Is it true that a simple asset beats a more complicated and clever one when cash is on the line? Even if you're only investing with $1,000, you still want something you can explain in a sentence and still believe in after it has a bad week.
In a sense, that's what separates Cardano (ADA 0.88%) and Zcash (ZEC 2.37%) today. Cardano tells a sweeping story about a meticulous engineering process that leads to better outcomes in the long run, whereas Zcash offers a simpler claim: it has Bitcoin's scarcity mechanics, plus the option for private transfers. So which one of these coins is a better pick with $1,000 -- the one-trick pony, or the versatile and multi-functional platform?
Image source: Getty Images.
Zcash has a clearer thesis, but a questionable near-term
Zcash is the simpler asset here, because it's essentially "just" Bitcoin plus a privacy feature that sounds fancy but is actually pretty easy to use.
Zcash has Bitcoin's fixed 21-million-coin supply, as well as its four-year halving cadence. The optional privacy features utilize a type of cryptographic proof known as zk-SNARKs. That means holders can use transparent wallet addresses like Bitcoin offers by default, or shielded addresses that encrypt sender, receiver, and amount while the network still verifies validity.
CRYPTO: ZEC
Key Data Points
For what it's worth, in a forum post in 2010, Bitcoin's enigmatic originator, Satoshi Nakamoto, held that if Bitcoin were to implement such "zero knowledge" proofs as part of its cryptography, "a much better, easier, more convenient implementation of Bitcoin would be possible." So Zcash is putting into production an idea that has been circulating in the Bitcoin community for a long time, dating back to its launch in late 2016.
But why does that matter now, of all times? In short, because Zcash just went vertical. The coin is up by 1,190% in the last three months alone. That's a textbook sign that the asset has market attention, for better and worse.
In fact, as of Nov. 13, there's now a Zcash digital asset treasury (DAT) company for the first time, meaning the coin has joined the trend of most of the other leading cryptoassets over the last year or so. Such buyers will constrict the circulating supply and force later buyers to compete with each other via bidding for higher prices.
But privacy coins invite regulatory scrutiny. Crypto exchanges have delisted Zcash and its peers in parts of the European Union. Policy momentum in Europe points to significantly tightening rules clamping down on anonymous transfers over the next couple of years. That could compress Zcash's exchange access or liquidity, and make it quite hard to invest in for most investors -- not to mention hard to sell for those who hold it.
The very same momentum that lifted Zcash can unwind fast. Investors should thus assume higher volatility than its Bitcoin-like branding suggests.
Cardano has a good track record on tech, but it lacks adoption
Cardano's promise is that it'll maintain an orderly system of innovation regarding its core tech platform, with peer-reviewed research, staged upgrades, consensus-building discussions, and a network meant to balance scalability, security, and sustainability. All that is admirable in a world where Mark Zuckerberg's ethos of "move fast and break things" tends to be glorified rather than questioned. But for investors, the most important scoreboard is network usage and value captured on-chain.
On those issues, Cardano isn't doing great. Across Cardano's decentralized finance (DeFi) ecosystem, total value locked (TVL) and trading volumes remain very modest relative to its ambitions and relative to leading smart contract chains. As of Nov. 13, there were roughly 25,000 daily active wallet addresses in the last 24 hours, and only $257 million in total value locked.
CRYPTO: ADA
Key Data Points
The ongoing question is one of competitive advantage. Cardano is not competing for tokenized real-world assets (RWAs). It's not the first (or second, or third) stop for stablecoin payments, the leading AI or crypto gaming chain, or the center of DeFi liquidity.
So when capital hunts for utility, it almost always goes elsewhere first. That leaves Cardano's investment thesis dependent on "catch-up" narratives where it's aiming to pick up the scraps left by the bigger players, rather than a story of gaining undeniable traction in a key niche.
What's the call?
Until Cardano wins a beachhead where it is the obvious choice, the investment case leans on hope rather than cash flows, fees, or network effects you can measure today. Therefore, Zcash is the better asset of the two to buy with $1,000, based on the simplicity of its thesis and its ongoing burst of adoption.
But, given how stretched the move is already, with prices skyrocketing in a very short period, new buyers should scale in very slowly or wait for pullbacks instead of chasing price spikes. The long term looks good for this coin. It's just that it's probably too hot to touch for the average investor's risk tolerance at the moment.
