts following and less than 40% institutionally owned.
Three rising stars
Now the payoff -- three companies that make the grade. Moreover, all three satisfy the more than two dozen other factors I consider before recommending any stock. I don't own positions in any, but all three have been featured on my short Hidden Gems Watch List:
Marine Products Corp.
Healthcare Services Group
When this article first ran, I talked about Papa John's
Learning from the masters
So there you have it. I don't make this stuff up. I've dedicated myself to the classic works of investors and teachers like Warren Buffett, Benjamin Graham, Peter Lynch, Bernard Baruch, Charles Royce, and dozens of others. Each made millions or billions applying simple mathematical logic, an enthusiasm for business, a knack for spotting an expanding market, and the patience to let their winners run. I return to them each month when selecting my Hidden Gems recommendations.
If you would like to read more about my approach, and study my Hidden Gems recommendations to date, you can take a free 30-day trial with no obligation to subscribe by clicking here.
Give it a whirl on me. I think you'll enjoy it.
More from The Motley Fool
This High-Yield Stock Just Declared Its 95th Dividend Increase
This company also makes monthly dividend payment and has lots of upside potential.
What to Expect When IBM Reports Earnings
The end of Big Blue's infamous streak of slumping sales is near.
Only 39% of Americans Are Ready for a $1,000 Unexpected Expense
Many would have to borrow or use a credit card to pay.