Cyclical stocks like Caterpillar (NYSE:CAT) are always subject to debate as to when and where the peak will occur in their earnings, and right now it's all the investment community seems to be focusing on. The company's recent second-quarter earnings were strong, and management was moved to increase full-year adjusted profit per share by 7% at the midpoint of guidance.

However, some analysts responded by downgrading their recommendations and price targets. What's going on, and what should investors make of it?

Mining machinery

Image source: Getty Image.

What the market is worried about

The Caterpillar bears are concerned that the company has passed, or is about to pass, peak cycle earnings. This is always a concern with cyclical companies because earnings at peak will be far higher than at the trough. Paradoxically, this means a cyclical company usually trades at a low price-to-earnings ratio at the peak and high P/E at the trough.

In other words, Caterpillar's forward P/E of less than 12 is a value trap if the company' earnings are set to peak. Such thinking was encapsulated by a question from Jefferies analyst Stephen Volkmann on the earnings call: "[T]he market is worried about where the industrial cycle is, and whether things may be kind of midcycle or above. And I'm curious if you have an opinion as to sort of where we are overall with Cat cycles."

There's a sense that the global construction cycle is a bit long in the tooth, and a look at Caterpillar's retail sales growth figures suggests that growth is indeed slowing in all its end markets:

Caterpillar retail sales

Data source: Caterpillar presentations. Chart by author.

Throw in concerns over the potential impact of tariffs on major industrial companies like Caterpillar, and it's tempting to conclude that selling the stock makes good sense.

I think it's far too early to draw such a conclusion from the information in front of us. There are two key arguments:

1. Sales remain below previous cycle levels

First, director of investor relations Amy Campbell pointed out that Caterpillar's Europe, Africa, and Middle East (EAME) sales are "well below sales levels a decade ago." In addition, while North America sales are currently very strong, they come after "years of below-trend sales." In other words, the rate of growth of sales might have peaked, but that doesn't mean sales growth won't remain positive so earnings can continue to grow.

To flesh out what Campbell is saying, consider oil-production capital spending, relevant to Caterpillar's energy and construction equipment: It peaked at $519 billion in 2014, then slumped as oil prices fell in 2014. Analyst projections are for spending to increase from $246 billion in 2017 to $299 billion in 2018 -- a far cry from levels in 2014.

2. Caterpillar isn't just about construction

Second, Caterpillar's key markets are driven by things like metals and mineral prices (in the resources industries segment), and the price of oil, as much as they are by the construction cycle. If these commodity prices go up, then capital spending by their producers (Caterpillar's customers) are likely going up. So unless you have a strong view that mining commodities and oil are going down, it doesn't make sense to conclude that Caterpillar's end markets are about to peak.

To illustrate the point that Caterpillar isn't just about construction, here's a look at second-quarter earnings from the three key segments. As you can see below, construction is the biggest profit center, but the biggest contributor to growth was the energy and transportation segment, closely followed by the fast-recovering resource industries segment:

How Caterpillar Generates Earnings and Earnings Growth

Data source: Caterpillar presentations. Chart by author.

Furthermore, the direction of Caterpillar's operating earnings has closely followed that of energy and mining commodity prices:

CAT Operating Income (TTM) Chart

CAT Operating Income (TTM) data by YCharts.

The takeaway for investors

Putting all this together, it seems clear that assuming Caterpillar is about to hit peak earnings is actually assuming both that energy and mining commodity prices are coming down in the next year or so, and that the global construction cycle is in late innings. These may or may not be the case. But unless you feel strongly that they are, the company's forward P/E of just less than 12 isn't going to stop you from buying or holding the stock. All told, Caterpillar is only expensive if energy and mining commodity prices are coming down.

Lee Samaha has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.