I can understand why Movie Gallery (NASDAQ:MOVI) chose to put out a press release affirming its previous outlook. Shares of the DVD rental chain fell a whopping 20% on Friday, after Goldman Sachs disclosed that it had trimmed its stake in the company.

Based on the premise that an institutional investor sold just a third of its holdings, the plunge was overdone, and the press release was the right move for Movie Gallery. Parroting back its November guidance -- which calls for comps at the store level to decline between 5% and 9%, and not far worse -- is fine.

My problem is that Movie Gallery chose to wax optimistically about a future that, in reality, is only likely to get bleaker.

"Looking forward to 2006, with the continued softness in the rental industry, we will soon resume discussions with our lenders regarding further amendments to Movie Gallery's senior credit facility," CEO Joe Malugen was quoted in this morning's release.

That's fair. The softness is evident in the financials, and even Blockbuster (NYSE:BBI) -- with nearly twice as many stores worldwide as Movie Gallery -- had to go back to the table with its creditors to relax its lending terms last year. However, Malugen then tried to put a positive spin on the malaise.

"We continue to believe that our industry is long-term fundamentally sound, and we are looking forward to the introduction of next-generation, high-definition DVDs as a significant catalyst for our business."

What? Can anyone reasonably assume that the video store rental business is "long-term fundamentally sound," or that Blu-ray and HD-DVD will turn Movie Gallery around? I don't think so.

For starters, with companies like Netflix (NASDAQ:NFLX) and Blockbuster Online eating away at the market share of the traditional rental stores, is there any reason to believe that the trend will shift back to the bricks-and-mortar chains? More importantly, what about the threat of digital delivery? Isn't it only going to grow and further nibble away at the Blockbuster Videos of the world?

The argument in favor of Movie Gallery is that it will be the last major player to feel this hit. Its flagship chain has focused on rural markets, where the fat pipes and willing audiences necessary to make it happen are less far along than in more metropolitan areas. This may have changed after the city slicker Hollywood Video chain was acquired by Movie Gallery last year, but the argument still carries some weight. However, I imagine that this is also the same demographic group that will be the last to adopt the new high-definition DVD technologies.

Another concern is whether the smaller Movie Gallery stores are equipped with the rack space to handle the same title on three different formats. Netflix already threw its support behind the new platforms, but I don't see new formats as being a savior to the rental chains.

HD-DVD will be great for the movie studios, since they are able to sell duplicate versions of older titles on the higher-end format. Consumer electronics chains like Best Buy (NYSE:BBY) and Circuit City (NYSE:CC) will also rake it in as folks upgrade their players. I just don't see how the fading rental industry feels that cutting-edge technology will save the day -- especially when dealing with the same technology-hungry crowd that will most likely bolt to home-delivered or digitally delivered rental options.

Sorry, Movie Gallery. You lost me at "looking forward."

Tomorrow, I'll be back to explore the ramifications of Blockbuster's latest policy of including free, weekly in-store rentals to its online subscribers.

Shares of Netflix and Best Buy have been recommended in our Stock Advisor newsletter service. Learn more with a free 30-day trial subscription.

Longtime Fool contributor Rick Munarriz lives in South Florida, the original stomping grounds for Blockbuster. He also owns shares in Netflix and has been renting online since 2002.The Fool has a disclosure policy. Rick is also part of theRule Breakersnewsletter research team, seeking out tomorrow's ultimate growth stocks a day early.