If you have ever visited an ill friend or relative in the hospital, you've probably noted the company name on the hospital bed: Hill-Rom (NYSE: HRC). The Hill-Rom name is so ubiquitous in hospitals that you might think it has a monopoly on hospital beds. In fact, it has had to fend off -- and eventually settle -- several antitrust lawsuits over the past decade.

So you might think that the $30 million legal settlement charge that Hill-Rom took in its latest quarterly earnings report would be for yet another antitrust lawsuit. It isn't. It has to do with a billing dispute the company has with the federal government, and that money may or may not have to eventually be paid.

However, because of that charge, Hill-Rom's earnings plunged 95%. Shares fell 20% on that earnings news and have fallen an additional 15% since on the general market turmoil.

Is that scalping deserved, or is Hill-Rom now a genuine bargain?

Buying opportunity?
When analysts expect $0.54 per share in earnings but the result turns out to be $0.02 per share, then yes, that would call for more than a polite "I daresay" in response. But the fall from $45 a share to $30a share because of that one-time charge was probably an overreaction.

True, one of Hill-Rom's three business segments, International, took a hit in Europe, which represents about 70% of the companies overseas revenues. Hill-Rom's CEO blamed that downturn on the "macro challenges" in Europe, and he anticipates that those challenges will lead to a year-over-year decline in fourth-quarter international revenues.

Consider the following table for Hill-Rom and some of its competitors. What I am pleased to see here are the solid returns on invested capital. This metric speaks to how well a company uses its money.

Company

Forward P/E

Forward Dividend Yield

Dividend Payout Ratio

Return on Capital (TTM)

Hill-Rom Holdings 12.1 1.5% 22% 15.2%
Kinetic Concepts (NYSE: KCI) 12.6 N/A N/A 11.4%
Stryker (NYSE: SYK) 11.8 1.5% 22% 14.6%
Becton, Dickinson (NYSE: BDX) 12.9 2.0% 27% 14.6%
Invacare (NYSE: IVC) 11.0 0.2% 4% 6.9%

Source: Yahoo! Finance.
ROIC computed from company earnings statements.
TTM = trailing 12 months.

My take
I think the pricing right now for Hill-Rom is quite attractive, but I don't think the company will have a sudden growth spurt. The worldwide economic problems will be a revenue constrictor for who knows how long. Also, domestically, proposed Medicare budget cuts could have a negative impact on Hill-Rom's business. If you do buy this stock, then buy it to sit on it … for a while.

Add Hill-Rom and the other companies mentioned to your Watchlist.