Image source: The Motley Fool.
Designer Brands Inc. (DBI -0.21%)
Q4Â 2019 Earnings Call
Mar 17, 2020, 8:30 a.m. ET
Contents:
- Prepared Remarks
- Questions and Answers
- Call Participants
Prepared Remarks:
Operator
Good morning, and welcome to the Designer Brands Inc. Fourth Quarter 2019 Earnings Conference Call. [Operator Instructions] Please note today's event is being recorded. I would now like to turn the conference over to Stacy Turnof from Edelman. Please go ahead ma'am.
Stacy Turnof -- Senior Vice President at Edelman
Good morning. Earlier today, the Company issued a press release comparing results of operations for the 13-week and 52-week period ending February 1st, 2020 to the 13-week and 52-week period ending February 2nd, 2019.
Please note that remarks made about future expectations, plans and prospects of the Company constitute forward-looking statements. Results may differ materially due to various factors listed in today's press release and the Company's public filings with the SEC. The Company assumes no obligation to update any forward-looking statement.
Joining us today are Roger Rawlins, Chief Executive Officer and Jared Poff, Chief Financial Officer.
Now let me turn over the call to Roger.
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Good morning, and thank you for joining us to discuss our results for the fourth quarter and fiscal 2019. As I'm sure you've all seen, the recent spread of the COVID-19 or coronavirus has caused massive disruption for every industry across the entire world.
First and foremost, our thoughts are with those who have been affected by this virus. Our priority continues to be the health and safety of our employees, customers and the communities in which we operate as well as the viability and stability of our business over the long-term. We've already taken several precautions, implemented new policies, conducted business continuity planning and are meeting daily to monitor this rapidly changing situation.
We are relying on the Centers for Disease Control, World Health Organization, Health Canada and local and U.S. government officials as reliable sources of information to inform our decisions. I am committed to ongoing communication and taking all necessary measures to ensure our customers and associates remain safe.
To that end, we're taking the following steps. To help flatten the curve and protect the welfare and safety of our store associates and customers, we will be temporarily closing all of our North American retail locations effective with the close of business Tuesday, March 17th. In addition to forcing social distancing by these actions, it will also provide us time to conduct further deep cleaning and sanitization services across our entire store fleet, distribution center, and fulfillment center.
Because this situation is incredibly complex and evolving rapidly, our plans may change. Store associates will be compensated for two weeks following the official closure. Our online business, including our app and website remain up and running. Our warehouses will remain open to fulfill our online orders operating under our emergency preparedness plan.
As we assess the extreme fluidity of the unfolding economic impact of this virus, we feel we should exercise an abundance of prudence as it pertains to near-term cash expenditures. As such, we are looking for material SG&A savings we can execute swiftly across our entire business. We are significantly reducing our planned capex for the year, including new store openings, remodels and special projects, and we are reducing our quarterly dividend to $0.10.
You should note however with only modest bank debt levels outstanding and with our proven ability to react quickly to volatile situations, we feel these actions will be temporary in nature and we would expect to return to normal investment and distribution policies as this volatility subsides.
Importantly, all of these actions are aimed at preserving the long-term health of Designer Brands and our plan is to emerge from this with a stronger enterprise as we focus on running our business responsibly and sustainably.
Turning to our results, as it relates to our recent performance, we are monitoring the rapid shifts in consumer behavior that we've seen as recently as last week. For the first 36 days of the quarter, our business was operating exceptionally with solid comps and performance above expectations. However, when precautionary measures and coronavirus cases increased here in the U.S., the impact to our business escalated and we've seen a dramatic reduction in both sales and store traffic as consumer priority shift.
Looking back at our 2019 results, we're disappointed with our performance which was not what we anticipated when we began the year. We know what we can do better and deliver more as an organization. However, our business began to stabilize following the identification of issues in the third quarter and the subsequent steps that we have taken to course correct. We feel we have solidified a base on which we can move forward with executing our strategic initiatives, even in the midst of unprecedented challenges. We saw comps of 0.8% for fiscal 2019.
Gross margins decreased by 110 basis points. Notably, both cost and gross margins improved sequentially from the third to fourth quarter. Following a challenging third quarter, I am pleased with how we ended the year, demonstrating our team's diligence and hard work to mitigate the missteps faced in the fall.
We have taken swift and effective action to correct the problems and have made notable progress in several key areas, including fixing our new POS system, cleaning up inventory and rolling out a more effective marketing strategy. We are particularly pleased with the nimble and proactive approach of our teams in responding to the ever-changing retail environment.
In fourth quarter, we saw our trends in kids and athletic continue to excel and our digital demand continue to provide strong growth. Our Canadian operations continue to deliver strong performance, leveraging the infrastructure and expertise we have given them. And Camuto has readied an outstanding inaugural collection of products for our spring exclusive brands, including the new JLO product that just launched.
Regardless of short-term issues, we remain committed to our goal of becoming the leading footwear and accessories company in North America through execution of our strategic pillars, delivering differentiated products, offering differentiated experiences both in-store and online and focusing on new growth opportunities to increase our market share.
We made meaningful progress in 2019 and expect to continue doing so into 2020. In our three main businesses, namely DSW, Camuto and Canada, we refine each of these three strategic pillars to ensure our customers have a consistent and positive shopping experience across our entire organization.
Despite the current impact of COVI-19, the Camuto Group integration is moving forward as planned, allowing us to bring exciting new products to the marketplace including our recently announced business partnership with global superstar Jennifer Lopez.
We believe our differentiators will continue to pave the way for growth and margin expansion at Designer Brands. Camuto will continue assuming responsibility for design, sourcing and manufacturing, all of which have exceeded my expectations thus far.
Our loyalty program remains strong with 32 million members and we continue to look for new and innovative ways to provide unique experiences to drive engagement, average spend and ticket size. As our world grows increasingly digital, we continue to enhance our technological capabilities, which are producing solid results. We are strengthening the way we engage with our customers at every touch point, positioning our Company as the leader in omnichannel footwear retailing. Canada remains a bright spot as we apply our learnings from our solid U.S. business to this new market, exponentially increasing its growth. Beginning on the forefront of the unique experience that is digital for this core segment of customers, gives us an edge as we build out our presence in this market.
Finally, I feel it is also important to briefly reflect on some of the short-term issues we discussed on our third quarter call. First, our POS system; following the holidays, we implemented changes that no longer allow customers to stack discounts on our digital channels. As a result, we saw our markdown rate improve considerably during the fourth quarter.
Second, inventory, during fourth quarter we implemented more disciplined controls within the Camuto organization to standardize ordering processes and prevent the over-buying of items in the future. We are also pleased to have cleared nearly all of the excess inventory as of the start of our fiscal 2020.
Finally, in terms of marketing, we began to take steps to reinvest in this important area and are doing so in a thoughtful way, employing a balanced approach to marketing through digital and social, as well as more traditional routes like TV and Direct Mail. We have plans to roll out a new TV campaign and we'll be consistently looking to optimize our media spend in conjunction with our agency partners. These actions proved effective in January and February as we saw an increase in foot traffic to our stores at the start of 2020.
The tariff environment continues to evolve and we want to provide a quick update in light of the latest exclusions. Based on the current regulations, DBI now expects the tariff impact to be roughly $10 million to $15 million, well below the $25 million to $30 million we outlined last quarter.
We remain dedicated to our mitigation efforts, working consistently with our vendor and factory partners, and the integration of Camuto sourcing capabilities will continue to benefit the business. We are still committed to reducing our dependence on China and have plans to decrease the amount of product sourced from that part of the world.
Despite the unprecedented near-term challenges that we are managing through on a daily basis, we have not lost sight of preserving the long-term health of our business. Through offering quality, differentiated product and differentiated experiences to our strong loyal customer base, Designer Brands is on a solid foundation to propel growth and position the Company for long-term success.
Finally, we are refraining from providing 2020 guidance in light of the rapidly evolving coronavirus situation. Given the uncertainty around the impact of the virus on our supply chain and consumer buying behavior in the U.S. and Canada, coupled with our mitigation efforts, including our store closures, it is challenging to reliably quantify the impact we might see. We remain committed to updating you as our visibility increases once there is a return to normalcy. The fourth quarter was about regaining our footing and we are confident that we have the controls and processes in place to move forward successfully given the improvement we saw in the latter part of the quarter and beginning of fiscal 2020, prior to the escalation of coronavirus.
We still have work to do and we'll update you on our progress. We recognize that the retail landscape is a challenging one especially in light of this crisis, but I have the utmost confidence that we are identifying unique and compelling ways to identify new customers as well as grow our incredibly loyal customer base, including bringing them differentiated products and experiences, identifying new areas of growth such as exclusive partnerships, continuing to evolve our omnichannel approach and enhancing our digital capabilities, applying our expertise from DSW to other parts of our business, namely Canada and bringing our private label product in-house will unearth enormous benefits and margin expansion.
In closing, the health and safety of our employees and the long-term viability of our business remain paramount. Our strategic pillars continue to guide our business and we have seen tangible progress as we lay the foundation for the future of Designer Brands.
As we source design and market new and beautiful products through Camuto and couple this with our retail expertise, we are committed to growing our market share and we will create long-term value for our shareholders over the long-term.
With that, I will turn it over to Jared. Jared?
Jared A. Poff -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Designer Brands
Thank you. I want to echo Roger's comments that the health and safety of our employees is our top priority along with the long-term health of our business. I will now walk you through our 2019 results. Our fourth quarter was marked by positive comps and improvement in store traffic trends and a sequential recovery in margin trends as a result of our proactive approach to mitigate many of the self-inflicted issues Roger discussed.
Although we are still disappointed with our full-year results, we made significant progress and ended the quarter with a clean inventory position, a patched POS system, and more refined marketing strategy and new inventory controls at Camuto.
2019 was challenging for us, but we are confident that recent actions we took helped to strengthen us. Please note the financial results that we will reference during the remainder of today's call exclude certain adjustments recorded under GAAP unless specified otherwise. These non-GAAP measures should be considered in addition to and not as a substitute for or in isolation from GAAP results. You can find additional disclosures regarding these non-GAAP measures, including complete reconciliations with comparable GAAP results in our press release.
Finally, please note that we have reclassified commission income previously presented as commission, franchise and other revenue to net sales. It is now included in our calculation of gross margin.
Including commission income in both net sales and gross margin for the Brand Portfolio segment is appropriate as the inter-segment commission income charged to DSW is included in DSW's cost of goods and flows through DSW's gross margin. Other revenue, primarily, including sublease income was reclassified to operating expenses.
Overall, these reclassifications simplify the presentation of our income statement. These reclassifications do not have an impact on operating income but will influence gross profit results. For the full year, net sales increased 11.2% to $3.5 billion after excluding the net sales of exited businesses from fiscal 2018.
Net sales included $72.1 million in inter-segment sales that were eliminated in consolidation. For the fourth quarter net sales were $829.6 million flat to prior year after excluding the net sales of exited businesses from last year. Net sales included $18.3 million in inter-segment sales that were eliminated in consolidation.
On a full year basis, total comps were up 0.8% on top of a strong 6.1% comp last year. For the fourth quarter, total comps were up 0.7% versus a healthy 5.4% comp last year, bringing the two-year comp to 6.1%. This strong two-year performance was mainly driven by continued growth in kids and athletic, as well as a planned increase in our more traditional marketing efforts.
Also, as I just mentioned, in addition to improved sales trends, we ended the quarter on a positive note with a clean inventory position. In the U.S. Retail segment, comps were up 0.3% for the full year versus 6% last year. For the fourth quarter, comps were down 0.3% compared to a 5.3% increase in the prior year delivering a two-year comp of 5%.
Our Women's category was down 3% in the quarter, driven largely by women's dress, which posted a down 14% comp on inventory down over 20%. However, this was an improvement from the third quarter's comp decline of 17% on inventory down 30%. We are working diligently to improve our dress category in stocks but lead times and low inventory levels in the market remain challenging.
There were several highlights during the quarter; our kids category continues to report robust performance with comps up 27%. Kids is a strategic priority of ours, as it will not only allow us to aggressively grab market share in the kid's category, but it will also allow us to meet more of the entire family's footwear needs. Our kids sales growth has far outpaced the growth of the entire industry and we continue to see strong attachment rates to adult footwear.
Digital demand in the U.S. Retail remain strong and was up 15% in the quarter on top of a 28% increase in the prior year. In Canada, comps were up 7.2% for the full year and 10.1% for the quarter, driven by a combination of strong digital growth and increase in loyalty members and strong comps at DSW retail stores.
Canada continues to be a point of strength for us as we apply our successful initiatives from the U.S. to the new Canadian operations. We relaunched our online presence in 2019 and are seeing impressive digital growth bolstered by the concurrent relaunching of the rewards program. The number of active rewards members on file at the end of 2019 was $2.4 million, up over 30% from the end of 2018.
The synergy and leverage have culminated in our Canadian operations becoming the largest women's footwear retailer in Canada and the third largest in kids. Additionally in 2019, our Canadian retail operations posted the largest comp growth of all retail in Canada. We were very happy with the results we saw in Canada.
For the year, our U.S. VIP rewards program growth continued with active members increasing to nearly 19 million members. This is our highest active member count in our loyalty program's history and reflects a 2% growth in members versus 2018. In addition to the new earnings tiers and benefits rolled out in 2018, we saw continued growth and engagement from this group around non-transactional benefits including our philanthropic initiative that has resonated strongly with our customers.
Turning to Camuto, as a reminder, our acquisition closed in the fourth quarter of 2018. So going forward, all results will be comparable. We did not own Camuto for the first three quarters of 2018, thus any reference to those periods are for informational purposes only.
For the full year, total net sales from Camuto including sales to DSW were $448.3 million, flat to last year as the increase in volume to DSW and e-commerce replaced lost sales from department stores as a result of increases in markdowns and returns and wholesale due to the over-inventory position.
Total net sales in the fourth quarter including sales to DSW were $103.3 million, which was up 3.5% to last year. Wholesale sales were $379.7 million for the full year 2019, slightly down to last year including $63.7 million in sales to our own retail segments. For the fourth quarter, wholesale sales were $82 million versus $86.2 million last year. This includes sales to our retail segments which totaled $13.2 million in 2019 versus $9.8 million the prior year.
Vincecamuto.com had full year sales of $15.4 million, almost double from last year. The sales growth in the fourth quarter was consistent with these dynamics, up almost 100% to $6.2 million. Full year sales for solesociety.com grew modestly to $26.7 million when compared to the prior year as we work to optimize our marketing spend and pulled back on some unproductive channels.
For the quarter, solesociety.com sales of $6.8 million were slightly up versus prior year. For the full-year, commission income including commissions from our retail segments totaled $26.4 million, slightly up to the prior year. During the quarter, commission income increased over 100% to $8 million. Finally, for the full year, ABG posted a positive comp of 0.3% on top of a 7.4% comp growth in the prior year.
In the fourth quarter, comp sales at ABG declined 1.8%, driven largely by a slowdown in boots sales and changes in the promotional cadence at our largest customer. One of the key benefits of Camuto is our ability to build out exclusive brands within our portfolio, and we made substantial progress during the quarter.
For the full year, sales of exclusive brands, sometimes also referred to as private label totaled $410 million, representing close to 12% of total sales versus $234 million in the prior year. Sales of exclusive brands at our retail business grew by 19% in the quarter, representing $102 million in sales. We were pleased with the early sell-throughs we saw on Camuto design products that rolled out in stores during the quarter.
By year-end, roughly 55% of our exclusive brands had been transferred from third-party production to being internally produced by Camuto and we will continue to migrate more of the product internally as we move forward in 2020. Additionally, we sold $43 million of Camuto national brands through our retail businesses during the quarter and $137 million during the full year including $42 million, which was sold in our direct-to-consumer channels at vincecamuto.com and solesociety.com.
Our adjusted consolidated gross profit increased to $999.7 million in 2019, up 5.9% versus $944 million in the prior year on higher consolidated sales. Our adjusted consolidated gross profit decreased to $205.9 million in the fourth quarter, down 3.4% versus $213.2 million in the prior year, primarily due to the liquidation activities to clear excess inventory at Camuto.
Our consolidated gross margin rate declined 110 basis points in 2019 to 28.6% versus 29.7% last year. This was mainly due to increased markdown activity, liquidation activity at Camuto, increased shipping expenses from a shift to digital, and higher transportation cost.
In the fourth quarter, consolidated gross margin rate decreased 50 basis points to 24.8% versus 25.3% in the prior year. While we are disappointed in these declines, we feel it is important to note that this is a significant improvement over the third quarter when gross margin rates decline 330 basis points.
As Roger mentioned, during the fourth quarter, we significantly reduced our promotional activity and updated our Company policy to no longer allow stacking of discounts, which was implemented in the POS patch. As a result, our DSW retail markdown rate improved by over 100 basis points when compared to the third quarter.
In U.S. Retail, our gross margin rate in the fourth quarter was 25.4%, a decline of 90 basis points versus last year. This is mainly due to the overhang from the increased markdowns following the POS issues, which was slightly offset by a reduction in promotional activity as well as private label growth.
Our Canada gross margin rate in the fourth quarter was 25.5%, an increase of 660 basis points versus last year. This was driven primarily by the wind down of the Town Shoes banner in 2018, partially offset by the 2019 Q4 launch of The Shoe Company loyalty program where over 1 million points were issued at the time of launch. At Camuto, gross margin rate was 20.2% in the fourth quarter, a significant decrease from last year's level of 24.3%. This was primarily related to the necessary liquidation of excess inventory.
Turning to the tariff environment, last quarter, we said we had identified 80% to 90% of the direct impact of the tariffs that we plan to mitigate leaving roughly $20 million to $30 million unmitigated. Following the latest exclusions, we now expect the annual tariff impact to be somewhere in the range of $10 million to $15 million.
We do want to flag that we had already brought in a large portion of our spring inventory under the 15% tariff rate and we are fully positioned in inventory related to the JLO spring launch. Moving to Designer Brands operating expenses, in 2019, adjusted consolidated SG&A for all four businesses was $856 million. And our SG&A rate decreased by 60 basis points versus the prior year, primarily driven by a reduction in incentive compensation.
This assumes a full year of Camuto in 2018, which as a reminder, we did not own until the fourth quarter of 2018. In the fourth quarter, adjusted consolidated SG&A decreased 2% versus the prior year and our SG&A rate leveraged by 20 basis points, primarily driven by lower incentive compensation. Depreciation expense totaled $85.6 million in 2019 versus $78 million in 2018.
In the fourth quarter depreciation expense was $22.1 million compared to $20.6 million in the prior year. Adjusted operating profit for Designer Brands was $153.8 million in 2019 versus $182.7 million last year. For the fourth quarter, we had an adjusted operating loss of $6.6 million versus a loss of $5.2 million last year. This was driven primarily by items we discussed last quarter and today. We also saw a small operating loss in Canada in the fourth quarter as anticipated, given the seasonally low sales in the quarter against our fixed cost base.
Interest expense for 2019 was $7.4 million versus interest income of $1.3 million in 2018. For the fourth quarter, interest expense was $1.4 million versus $1.1 million in the prior year. Moving on, our effective tax rate was 22% in 2019 versus 26.1% last year. The decrease was largely related to the tax impact of improved performance in our Canadian operations.
Total weighted average diluted shares for the year were 74.6 million compared to 81.2 million last year. During the fourth quarter, total weighted average diluted shares were 71.8 million compared to 79.4 million last year.
Adjusted EPS for 2019 was $1.53 per share versus $1.66 last year. Adjusted EPS for the fourth quarter of 2019 was a loss of $0.05 per share. In both cases, net after tax charges not included in adjusted EPS were primarily related to impairment charges as well as integration and restructuring expenses associated with the acquired businesses.
Turning to the balance sheet, we ended the year with $111.5 million in cash and investments and $190 million drawn on our revolver compared to $169.1 million in cash and investments and $160 million drawn on the revolver last year. The key driver of this change was the share repurchases made during the year.
Capital expenditures were lighter than originally projected for 2019 given the timing of certain projects. We expect these projects to be completed in 2020 and beyond. During the quarter, we did not open any stores in the U.S. or Canada and ended the year with 521 DSW stores in the U.S., a 118 Shoe Company stores in Canada and 27 DSW stores in Canada.
As we look to 2020 and in light of the rapidly evolving coronavirus situation, we think it's important to reinforce the sales trends quarter-to-date that Roger discussed. In February, our actions to turn around the DSW business continued and we saw our store traffic improvement from Q4 strengthen, as we further surpassed the retail indices we monitored beating by 2 percentage points.
In fact, for the first 36 days of 2020 we delivered a 2% comp increase and were over our budget by $3 million. However, at the end of the first week of March, as COVID-19 started to impact performance, we began to see a significant deterioration in both store traffic and sales and digital sales did not offset the decline in store traffic. March and April are among our busiest months of the year and we anticipate our operations will be substantially impacted in light of the lack of digital traffic coupled with our decision to temporarily close our retail locations in North America.
We continue to actively monitor this urgent situation as new information becomes available. Given the uncertainties around the impact of the coronavirus we are not issuing guidance for fiscal 2020 at this time. The situation is rapidly evolving and we are unable to reliably quantify the impact of COVID-19. We remain committed to keeping you updated on the situation as visibility increases.
With that, we will open the call for questions. Operator?
Questions and Answers:
Operator
Thank you. We'll now being the question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions] Today's first question comes from Sam Poser at Susquehanna. Please go ahead.
Sam Poser -- Susquehanna International Group, LLP -- Analyst
Good morning. Thank you for taking my questions. I have a handful. First of all, good job of closing the stores. Second off, if the store closures go beyond two weeks, what do you do about paying the staff after that point, because it's going to be difficult -- it's going to be exceptionally difficult for everybody?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Yeah, Sam, let me start, and it's probably not just for you, but for the rest of the folks that we have in the queue. I mean, as we said on the call, there are two things we have as priorities. It's protecting the health of our associates first of all, and second, protecting the long-term health of the business. So we're going to be focused on that, we're going to be taking actions, frankly, they're changing by hour. But those are the two priorities.
So, as we're going through answering questions today, I really want to make certain you guys understand that we're not going to be able to engage in sort of hypotheticals as this is a very fluid situation that's going to change by day. And number two, we are playing in an unprecedented territory that I think it's going to be impossible to quantify the financial impact of some of these decisions.
So Sam, what I would tell you is we're not prepared to answer that question at this time. We will make decisions just like what we have over the last, frankly, seven days as these things sort of crop up. But where we sit today is, as people were scheduled and we've shut down stores for the next 14 days we will pay them as we had planned.
Sam Poser -- Susquehanna International Group, LLP -- Analyst
Okay, thank you. All right, just -- I have a few more here. Your inventory is in very good shape, but given that stores are going to be closed, how are you adjusting your inventories going forward and so on? And some of that is very seasonal goods. So if stores do stay closed, I mean, how are you managing flow plus the goods you have on hand right now?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Yeah, great question, Sam. So I think, first, let me start by saying the investments we have made over the last four, five, six, seven years to develop the omnichannel capabilities, those things are going to pay back in a huge way right now, because while we are shutting the stores down to the -- a consumer walking in day in and day out shopping, we are going to keep them up and operating those fulfillment centers.
So leveraging them as a huge asset because we are within 20 minutes to 70% of the U.S. population. That's a huge advantage for us. So we're going to get after that. Obviously, we are cutting receipts. And as things are late, we will pick what we want to keep and what we would cancel. But the diligence around inventory management that the DSW brand has exhibited for the last 28 years, I have a really, really, really good planning and merchant organization and we're going to be very diligent in managing the inventories.
But I do think the tools we've put in place to help us mitigate a situation like this, it won't offset all of the impact, but it will allow us to perhaps alleviate some of the markdown pressure we would have felt had we did not have that capability.
Sam Poser -- Susquehanna International Group, LLP -- Analyst
Okay. I have two more. One, what's the status of ABG throughout this whole thing? How many of those stores are opened, closed and so on? And secondly, what percent of Q1 generally -- Q1 revenue generally runs through those first 36-day? [Speech Overlap] there was a lot more volume coming in the back half or that two-thirds of the quarter?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Yeah. So I'll split up in two. One, as it relates to sort of the first quarter, as you know, Marpril, those nine weeks, as well as Septober those nine weeks, they are huge for our business. They are our holiday equivalent. So, while I was really excited about the first 36 days, it still was a fairly small portion of the first quarter as well as the year, obviously.
As it relates to ABG, we are in conversations daily with what's happening within our ABG relationships. As of this hour, yes, there are some Stein Mart locations that have shut down, but there's not been a full chain shutdown. But again, I haven't looked at the press releases here of late, but we're continuing to do business within Stein Mart and Frugal Fannie's today.
Sam Poser -- Susquehanna International Group, LLP -- Analyst
Okay. And then have you -- I mean just, have you -- given that you're looking out for your employees and everything else, have you pressured Stein Mart and everything to think about shutting it down as you had?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
That's up to the Stein Mart team. That is something that's out of our control Sam, and frankly, we've got enough challenges of our own, trying to manage through this to make it through in a way that protects our associates and our business, but I have not been having those conversations.
Sam Poser -- Susquehanna International Group, LLP -- Analyst
All the best in this really difficult time. Hope everybody is safe.
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Thanks Sam. Really appreciate it. Yeah, thank you. You too.
Operator
Our next question comes from Rick Patel with Needham & Company. Please go ahead.
Rick Patel -- Needham & Company -- Analyst
Thank you. Good morning, everyone. I appreciate the situation is extremely fluid at the moment, but was hoping you can update us on how your expenses are split between fixed and variable in a normalized environment? I'm just curious if stores had to remain closed till the end of April or even longer, how much of the pain you can mitigate as we think about the impact to operating profit?
Jared A. Poff -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Designer Brands
Yeah. Rick, I'll take that. I won't be able to give you a defined fixed versus variable. What I can tell you in categories, obviously, our store expenses tend to be relatively flexible. We changed our labor model. If you recall two years ago, 18 months to two years ago where we actually alleviated a good amount of our fixed leverage in our stores and moved to a much more variable scenario.
So that has allowed us both in this situation, as well as just regular volatility in the business to be able to flex up and down more regularly. Obviously, most of your home office expenses and things like that are more fixed in nature. And then the expenses associated with our digital business tend to be very variable, not heavily fixed.
Rick Patel -- Needham & Company -- Analyst
Understood. And can you also update us on what your debt covenant are for the revolver? And perhaps touch on what actions you're taking from a working capital and capex perspective to support the balance sheet and free cash flow? I think you touched on a few factors on the call, but just hoping for some more color there.
Jared A. Poff -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Designer Brands
Yeah, we have two covenants. We have a leverage ratio and then a fixed charge coverage. If I quoted you the actual number, I probably would miss it by something. It is a public document, so if you go out and look when we redid that, I think it was two years ago, it's filed, and you can find them out there or I can look it up and tell you in our one-on-one. But those are the only two financial covenants that we've got in our revolver.
We did just enter into an amendment on the revolver. It actually brought down our pricing and that just closed and we've got the cushion built into our covenants to be able to withstand certain amounts of volatility and we're working with our partners. We have had the same bank partners for decades, have very strong relationships and I have no doubt that as we continue to explore financing and liquidity options, we'll have the support of the banks.
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
And Rick, I'll take the other part of your question. I think, we have already begun to roll out I think a number of mitigating strategies. Obviously, we've been facing this for all of seven days. But first, we have already dramatically reduced our inventories and are cutting back future orders in anticipation of what we think is going to be a notable sales disruption for some period of time.
Second, we are accelerating our level of markdowns, so you're going to see us offer a deeper value to our consumer. As you guys are aware, seasonal product does not get better as the season progresses. So we're going to distort a lot of marketing there.
We are also going to distort our marketing dollars away from what I would define as conventional channels that would have been intended to drive store traffic and instead we will divert those dollars toward digital engagement.
And then lastly, we are going to closely evaluate all of our SG&A expenses across the business. I mean, as I said, we are looking out for the health of our associates, but also we have to manage the long-term health of this business. And unfortunately, SG&A will be an area that we will have to look at, given the disruption that we're experiencing.
Rick Patel -- Needham & Company -- Analyst
Thank you. Stay healthy and all the best guys, thank you.
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Alright, thanks Rick.
Jared A. Poff -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Designer Brands
Thanks, Rick.
Operator
Our next question today comes from Tom Nikic of Wells Fargo. Please go ahead.
Tom Nikic -- Wells Fargo -- Analyst
Hey, good morning guys. Thanks for taking my question. I'm not sure if this is a question you'd want to answer, but let's say you were reporting earnings two weeks ago rather than today and before all this disruption happened. I think you mentioned that you were comping up low singles, quarter-to-date and that's what's embedded in your multi-year plan.
So, I mean, if I kind of think about like what you're -- what the shape of the year would have looked like if the situation had never happened, is it safe to say that something in the order of like low single-digit comps and gross margin expansion is what we would have been looking at in 2020 in a more normal environment?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Yeah, Tom, I'll take that. I think I was really, really pleased with Q4. We addressed all the missteps we had had in Q3. We cleaned up inventories. We had improved the margin trend as we -- compared to Q3 and we were seeing the same thing as we were headed through those first 36 days. We've made gigantic progress in Canada, which I won't get into all the detail, but I was really, really happy with that. Our kids business was continuing to grow in fourth quarter as well as in February. We're up over 25%.
All of our categories with the exception really of dress, we were getting really strong selling out of and the progress we have made with the exclusive brands that grew close to 30% in Q4, we were seeing that same run rate as we were in those first 36 days.
So, all of the things we have said we were going to do to differentiate product, to differentiate the experiences and drive growth, those things were playing out really through January and February exactly as we had played out in our budgets. And then Monday happened and that's the lens that I've applied to the business looking back at it and how we had started the year.
Jared A. Poff -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Designer Brands
I would add to that, Tom, one other thing that we were very excited about was we literally had received and had set all of the products for the exclusive brand, the conversion to Camuto, which was a huge initiative for us. So progressing as we had planned to have that product, customer-facing it was in stock. It was here, the stuff that was already on the floor was selling more swiftly than even what we had anticipated. So we were very excited. Still, are very excited for that product, but unfortunately, obviously there is a demand disruption across all footwear.
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
And I know, right now you can't go see. Well, today you could go see it. But if you want to go look in a store, but the work we had done to set Mix No. 6 is an example in the front of a store and the way that product look and the way it was targeting a certain customer, we were really, really proud of the work our team at DSW, our team at Camuto had done to bring to life a whole different product line for a different customer. So again, we were feeling good about our business.
Tom Nikic -- Wells Fargo -- Analyst
Understood. Well, hopefully this situation doesn't linger too long. And best of luck this year.
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Thanks Tom. Appreciate it
Jared A. Poff -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Designer Brands
Thank you.
Operator
And our next question today comes from Paul Trussell with Deutsche Bank. Please go ahead. Mr. Trussell, your line is open.
Paul Trussell -- Deutsche Bank -- Analyst
Yes, good morning. And thank you for all the color today. I guess maybe let's just ask the question. Again, I know theoretical isn't where we want to -- what we want to deal with. But let's maybe flip it the other way and say that the store closures continue through what you've already outlined. And then the stores are open and are back to expected volume thereon.
Is there any way for you to share with us or quantify what that financial impact would be just for what has taken place to-date, and for the timeframe over these next few weeks while the stores are closed?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Paul, I'd say -- as I said in my opening comments, this is just unprecedented territory and we just can't speculate on what we think the financial impact is going to look like. I will tell you that the conversations that we've been having with our team, I feel really good about how we're positioning inventory. And as it comes out, I think we have a history and a tradition at DSW of finding ways to get product. So I know we will be aggressive and there will be product available, I do know that.
Paul Trussell -- Deutsche Bank -- Analyst
Absolutely, well maybe let's get an update on Camuto, right, as we kind of think about the steps taken last year. Maybe kind of give us an update on how you feel like you're positioned with that organization? And what volume you think will be transferred over to Camuto by this fiscal year-end?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Yeah. So, thanks for the question, Paul. I think I'll share sort of the different buckets of the business we do on our now production sourcing side of our business. I was really, really happy with the progress we've made with our direct-to-consumer capabilities with Vince Camuto growing at close to 100% year-over-year. And that's still going to be a real focus, not just for Vince, but for all of the brands that we own and operate, how do we get after that?
You've heard us share that the folks that have really grown market share over the last six, seven years in footwear have really been brands themselves going direct-to-consumer and we own and operate three of the most powerful footwear brands that are out there in Vince, Lucky, and Jessica and we have growth potential in going direct-to-consumer there. So I was really happy there.
I think the progress that that team made along with the support of the DSW organization around getting these exclusive brands up and running and the kind of sell-throughs we were seeing were exactly in line with what we were expecting. So I think that part of the strategy is working. I think the work that the Camuto organization did to win back open to buy within their customer base.
They had made great progress and as we've been out of the gate, I'm pleased with where that has progressed. So, really across the board and then when you add into the fact that we do a large chunk of the private label brands for many other retailers out there and I think this isn't a data point. So please don't quote this, but I think we're probably the largest designer and sourcer of private brand footwear in North America based on all the relationships we have.
So I'm really happy with the progress that we've been making there. And then to come back, I really -- I think it's important for this group to understand, I was sharing this the other day with some of our partners -- take athletic out of the equation, we own roughly 13% of the non-athletic footwear market. That's an amazing market share. That's on the women's side. That's an amazing market share position.
So our lens is, let's get through this, let's keep our people healthy, let's keep our business healthy and then let's come out of this and take advantage of that market share position and really grow this thing the way that we had planned. So again, I'm pleased with the work we've been doing at Camuto.
Jared A. Poff -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Designer Brands
And I would add two data points to that or two color points to that, Paul. One, as I mentioned in the script, we had positioned all of the transition that we had planned to do from our prior vendor to Camuto for our own exclusive brands such that the sales of private brand products that we were going to make in 2020, 55% of that would have been produced by Camuto. That is right on track.
There are a few categories we had not transitioned yet, but we were in the process of doing it. And the sale of all of our Camuto produced goods, be they exclusive brands or our sale of their national brands was going to increase in the very strong triple digits for this year. So that vertical margin story is very real, and is positioned to take off once demand is back there.
The second data point I would give and I don't think Roger mentioned this, although initial expectations are relatively, from a sales standpoint, relatively muted, we were very excited about the relationship that we were able to craft with Jennifer Lopez and the way it was structured is only because of what we've created at Designer Brands.
So the fact that she can source with Camuto, one of the best in the industry and sell exclusively at DSW, is something that we know is going to be a big deal for us and it's created unlike anything you've ever seen from a structuring standpoint. So we're really excited about that.
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Yeah, it's great color Jared.
Paul Trussell -- Deutsche Bank -- Analyst
Thank you. Thank you for that. And lastly from me, just curious to hear an update on how you're thinking about adding in services in the store or any other kind of retooling of the way the store is engaging with the customer?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Thanks, Paul. I love the opportunity to talk about the progress we had made in services and I'm going to use the reference point of the locations we have in Columbus, Ohio, where all three of our DSW locations have nail bars. So we have experienced for a customer that had shopped our footwear assortment a year prior that comes in and receives a nail service. We are seeing a 30% to 40% increase in their footwear purchases one year later. There are not many other things that we have had experience working in our retail history that drives that kind of lift.
And as an example, they're coming in about twice as many times -- or no it's actually four times as many visits as a customer that does not have a nail service and their attachment rate when they come in for that nail service is close to 25%.
So we got to survive and make it through the challenging times we're dealing with today and we are going to continue to grow more aggressively the service offering, whether that'd be nails or other things. But obviously, in today's climate that's not something we're focused on at this very moment but we think there is still lots of opportunity there, but thanks for that question.
Paul Trussell -- Deutsche Bank -- Analyst
Thanks. My best.
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Yeah, you too.
Jared A. Poff -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Designer Brands
Thank you.
Operator
Our next question today comes from Dana Telsey at Telsey Advisory Group. Please go ahead.
Dana Telsey -- Telsey Advisory Group -- Analyst
Good morning, everyone. As you think of measures...
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Good morning.
Dana Telsey -- Telsey Advisory Group -- Analyst
Hi. As you think of measures to manage through this, the warehouse and obviously e-commerce continuing to operate, is there any changes to the warehouse productivity or labor or do you need to do any more efficiencies in terms of the warehouse side in order to manage through this?
And same thing on the marketing side, any adjustments to marketing that you make in the first quarter that you may push to 3Q or the back half of the year, especially given the prominence of the JLO launch? Thank you.
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
I think there are obviously, from a -- I'll start with the marketing. We are going to be shifting our focus of our marketing to focus more on the digital side of the business. Obviously, the social space and having Jennifer Lopez as a partner and being able to leverage her over 200 million social followers to find ways to engage with our brand. That's something that we're going to work on and how we can leverage that.
So I think you're going to see a distortion of our marketing efforts toward obviously the digital experience. As it relates to operating the warehouses, I'll split that into two frameworks. The warehouses one that are close to the consumer meaning what many folks would call a store, we have standards in place today in each of those locations on what it takes to fulfill an order and how quickly we can get that out.
We will be evaluating what those standards could be because we are anticipating more volume coming out of what is -- what would be defined as a store to fulfill the consumer demand. And then obviously, our fulfillment center that we use here to fulfill that demand is also going to be -- going to be busy. But I feel like we've got that in a really good place. But as far as the day-to-day operation of the local warehouses, I think we've got good practices in place and we will -- our team will be all over ensuring we're meeting the demand of the customer. Thank you.
Dana Telsey -- Telsey Advisory Group -- Analyst
Thank you. And on the warehouse side, any functionality in terms of putting it in one or two warehouses instead of many? How are you operating that through this time period?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Again, the way we look at our business is, our average store is roughly 20-some-thousand-square-feet and we have lots of opportunities to leverage those facilities to house product whether they're open or closed and that's how we're looking at utilizing our space. And then we also, through our Camuto acquisition acquired a warehouse in New Jersey that has capacity. So we feel pretty good about our ability to manage through this with the existing footprints we have.
Jared A. Poff -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Designer Brands
Yeah, one thing I would add, Dana, we have made just some work shift changes to account for social distancing and cleaning. So we've gone through and put some space between shifts and things like that, but we were already functioning at a multi-shift kind of environment.
Dana Telsey -- Telsey Advisory Group -- Analyst
Got it. And any movement of store openings and timing of openings to the back half of the year from the front half or what were you looking for in the front half of the year?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Go ahead.
Jared A. Poff -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Designer Brands
Yeah, so we were -- again, I don't want to give guidance that really just completely fell off the cliff but obviously, we were going to continue with a very modest net new store opening cadence, I'm sure. And if you kind of follow how we do that, we tend to be a little heavier weighted in the back half but trying to get open by that fall time period. Right now we've halted basically most anticipated openings just as we are looking to see where we want to expend capital and things like that.
Dana Telsey -- Telsey Advisory Group -- Analyst
Thank you.
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
You're welcome.
Operator
Our next question comes from Chris Svezia at Wedbush. Please go ahead.
Chris Svezia -- Wedbush Securities, Inc. -- Analyst
Good morning everyone. Thanks for taking my questions and thanks for the color. I guess just first, I want to go to supply chain for a moment. I think any color you can update us on just -- I guess you would normally step back and say, there might have been supply chain disruption given what was going on with China and product availability. Where does that stand now in relation to your observations about comp slowing, making some reductions, canceling some orders, maybe looking at both the DSW side and the Camuto side shipping into your wholesale and your private label customers? Just sort of where that whole dynamic on the supply chain side stands right now today?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Yeah, Chris, thanks. We were very focused prior to Chinese New Year to get as much product out as we possibly could in light of many situations. One, we were launching our exclusive brands at DSW. So we were able to move a lot of product and actually we're delivering goods when I know that there were a lot of folks that were feeling some real stress and pain around some of the shutdowns that had taken place in China. So I think we did a really nice job of managing through that.
As it relates to where things stand today and the supply chain, all of the factories that we have historically worked with are up and operating. I would say in general, capacity-wise operating between 70%, 80%-ish of their capacity is where we stand today. So that's more than enough to meet the kind of flow that we see of product that we need to keep the business moving forward. So I feel pretty good about where that stands.
As it relates to the DSW brand, obviously, we have a lot of product that's flowing. This is a peak period for us. Again, marpril is, that's a holiday -- Easter is a huge holiday for us and we're working with all of our partners as well as our supply chain team to ensure that we get the product in the right place, right now.
That's the big focus we have is, as stores are slowing down or closing, where can we get that product so that we can ensure we can get it to a customer when it's demanded digitally or when the stores open back up to ensure that it's located in the right place, when that does happen.
Chris Svezia -- Wedbush Securities, Inc. -- Analyst
Okay, thank you. And on the -- I'm curious on the SG&A side, I guess as you look at SG&A today, are you finding savings opportunities or are you waiting until after the 14-day period if by any chance you still have stores closed, taking that action to look at opportunities? I'm just curious where you are in that thought process? Are there opportunities today that you actually have line of sight to or are you waiting until if this prolongs, looking for opportunities at that point in time?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
No. Thanks, Chris, for the question. No, we have already started acting upon some of the SG&A, as an example, implementing a hiring freeze, ensuring that every single cash outlay that we are making is something that is driving a sale today. That's sort of the mindset that we're having and we're obviously working through all of our teams to figure out ways to cut expenses.
And I think we were really lucky as we went through this whole tariff thing to reach out to partners and I don't know who else did this, but real proud of the fact that we reached out to all of our vendor partners and asked for a 5% reduction in SG&A to deal with the tariffs. And for the most part, with the exception of one or two we got that support and we'll be going down that same path with partners that are in place today.
Obviously, everyone is going to end up sharing in the pain that I think we're feeling. So we're going to take every action we possibly can to, again, ensure the long-term health of this business. We got a great balance sheet, very little debt, access to cash. We got to weather this storm and come out of it stronger than when we went into it.
Chris Svezia -- Wedbush Securities, Inc. -- Analyst
Got it. And just final thing for me, just clarification, what you saw in the first 36 days, just to be clear, roughly a 2% comp. You talked about the kids accelerated. I think you've mentioned athletic improved relative to what you saw in the fourth quarter. Any color about early reads on spring Open-toe sandals, any color around that product? I think you referenced the dress business -- women's dress was still down, but just clarification around -- color around some of those puts and takes and what you saw on the first 36-days?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Yeah, Chris, I can't give that color. But what I would tell you what I think is important for everyone on the call to know is what was great about the result we were getting, we were doing that without having to be promotional to get comps, the way that we were publicly really throughout the fall season.
Yeah, there were still marketing activities in place but we had reduced the number of days of public promotion, meaning screaming a percent [Phonetic] off or some kind of tier offer that was available significantly year-over-year and significantly to where we had been throughout third quarter and really November, December.
So the progress we made in January and February to enhance margins to really tell the story about our value proposition to our consumer, leveraging our rewards program, leveraging our stores and digital channel to demonstrate the everyday value offering. I was really proud of the team and the progress we had made. So while a 2% comp might not sound like it's all that inspiring, when you're doing it without having to run the same level of promotion; you guys have followed our business long enough, you know what that flows through. So that's where I was really excited.
Chris Svezia -- Wedbush Securities, Inc. -- Analyst
Got it, understood. Well, stay healthy, all the best and [Indecipherable].
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Yeah, thank you.
Jared A. Poff -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Designer Brands
Thank you.
Operator
And our next question is a follow-up from Sam Poser at Susquehanna. Please go ahead.
Sam Poser -- Susquehanna International Group, LLP -- Analyst
I have two things. One, have you -- prior to today, have you opened any stores? And if so, where or which banners in the quarter?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
No, Sam. We haven't opened stores this quarter.
Jared A. Poff -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Designer Brands
Correct.
Sam Poser -- Susquehanna International Group, LLP -- Analyst
Okay, thank you. And then secondly, can you give us some idea maybe for last year of what e-commerce was to your total so we can get some idea of how to think about what sales may or may not occur during this time of store closing?
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Well, Sam, again we've never shared that color and we can't start that today. It's such a huge impact on all channels that I just -- I don't want to get into that practice. If we see that over time we continue to have these store closures, I'd be more than comfortable to share that breakout at some point, but as we sit here today, I'm not comfortable doing that yet.
Sam Poser -- Susquehanna International Group, LLP -- Analyst
Okay, thank you. And again, stay safe.
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Yeah, thanks, Sam.
Jared A. Poff -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Designer Brands
Thank you.
Operator
And ladies and gentlemen, this concludes the question-and-answer session. I would like to turn the conference back over to Roger Rawlins for any closing remarks.
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Thanks again. I know everyone's got a lot going on. We appreciate you taking the time to listen in today. Again, I want to reinforce, we're working to protect the health and safety of our associates. We're working to help the health of our long-term business. I think the fact that this organization has demonstrated a resiliency and passion for overcoming hurdles that have been thrown our way, whether it'd be a border tax, a tariff, changing consumer landscape, changing competitive landscape, I will tell you, I feel very confident in our ability to get through this challenge and to come out stronger and more relevant to our partners, to our customers and grow amazing brands and leverage our retail channels to add value for our shareholders. So, thank you so much for your time and everybody please be safe.
Operator
[Operator Closing Remarks]
Duration: 64 minutes
Call participants:
Stacy Turnof -- Senior Vice President at Edelman
Roger L. Rawlins -- Chief Executive Officer, Designer Brands & Interim President, DSW
Jared A. Poff -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer, Designer Brands
Sam Poser -- Susquehanna International Group, LLP -- Analyst
Rick Patel -- Needham & Company -- Analyst
Tom Nikic -- Wells Fargo -- Analyst
Paul Trussell -- Deutsche Bank -- Analyst
Dana Telsey -- Telsey Advisory Group -- Analyst
Chris Svezia -- Wedbush Securities, Inc. -- Analyst
