One of my favorite stocks, Ariba (Nasdaq: ARBA) suffered a downturn and I wanted to take advantage of the situation. After reaching a high on March 8 of this year, it started to plunge. By March 27 it had lost more than a quarter of its value. I looked at the reasons for the drop and reconsidered the company. I felt that this was still an excellent long-term hold and the time was right for another purchase.
I examined my finances to see if there was some way that I could afford to buy more of the company. The problem was that I had recently purchased a house and you know how expensive it can be to get the telephone hooked up, the electricity turned on, etc. I decided that I simply couldn't afford to buy more at the time.
The stock continued its slide and by April 4 it was worth 40% less than the early March high. I looked at the news again, noted that the bottom had fallen out of the other Nasdaq companies, and I decided to add more onto my stake.
Again, I checked through my finances for extra money. However, I had recently purchased a house and we were looking at a security system -- and you know how expensive those can be.
On April 24 I looked again at the price and it had now dropped more than 60% from the March high. This is a company with a tremendous future that was getting carried downstream with the rest of the other Nasdaq companies. I knew that it was absolutely time to pool my resources and make another purchase.
My finest comb, however, could not find funds that were not accounted for, as I had bought this house, you see, and� well, you get the picture.
I had called it -- the bottom -- three times, and so far, two of those were wrong (the jury is still out on the third call).
As I had called the bottom wrong two of the three times, it got me thinking about the wisdom of setting up a fee-laden Pseudo-Drip in cases where the company offers a fee-free Drip. The most commonly mentioned reason for doing this is to take control of the timing of the purchases. Paying a fee to be able to work the timing aspect is certainly something at which I would not be successful.
It is no problem to watch a price fall and call the current condition a dip. However, it is a much different matter to know the point at which the falling action should actually trigger an additional purchase. If one could do so on a consistent basis, then it would make sense to set things up to take advantage of those opportunities.
Beginning a Pseudo-Drip to make one's purchases this way can be a costly affair. The fee for a single purchase should be of little concern. The problem, however, shows itself when one does this on a regular basis. Consider a $2.99 monthly fee invested over 20 years where it returns 11%. That $717.60, when invested as such, would result in $2,588.26. Suddenly we are talking about real money.
However, I am not willing to discount the use of a Pseudo-Drip for this purpose completely. Because BuyandHold.com (www.buyandhold.com) and Sharebuilder (www.sharebuilder.com) do not charge the customer if a minimum number of purchases are not made during the course of a year, it would make sense to open an account to use them to make those additional purchases.
For instance, if one had made a purchase of Intel through the regular Drip and the price then dropped to a level at which one wished to make an additional purchase, the Pseudo-Drip account could do this at a cost much less than a typical discount broker. There's certainly nothing wrong with holding the shares of a company in two different places.
But I would like, at some time, to return to the problem of determining the trigger point for an additional purchase. If you have an unemotional, mechanical means for doing this, I would invite you to share your idea with us on the Drip Investing boards linked below.
I Called It (Wrong)
You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More
A Fool tries to time the market and gets it wrong... twice. George Smyth learns a lesson.
Invest Smarter with The Motley Fool
Join Over Half a Million Premium Members Receiving…
- New Stock Picks Each Month
- Detailed Analysis of Companies
- Model Portfolios
- Live Streaming During Market Hours
- And Much More
Motley Fool Investing Philosophy
- #1 Buy 25+ Companies
- #2 Hold Stocks for 5+ Years
- #3 Add New Savings Regularly
- #4 Hold Through Market Volatility
- #5 Let Winners Run
- #6 Target Long-Term Returns
Why do we invest this way? Learn More
Related Articles
Motley Fool Returns
Market-beating stocks from our award-winning analyst team.
Calculated by average return of all stock recommendations since inception of the Stock Advisor service in February of 2002. Returns as of 03/28/2024.
Discounted offers are only available to new members. Stock Advisor list price is $199 per year.
Calculated by Time-Weighted Return since 2002. Volatility profiles based on trailing-three-year calculations of the standard deviation of service investment returns.
Premium Investing Services
Invest better with The Motley Fool. Get stock recommendations, portfolio guidance, and more from The Motley Fool's premium services.