Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Fortuna Silver Mines (FSM) Q4 2019 Earnings Call Transcript

By Motley Fool Transcribing - Mar 13, 2020 at 12:00PM

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

FSM earnings call for the period ending December 31, 2019.

Logo of jester cap with thought bubble.

Image source: The Motley Fool.

Fortuna Silver Mines (FSM -0.59%)
Q4 2019 Earnings Call
Mar 12, 2020, 12:00 p.m. ET


  • Prepared Remarks
  • Questions and Answers
  • Call Participants

Prepared Remarks:


Good day, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the Fortuna Silver Mines fourth-quarter and full-year 2019 financial and operational results call. [Operator instructions] At this time, it's my pleasure to turn the floor over to Mr. Carlos Baca, investor relations manager. Sir, the floor is yours.

Carlos Baca -- Investor Relations Manager

Thank you, Tom. Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. I would like to welcome you all to Fortuna Silver Mines and to our financial and operational results call for the fourth-quarter and full-year 2019. Today, we will be using a webcast presentation which will be controlled by us.

To download the presentation, please go to our website at, click on the Investors tab, then click on the financials sub tab. And under Q4 2019, click on the Earnings call webcast link. Jorge Alberto Ganoza, president and CEO and director; and Luis Dario Ganoza, CFO, will be hosting the call from Lima, Peru. Before I turn over the call to Jorge, I would like to indicate that this earnings call contains forward-looking information that is based on the company's current expectations, estimates and beliefs.

This forward-looking information is subject to a number of risks, uncertainties and other factors. Actual results could differ materially from a conclusion, forecast or projection in the forward-looking information. Certain material factors or assumptions were applied in drawing a conclusion or making a forecast or projection as reflected in the forward-looking information. Additional information about the material factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from the conclusion, forecast or projection in the forward-looking information and the material factors or assumptions that were applied in drawing a conclusion or making a forecast or projection as reflected in the forward-looking information is contained in the company's annual information form and MD&A, which are publicly available on SEDAR.

The company assumes no obligation to update such forward-looking information in the future, except as required by law. I would now like to turn the call over to Jorge Alberto Ganoza, president, CEO, and co-founder of Fortuna.

Jorge Alberto Ganoza -- President, Chief Executive Officer, and Director

Thank you, Carlos, and good morning to all. As Carlos stated, along with Luis, our CFO, we'll be presenting a review of our Q4 and year-end financial results and main developments across our projects and operations in Mexico, Peru and Argentina. In Slide 6 of the presentation under highlights for the year. We're pleased to report strong financial results with annual adjusted earnings of $28 million, free cash flow from ongoing operations of $34.5 million and a robust EBITDA margin of 37%.

Liquidity available stands at $123 million with a current debt-to-EBITDA ratio of 1.7. This ratio is expected to peak at 2.4 by midyear before the start of commercial operations at Lindero. As of the end of January, Lindero shows a completion of 89% with $280 million of construction spending and first dor planned for the end of Q2 2020, as announced in our December construction update. A year of strong financial results and difficult challenges that we have overcome was tainted by a fatal accident of a mine contractor at our San Jose mine in August.

This terrible loss was a blow to our organization at a time when our efforts are showing sustained improvement year over year in safety performance indicators as we will show. We pledge our commitment to our culture and procedures conducive to a safe work environment where all our personnel goes back home safe and sound every day. In the second quarter of this year, we will be releasing our 2019 sustainability report. This is a much improved and comprehensive effort compared to our first published report for 2018.

We expect this report will set a solid baseline from which we can benchmark our progress on key areas of environment, social and economic benefits to the communities. Next slide, please. In Slide 7, although health and safety have always been a priority at Fortuna, starting three years ago, we recognized we could not achieve our objectives without a cultural change. The plans we implemented to defend are rendering strong results as we can show in these three graphs, which present trends over four years for total recordable injury rate, lost time injury rate and severity rate of injuries across our operations and projects.

This is a process of continued learning and improvement across three countries, involving over 3,500 people today. And as I stated before in this presentation, we pledge our commitment to our culture and procedures, conducing to a safe work environment where all our personnel goes back home safe and sound every day. Slide 8. For 2019, we met our annual guidance once again and produced 8.8 million ounces of silver and 50,500 ounces of gold.

Looking at Q4 production against Q4 of last year, silver production was up 16%; and gold, essentially plus. Next slide. In Slide 9, our realized price for silver in Q4 was $17.30, compared to $14.60 per ounce a year ago. The story is similar for gold, where we realized a price of $1,483 compared to $1,236.

We look with anticipation at the price environment this year, particularly for gold as we plan for a significant increase in annual gold ounces produced and our Lindero project going into production in the second quarter. Slide 10. Under consolidated financial highlights for the period. Order sales, adjusted EBITDA and adjusted net income were higher when compared to Q4 2018.

Not shown in this slide, but our sales for the year were $257 million. This is 2% lower when compared to 2018. Higher realized silver and gold prices for the year were offset by a 7% lower gold production, higher TCRCs and lower by-product lead and zinc prices. Adjusted EBITDA for the quarter was $25 million, yielding an EBITDA margin of 36% and net income at $11 million or $0.07 per share.

Next slide. In Slide 11, we present our all-in sustaining cost on a comparable basis for the quarter and year. For 2019, our consolidated all-in sustaining cost is $11.90 per ounce, in line with annual guidance and 13% higher than 2018. The year-over-year increase is explained by higher cash cost at both Caylloma and San Jose mines, deteriorated commercial terms for concentrate and lower realized by-product prices for -- or by-products lead and zinc.

Slide 12. Capital investments for the year totaled $215 million, $188 million allocated to the Lindero construction and pre-operation, $20 million in sustaining capital at our two operating mines and approximately $7 million in brownfields and greenfields exploration. Slide 13. This slide presents a pyramid with our current asset portfolio and 2020 guidance for mine and project.

Over the last two-and-a-half years, we have been doing something that is not very popular in a tough market for mining equities, where investors have been largely sector risk averse. We have been building a mine. It is our view that in our industry, to provide shareholders with long-term superior returns on assets and growth, one must consider countercyclical strategies for capital allocation. And that is precisely what we have done with the timing for acquisition and development of Lindero.

Short term, it has been difficult, and we're not where we need to be yet. We're very close but not there yet. We have been dealing with the inherent complexities of a large construction in a remote location in a known mining jurisdiction like Argentina. Despite all this, we're showing a 20% deviation in our capex forecast when compared with guidance provided back in 2017.

We plan for Lindero to take our consolidated gold production from 50,000 ounces in 2019 to approximately 110,000 in 2020 and closer to 180,000 in a full year of production, all this at a time when gold price is trending to higher levels driven by renewed investor interest. At current prices, our internal rate of return for Lindero is in the low 20s. Slide 14. We provided an update to our construction schedule on February 13.

We plan to initiate stacking of ore early in the second quarter. We're targeting April, and we expect to see first gold in late May or June. Next slide. As of the end of January, Lindero reports an advance of 89% complete.

For February, we're really closer to 92% complete. We forecast construction capex between $314 million to $320 million, an increase of 28% compared to our 2020 guidance, as I stated before. The increase in this figure is largely driven by higher owners and direct costs associated to the extension of our construction timing. Next slide.

We were providing a slide regarding conducting business in Argentina under the current conditions. This is -- we've been addressing questions from shareholders and investors regarding the current business environment in Argentina. Under the current laws and regulations, we have no restrictions on capital repatriations through the use of official FX markets for intercompany debt repayments. Fortuna expects to fund close to $200 million or over $200 million through intercompany debt, so we have the ability to access the official FX market to service this debt.

There has been a step in the right direction taken by Argentinian authorities early this year, easing restrictions for repatriation of capital. Today, dealing and distributions allowed through official FX market are up to 30% of invested capital. This is new regulation that came in effect early this year. There are no restrictions to conduct the imports of capital goods and supplies through official FX market.

So we have the ability to service the requirements of our business, accessing the official FX market. We confirm that. With respect to export duties, dor exports are subject to 8% duty and concentrate, subject to a 5% duty. Fortuna, through its subsidiary Mansfield in Argentina, has a company tax-stability agreement, which caps export duties at about -- at 5% for Lindero.

Next slide, we present a series of updated photos for the construction. Preproduction mining at Lindero commenced back in September 2019. We currently have about one million tonnes of mid-grade ore in stockpile, and the mine has -- the full fleet is operational. And I can report that it is achieving in late February -- since late February, early March its designed rate of mining.

Next slide, leach pad and stacking system. Our leach pad is ready to receive ore. We are concluding finalizing installation and commissioning initiation of pre-commissioning activities on the stacking system. Next slide, please.

Primary and secondary crushing circuits are currently under commissioning with load. We are running ore through primary and secondary crushers as part of commissioning activities. Next slide, the tertiary crusher, which is the HPGR, or high-pressure grinding roll, is under pre-commissioning. It's been -- the crusher, the HPGR has been launched already without load as part of pre-commissioning activities.

We expect to be running the crush, the tertiary crushing system with ore, in line with primary, secondary and tertiary crushing systems this month. Next slide, please. This is a general view of our processing facilities with ancillary facilities as well, ADR plants, SART plants, our power plants and assay lab. ADR plant is on piping and electrical installation at this stage.

We are expecting commissioning for May or this month. SART plant is the same. Basically, mechanical installations are 90% concluded, and we are advancing with piping and electrical. With that, I turn the call to Luis, so he can take you through our results for the period.

Luis Dario Ganoza -- Chief Financial Officer

Thank you. On Slide 25. As has been discussed by Jorge, we had a strong fourth quarter driven by higher sales, up 16% over Q4 2018. We reported quarterly net income of $19 million, compared to $2.2 million in Q4 of 2018.

And after adjusting for noncash and certain nonrecurring items, we recorded adjusted net income of $10.9 million, significantly above the $4.4 million in 2018. As Jorge mentioned as well, adjusted EBITDA increased 11% to $25.1 million. Free cash flow from ongoing operations was $6.4 million, down 46% over 2018, due mostly to timing issues on our sales and trade receivables, as well as an accumulation of VAT receivable at our San Jose mine. For the full-year 2019, we recorded adjusted net income of $28.4 million.

It's 26% below 2018 as a result of slightly lower sales, higher production cash cost over the prior year and higher share-based payments, expenses and exploration and evaluation cost. Our annual EBITDA of $95.4 million was 16% below the prior year, and we generated annual free cash flow from ongoing operations for the full year of $34.5 million, which was impacted by an accumulation of VAT receivable in Mexico of around $10 million in the year. Next slide, Slide 26. When breaking down our sales performance for the quarter, we can see the highest impact came from higher silver and gold metal prices, which were 19% and 20% above Q4 2018, as well as higher silver and zinc production.

Moving on to the next slide, Slide 27. When looking at our comparative segmented results over Q4 2018, we can see that the strong results in the quarter were driven by the San Jose mine, which saw improved EBITDA of 34%. As we have discussed, these results were, in turn, driven by higher sales, which more than offset an increase in production cash cost at both San Jose and Caylloma. Production cash cost at San Jose in Q4 was slightly above our annual guidance range, but we remain within guidance for the full year.

At Caylloma, cash cost was in line with guidance both for Q4 and the full year. On Slide 28. The bulk of the increase in total G&A of $9.4 million for the quarter comes from share-based payment expenses related mostly to a higher share price. We do have higher G&A expenses at the operating mines for Q4, as shown in the first line item, where the increase is due mostly to expenses of a nonrecurring nature.

Moving forward, we expect an average of $2.5 million per quarter on this line item. And for corporate G&A, we expect average quarterly expenditures in line with the amount we see for Q4 of 2019 of $3 million. Our effective tax rate on an adjusted basis was 23% for the quarter and 46% for the full year. The lower effective tax rate in the quarter reflects higher deferred tax credits related to the recognition of the convertible debenture and the positive impact of movements in foreign exchange affecting our income tax provision.

Although not included in this slide, there are two additional items pertaining to financials that merit a comment. The first one being the $11 million of investment gains in Q4. These are gains denominated in Argentine pesos and related to trades, which constitute part of our strategy to bring dollars into the country as we seek to obtain the best possible exchange rate under current market conditions. We do not expect any further significant gains in relation to these trades in Q1.

The second item pertains our VAT receivable in Argentina. Total VAT incurred as of year-end 2019 on accumulative basis is $49 million, and accumulative foreign exchange losses recorded so far amount to $14.9 million, of which $12 million took place in 2019. We expect to begin collection of VAT as we start generating revenue at Lindero. And even though the delaying the schedule does increase our exposure, we do anticipate that, once in operation, we should be able to recover within a 12-month period.

On our next slide, Slide 29, we provide a summary of our liquidity position at year end and our projection of liquidity over the coming quarters as we transition Lindero toward the commissioning phase based on the updated schedule for the project. Our liquidity position as of year-end 2019 was $123 million. We expect to maintain a minimum liquidity of between $30 million and $45 million through the start of commercial operations based on our existing credit facility and free cash flow generation. On top of this, we are looking to put in place a short-term completion facility at the asset level as we go fully into the commissioning phase.

With that, I conclude my prepared remarks and back to you, Carlos.

Carlos Baca -- Investor Relations Manager

Thank you, Luis. We would now like to turn the call over to any questions that you may have.

Questions & Answers:


[Operator instructions] And we do have a question coming through from Justin Stevens with PI Financial. Justin, please check your mute button on your phone. We cannot hear you at this time. [Operator instructions] And Justin, your line is open again.

Could you check your mute button, please?

Justin Stevens -- PI Financial -- Analyst

Hello. Can you hear me now? Hello. No?


Yes, we can hear you.

Justin Stevens -- PI Financial -- Analyst

Ok. Sorry about that. Thanks, guys. You answered most of my questions.

I was mostly wondering on power at Lindero. You guys have a power purchase agreement from a contractor, right? So the diesel generation is done at a fixed price per kilowatt hour?

Jorge Alberto Ganoza -- President, Chief Executive Officer, and Director

We are responsible for sourcing the fuel for the power generation, so we are currently contemplating price protection or hedging alternatives, taking advantage of where the oil has been trending, so yes.

Justin Stevens -- PI Financial -- Analyst

Yes. That's most of what I was -- yeah. So yes. Because you supply -- if you're sourcing all the diesel for the site, then you could theoretically realize some of the sort of the -- recognize some of these lower prices and lock them in going forward.

Jorge Alberto Ganoza -- President, Chief Executive Officer, and Director

Yes, yes.

Justin Stevens -- PI Financial -- Analyst

Great. Other than that, yes, just the timing on that first dor pour, I guess, will depend on how quickly you can irrigate after stacking, but the current plan is to stack, you said, in April. And then when do you think you'll be irrigating?

Jorge Alberto Ganoza -- President, Chief Executive Officer, and Director

Yes, absolutely. Irrigation is a function of available surface area on the ore placed on the leach pad. There are several factors there. One is our ability to have a smooth commissioning of and placement of ore from the start on the leach pad.

We have a commissioning curve that we are working under. The delays that we have been encountering, although unfortunate, also create opportunities, give time for us. We're not just sitting there. So the primary crushing, the secondary crushing, for example, we are stressing the equipment.

We already are advancing with addressing issues that otherwise we would be dealing with in the commissioning phase with the entire site within operation, for example, small spills and corrections on structures and shoots that are typical of the start of commissioning. So we are gaining time on primary. We're gaining time on secondary, and we're going to start doing the same with tertiary soon. So we are -- we have a curve for the commissioning and operation ramp-up of our systems to start placing ore on the leach pad, and we believe we can start irrigating relatively soon.

And as that ore is going to be closer to plastic, we expect we can be generating enough solutions that we can start running our ADR by late May or June.

Justin Stevens -- PI Financial -- Analyst

Ok. No, that sounds good. And you currently -- I'm assuming, you've got everything that you need on site. Now there is nothing that's really outstanding yet on that end?

Jorge Alberto Ganoza -- President, Chief Executive Officer, and Director

In terms of supplies, you mean?

Justin Stevens -- PI Financial -- Analyst

Yes, supplies and equipment. Everything has been transported to site.

Jorge Alberto Ganoza -- President, Chief Executive Officer, and Director

Yes, yes, yes. In terms of equipment, we have everything. In terms of supplies, explosives, we're drilling and blasting every day since September. Cyanide, we have a -- and due to our concerns on supply chain due to the coronavirus, we are taking action to guarantee our key supplies to site.

Justin Stevens -- PI Financial -- Analyst

Yes. And just on the stockpiling. Are you still sort of mostly running -- moving waste and some of the lower-grade ore to expose the higher-grade ore? Or have you started moving to some of the higher-grade ore yet?

Jorge Alberto Ganoza -- President, Chief Executive Officer, and Director

We are going to start now building a smaller higher-grade stockpile in preparation, probably a week to two weeks of ore in the high-grade stockpile. Again, the idea was to minimize rehandle. In our mine plan, our mine plan has a mid-grade stockpile, we manage for the first year a mid-grade stockpile. So we have basically accomplished that through this preproduction phase.

We have the primary -- the higher-grade ore exposed. We're going to start building a small higher-grade stockpile, just small. And then we're going to start slowing down our mining rate until our crushing circuit is ready to start taking load.

Justin Stevens -- PI Financial -- Analyst

Right. And then so -- once you put sort of the drainage layer like the liner -- on top of the liners of, I'm assuming, sort of low grade, the first thing that will be some of that high grade from both the pit as well as that stockpile?

Jorge Alberto Ganoza -- President, Chief Executive Officer, and Director

Yes, yes.

Justin Stevens -- PI Financial -- Analyst

Right. Perfect. Well, that is it for me then. Thanks a lot, guys.

Jorge Alberto Ganoza -- President, Chief Executive Officer, and Director

Thank you.


We'll take our next question from Adrian Day with ADAM.

Adrian Day -- Adrian Day Asset Management -- Analyst

Adrian from Lindero. First one is on San Jose. I don't -- obviously, you've got your stay in court which was essential, but I don't know if you care to say are you in negotiations with the Mexican authorities on potential settlement. Or are you just pursuing it in the courts? And then the second question will be on Caylloma.

Do you have any sense of the next several quarters, what the mix of silver versus zinc, etc. might be?

Jorge Alberto Ganoza -- President, Chief Executive Officer, and Director

Ok. Thank you for the questions, Adrian. We are pursuing three lines of action with respect to the royalty claim in Mexico at our San Jose mine. First are the legal ones.

We have, as you mentioned, we requested an injunction to the -- to a court. And the -- or a request for an injunction was heard -- admitted by the court. And second, the court issued, first, a temporary stay that later moved into -- on March 2 moved into a permanent stay of execution. So the DGM and Mexican mining authorities have a period to appeal that.

I believe late this week or early next week is their deadline. That appeal will likely take several weeks, if not months, to get a result. But our legal team in Mexico believes that our arguments are sound and our legal position is strong, and the reflection of that is the continued resolutions we have been getting in this court. Second, there is a path on what's called in Mexico an administrative court where we have not filed an injunction, but we have filed a request that the authorities remove the inscription of the royalty from our title.

The administrative court is hearing this case. We presented this request in front of that court last year, and that is a process that is ongoing. And third, directly to your question is direct negotiations with the authorities. Yes.

We would like to have an agreement with authorities where we can settle this out of court. It is our strong view that there is no legal thesis for the royalty, but we would agree to a reasonable settlement at least out of court with authority. I have personally met already, in two occasions, with the secretary of mines of Mexico. We have had conversations where we have worked toward a plan to achieve these negotiations.

The Mexican law allows the authorities to engage in these type of discussions and negotiations and eventual settlement. It is not an easy process as it involves authorities, not only from the secretary of economy and mines, but also other branches of government, but we are working toward that as well. So those are the three lines of actions we are working on: the judicial court, the administrative court and an administrative solution with the authorities. With respect to Caylloma, a few years ago, we changed the revenue composition of Caylloma by focusing more on base metal zones and leaving behind the silver zones at this mine.

Just as a refresher, those silver zones were narrow veins, very labor intensive and with the related higher operating costs. So we believe that to return to those narrow veins at Caylloma that can help increase and even double our silver output from the current close to one million ounces that we produce at that mine would require sustained prices above $19. So at this stage, we are monitoring this closely, but we're not there yet. So for the year -- for 2020 and in our loans, what we have is a metal output composition, similar to what you've been seeing over the last years at this mine.

Luis Dario Ganoza -- Chief Financial Officer

And so to be around 20% silver in the revenue composition.

Jorge Alberto Ganoza -- President, Chief Executive Officer, and Director

Today, yes.

Luis Dario Ganoza -- Chief Financial Officer

Yes, approximately.

Adrian Day -- Adrian Day Asset Management -- Analyst

Ok. But there will be no difficulty going back to those silver-rich areas, veins?

Jorge Alberto Ganoza -- President, Chief Executive Officer, and Director

There is a period of preparation. I would -- if I have to provide a ballpark figure to you today, let me take several months to open up and prepare those areas for production back again. It will be measured in months.

Adrian Day -- Adrian Day Asset Management -- Analyst

OK. I appreciate that. Thank you.


[Operator instructions] And Mr. Baca, there appears to be no further questions at this time. I'll turn the call back over to you for closing remarks.

Carlos Baca -- Investor Relations Manager

Thank you, Tom. If there are no further questions, I would like to thank everyone for listening in to today's earnings call, and we look forward to you joining us next quarter. Have a great day.


[Operator signoff]

Duration: 41 minutes

Call participants:

Carlos Baca -- Investor Relations Manager

Jorge Alberto Ganoza -- President, Chief Executive Officer, and Director

Luis Dario Ganoza -- Chief Financial Officer

Justin Stevens -- PI Financial -- Analyst

Adrian Day -- Adrian Day Asset Management -- Analyst

More FSM analysis

All earnings call transcripts

Invest Smarter with The Motley Fool

Join Over 1 Million Premium Members Receiving…

  • New Stock Picks Each Month
  • Detailed Analysis of Companies
  • Model Portfolios
  • Live Streaming During Market Hours
  • And Much More
Get Started Now

Stocks Mentioned

Fortuna Silver Mines Inc. Stock Quote
Fortuna Silver Mines Inc.
$3.38 (-0.59%) $0.02

*Average returns of all recommendations since inception. Cost basis and return based on previous market day close.

Related Articles

Motley Fool Returns

Motley Fool Stock Advisor

Market-beating stocks from our award-winning service.

Stock Advisor Returns
S&P 500 Returns

Calculated by average return of all stock recommendations since inception of the Stock Advisor service in February of 2002. Returns as of 05/24/2022.

Discounted offers are only available to new members. Stock Advisor list price is $199 per year.

Premium Investing Services

Invest better with The Motley Fool. Get stock recommendations, portfolio guidance, and more from The Motley Fool's premium services.