Image source: The Motley Fool.
Meta Financial Group Inc (CASH 1.03%)
Q3Â 2020 Earnings Call
Jul 22, 2020, 5:00 p.m. ET
Contents:
- Prepared Remarks
- Questions and Answers
- Call Participants
Prepared Remarks:
Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for standing by, and welcome to the Meta Financial Group Fiscal Year 2020 Third Quarter Investor Conference Call. [Operator Instructions] Following the prepared remarks, we will conduct a question-and-answer session. [Operator Instructions]
I would now like to turn the conference call over to the Brittany Kelley Elsasser, Director of Investor Relations. Please go ahead.
Brittany Kelley Elsasser -- Director of Investor Relations
Thank you, and welcome to the Meta Financial Group conference call and webcast where President and CEO, Brad Hanson; and Executive Vice President and CFO, Glen Herrick will discuss the results of our third fiscal quarter ended June 30, 2020. Also participating in the call is Brett Pharr, Co-President and COO of MetaBank. Before I turn the call over, we want to apologize in advance for any potential technical difficulties that we may encounter as we are in different locations and continue to work remotely during this time.
Additional information, including the earnings release and investor presentation may be found on our website at metafinancialgroup.com. As a reminder, our comments may include forward-looking statements. Those statements are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual and anticipated results to differ. The company undertakes no obligation to update any forward-looking statements. Please refer to the cautionary language in the earnings release, investor presentation and in Meta's filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission, including our most recent filings for additional information, covering factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from the forward-looking statements.
Additionally, today we will be discussing certain non-GAAP financial measures on this conference call. References to non-GAAP measures are only provided to assist you in understanding Meta's results and performance trends. Reconciliations for such non-GAAP measures are included within the appendix of the investor presentation.
Now I will turn the call over to Brad Hanson.
Brad Hanson -- Co-President and Chief Executive Officer of Meta Financial Group, and Co-President and Chief Executi
Thank you, Brittany. It goes without saying that COVID-19 and various social awareness activities continue to impact the economy and psyche of our country. Through these times, I have watched with pride as my team successfully implemented our pandemic plan as part of our business continuity program protecting staff and enabling them to effectively serve our partners and customers while adapting to working from home. Engagement and productivity remain high as we continue our remote work schedules and contemplate various scenarios for safely allowing staff back into the office. This will likely include more flexible scheduling on an ongoing basis to allow for distancing and reduce the need for additional office space as we continue to grow.
The disciplined hard work of our people help us to earn $18.2 million or $0.53 per diluted share during the quarter compared to $0.75 in the prior year third quarter. The decline in EPS mostly reflected lower revenue as a result of last quarter sale of our Community Bank division, lower loan and lease balances, a decline in net interest margin given recent rate cuts, a higher provision for loan losses and reduce tax product in card fee income, partially offset by lower interest expense, tax rate and compensation costs.
While credit trends have outperformed our initial expectations, we believe it is prudent to remain conservative as macroeconomic conditions continue to evolve. We have taken additional provisions related to the uncertainty of the COVID pandemic allowing us to build our allowance. Our stock repurchase program remains on hold as we remain focused on strengthening our capital position. I believe there our allowance and strong balance sheet position us well should any unforeseen events unfold. I want to recognize the outstanding effort of our team members during this time.
Our commercial lending team immediately took steps to contact every borrower, ensuring they have access to appropriate loan deferral programs, modifications or government assistance programs such as the small business administration, paycheck protection program or PPP. They worked tirelessly providing PPP loans to existing customers and many new customers desperately looking for help when their existing financial institution was unable to assist. We heard numerous moving stories of appreciation from these businesses and hope that many of them will become long-term relationship for us going forward.
I also want to thank Central Bank for their efforts and servicing our legacy community bank loan portfolio. We appreciate their efforts as we can coordinate closely with them to manage our portfolio alongside their own providing the same high quality of service, our customers have come to expect. Our payments team successfully work to wind down two small program managers who were forced to discontinue operations due to the pandemic. They also coordinated with various partners to help ensure customer support issues were adequately addressed as call centers around the world, struggled to adapt and handle increased call volumes.
During the height of the pandemic, our teams work to secure the previously announced letter of intent with H&R Block, which is expected to be a significant contributor to earnings beginning in fiscal year '21. At the same time, MetaBank was selected as the issuer of prepaid cards for economic impact payments as part of the government stimulus package. We worked closely with Visa, Fiserv, the IRS and the US treasury to execute this important program in a timely manner.
Finally, I'd like to highlight some of the enhancements made in several areas of management. In addition to our current bench of strong business leaders, we've been fortunate to bring on Kathi Winter as Chief People Officer and Charles Ingram as Chief Information Officer. We promoted Anthony Sharett to Chief Legal and Compliance Officer and Corporate Secretary, as well as Brett Pharr to Co-President and COO of MetaBank. Under their leadership, we are realigning the company for growth and achieving even greater levels of execution, leaving us well prepared as we look forward.
Now let me turn the call over to Brett for more detail on our credit portfolios and overall response to COVID-19.
Brett Pharr -- Co-President and Chief Operating Officer of MetaBank
Thank you, Brad. I would like to start by saying, I'm honored and excited for the opportunity to work with the team as we navigate these unprecedented times. Over the last 18 months, management has focused a significant amount of time and effort in optimizing and streamlining our infrastructure resources and we will continue to focus on improving efficiencies and collaboration across teams and businesses.
Asset quality remains a priority for the company and as Brad mentioned, we likely won't fully understand the pandemics impact until COVID-related deferrals and modifications run their course. From a credit perspective, we continue to monitor each of our lending portfolios through these unprecedented times. A significant focus has been placed on our hospitality loans in the legacy community bank portfolio and on small ticket equipment finance relationships, which represent 3% of total assets. We are taking prudent steps in order to monitor and work with those customers to reduce potential losses.
As of June 30, 2020 Meta's Legacy Community Bank hospitality loan balances were $169 million or 2% of total assets, with an average loan to value ratio on those loans of 60% compared to 61% at March 31. The credit management team remains focused on these relationships, including real time tracking of key metrics such as occupancy and breakeven RevPAR and has been in regular contact with these borrowers. We are seeing occupancy rates start to rebound off of lows in April. A majority of these hotel relationships received PPP loans and 51% received some form of short-term payment deferral modifications.
Since the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic through June 30, 2020, we granted short-term payment deferral modifications on outstanding loan and lease balances of $352 million of which $292 million were still in their deferment period as of June 30, 2020. In addition, we granted a total of $53 million and other COVID-19 related modifications, of which 35 million are still active. The majority of the other modifications were related to adjusting the type or mount [Phonetic] customers payments. Of the total modifications have granted, $87 million were loans in the hospitality industry and $67 million were just small ticket equipment finance relationships.
As a result of the emerging COVID-19 pandemic, we also increased our allowance for loan and lease losses during the fiscal third quarter. As of June 30, excluding reserves on our seasonal tax services loans. Our allowance for loan and lease losses was $54.3 million or 1.56% of loans and leases, an increase from 1.25% at March 31, 2020 We will continue to diligently monitor the allowance for loan and lease losses and adjust as necessary in future periods to maintain an appropriate and supportable level. During the quarter, we took a provision for loan and lease losses of $15.1 million, $9.4 million of which was related to additional allowances for potential losses associated with the COVID-19 pandemic.
On Slide 6 of the investor deck, we provided historical look back on cumulative net charge-offs during the prior cycle. From a management perspective, virtually all the Crestmark leadership team worked through the last credit cycle and are very experienced in credit management debt restructuring and workouts. Non-performing loans and leases at June 30, 2020 represented 1.1% of total loans and leases, an increase of 23 basis points compared to March 31. The increased during the quarter was primarily related to deterioration in small ticket equipment finance relationships in our term lending and leasing portfolios.
Through June 30, 2020, we had 686 loans outstanding, drilling $215.5 million in loans under the paycheck protection program. The average fee rate of approximately 2.5% equates to approximately $5.3 million of net fees on an average loan size of $315,000. We will be deferring those fees until we receive them and amortizing them over the life of the loan. There were also be a yield adjustment assessment over the life of those loans as we would expect most of those to be forgiven.
As Brad mentioned, we were the issuer for the EIP cards. Under the program, we issued 3.6 million cards representing $6.42 billion in funding. As of July 19, over 80% of the cards had been activated and $2.08 billion in balances remained outstanding. As a result of the program, we saw a quick influx of deposits come on to our balance sheet with limited visibility into the duration. While this program had an immaterial impact to earnings, it's significantly increased our total assets which artificially depressed our leverage ratio and our net interest margin. We have provided a more in-depth analysis of the effects of the EIP cards in the appendix of our investor deck and in the earnings release.
Now let me turn the call over to Glen Herrick, our CFO, to provide more detail on our fiscal 2020 third quarter financial results.
Glen Herrick -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of Meta Financial Group and MetaBank
Thank you, Brett and good afternoon, everyone. For the third quarter of fiscal 2020, we reported GAAP net income of $18.2 million or $0.53 per diluted share compared to $29.3 million or $0.75 per diluted share for the same quarter of the prior year. The year-over-year decline was primarily related to one, lower net interest income as a result of lower loan balances related to the sale of the Community Bank division and a decrease in loan yields. Two, higher provisioning related to COVID-19 in the current economic environment. And three, lower non-interest income, mostly related to decreased card fee and tax product income.
The net interest margin was 3.28% for the fiscal 2020 third quarter. The EIP stimulus card balances that were held in cash pressured NIM by 140 basis points. Excluding the impact from those deposits, net interest margin was 4.68% compared to 5.07% in the fiscal 2019 third quarter. As we previously mentioned, we saw pressure on net interest margin in loan balances, with net interest income decreasing by 7% year-over-year. While, slower loan demand and lower yields likely continue to pressure net interest income in the near term, the ongoing transition of our earning asset mix likely leads to improved net interest margin over time.
Cost of funds, improved by 86 basis points compared to the same quarter in the prior fiscal year largely as a result of the EIP card deposits and the lower rate environment. While non-interest income of $41 million for the fiscal third quarter was down 6% from the same quarter of fiscal 2019, non-interest income did represent 40% of total revenue, reinforcing our differentiated business model. Non-interest expense decreased by 2% to $71.2 million for the fiscal third quarter compared to the same quarter of fiscal 2019. Expense reduction initiatives put in place in the fiscal second quarter continue to generate savings and compensation and other expenses such as meals, travel and entertainment, which we expect to continue through the remainder of fiscal 2020. As a result of our focus on improving efficiencies and expense reduction initiatives, our rolling 12-month efficiency ratio improved from 70.6% as of June 30, 2019 to 63.6% as of June 30, 2020.
Turning to our balance sheet. Total gross loans and leases decreased 3% on a linked quarter basis to $3.5 billion at June 30. The decrease was primarily related to certain legacy community bank loans classified as held for sale, which we expect to sell this quarter. Commercial finance loans, which comprise 62% of the company's gross loan and lease portfolio totaled $2.16 billion, reflecting growth of $133 million or 7% from March 31, 2020. Excluding the impact of the PPP loans, our commercial finance portfolio decreased 4% on a linked quarter basis as a result of lower asset based lending and factoring balances, offset by higher originations in our leasing business lines.
Average payments deposits were $6.32 billion for the quarter. Average payments deposits were inflated by $2.32 billion related to the EIP cards that were issued by MetaBank. Excluding the impact from the EIP cards, average payments deposits rose 46% compared to the same quarter in the prior fiscal year. A large component of the increase in payments deposits were driven by various stimulus payments that ended up on program partner cards as well as lower overall consumer spending levels. Finally, as we prepare to adopt CECL as of October 1, 2020, we have been running our inccurred allowance in CECL methodology in parallel and continue to refine our process and impact estimates.
Pre-COVID-19 provisioning levels were expected to be marginally higher. However, we certainly expect higher provisioning levels under CECL in the near term as COVID-19 factors are incorporated. As it relates to regulatory capital, we expect to elect the two-year delay and the five-year total transition period to minimize the impact of the increase in our allowance for credit losses on our capital ratios.
With that, I'll turn the conversation back to Brad for closing comments.
Brad Hanson -- Co-President and Chief Executive Officer of Meta Financial Group, and Co-President and Chief Executi
Thanks, Glen. We want to ensure all of our stakeholders that we continue to put our people first, while still maintaining a high-functioning business and operations. From a financial and regulatory perspective, we have been still even more diligent monitoring processes regarding credit quality, capital forecasting and financial stability. From a social perspective, we strive to promote financial equity by ensuring that everyone, not just a fortunate few, have access to quality financial products and services. That completes our prepared remarks, so I'll ask Brett and Glen to join me for Q&A.
Operator, please open the line for any questions.
Questions and Answers:
Operator
Thank you. [Operator Instructions] Our first question comes from Michael Perito with KBW. Your line is now open.
Michael Perito -- KBW -- Analyst
Hi. Good afternoon, everyone. Thank you for taking my questions.
Brad Hanson -- Co-President and Chief Executive Officer of Meta Financial Group, and Co-President and Chief Executi
Hi, Mike.
Michael Perito -- KBW -- Analyst
I wanted to just ask, I appreciate all the extra color on the treasury program liquidity. I just wanted to kind of get a sense of, if there was any kind of cadence to the consumer deployment here, I mean do you expect that there will be some kind of carryover of liquidity for some duration of time. Obviously, it seems like right out of the gates, there was quite a big drop, but has that slowed and is it realistic to assume that liquidity could be quite a bit elevated for the remainder of the year at this point?
Glen Herrick -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of Meta Financial Group and MetaBank
Hi, Mike. This is Glen. That is correct. The amount of funds that are still on there surprised us a little bit. We assume that the ramp down might be closer to what we see in tax season with the spending that occurs on those although we didn't expect it quite as fast. But what's been interesting is at least so far consumers have been hanging on to a fair amount of these funds and thus a little lower down as well as there is still some cards that haven't been activated and so we're working with the United States Treasury and Fiserv to help make sure we're communicating to those consumers properly. But that said we -- yes, we do expect to have some increased liquidity from that program over the next couple of quarters.
Michael Perito -- KBW -- Analyst
Okay. Thanks, Glen. And then, on the credit side, it seems like based on the prepared remarks there has been quite a bit of outreach to a lot of the, especially in the small ticket bucket, but to a lot of the commercial finance customers. And I'm just curious to this point, industrywide really we haven't really seen much in terms of any specific reserve or anything of that nature. I was just curious what your viewpoint is today, I mean obviously there is still a lot of government intervention stimulus given your customers, I imagine, quite a bit of liquidity, but I also have to imagine that cash flow might not be quite a strong as it was pre-pandemic. And you guys track those things when just kind of the push comes to show? I think, is it just simply when the deferral comes up or is it more complex than that in terms of when we could maybe start to see some more movement either direction really on the credit clarity front?
Brett Pharr -- Co-President and Chief Operating Officer of MetaBank
Hi. This is Brett. I'll take that at least initially, we have watched the credit trends and they have actually outperformed what we thought initially might happen. We've taken a measured approach on the reserves etc., decrease our allowance. Really the jury is out. We're going to have to watch as these modifications come off to see are they getting completely back in business or not. In some cases, these modifications were taken and what I would call an abundance of caution by the borrower and may not have even been needed. In other cases, they clearly where needed. But we're just going to have to watch and see. We're not -- we don't have enough information to have any insights really into which way this is going to go or how fast it's going to go.
Glen Herrick -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of Meta Financial Group and MetaBank
And Mike, I would say, we've been trying to get out in front of this by taking a measured approach to how much provision we can -- how far we can extend our provision for loan losses and our allowance ahead of the cycle here. So we feel like as we stated earlier that with our allowance, where it is and with the strength of our balance sheet that we're well positioned for however that falls out.
Michael Perito -- KBW -- Analyst
Okay. Is it fair to say that at this point with the reserve bill you've had in the first I mean in the last couple of quarters here plus kind of the opportunity you'll have with CECL adoption that you feel like environmentally, you have a pretty good handle on what the reserve needs to be and going forward or probably more specific in terms of what the provision cost looks like with actual credit starting to migrate in either direction.
Glen Herrick -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of Meta Financial Group and MetaBank
Mike, I think it's still too soon to tell. We feel good about our reserve levels today and it's a very fluid environment. It's a dynamic portfolio and we're staying very close to our borrowers on this.
Brad Hanson -- Co-President and Chief Executive Officer of Meta Financial Group, and Co-President and Chief Executi
And I think we're still waiting to see what the government does with respect to any further stimulus and that could impact things as much as anything else that we're looking at. So until those things start to evolve and we get more clarity, I think we're just trying to be as prudent as we can about how we proceed.
Michael Perito -- KBW -- Analyst
Great. I will jump back in the queue. Thank you, guys, I appreciate the time too.
Brad Hanson -- Co-President and Chief Executive Officer of Meta Financial Group, and Co-President and Chief Executi
Yeah.
Operator
Thank you. And our next question comes from Steve Moss with B. Riley FBR. Your line is now open.
Steve Moss -- B. Riley FBR -- Analyst
Hi. Good afternoon. Let's start with the -- perhaps the high-impact industries here. Kind of curious as to what you're seeing for business activity for those borrowers. If you can give any color there within the different buckets? And for hotel to again look what's the occupancy rate? And kind of what's the level of reopening you're seeing in those portfolios?
Brett Pharr -- Co-President and Chief Operating Officer of MetaBank
Yeah. A few things on the hospitality, I would particularly highlight the fact that these are not full service hotels or limited service and you likely understand that there has been a disparate impact based on which one of those you're in and we're on the right side of that trade. So we've not disclose exactly occupancy rates, but they are climbing revenue per available room is climbing and seeing some encouraging things that also referenced some materials we have on the geographies on where we're sitting. So an awful lot of our locations are in places that are, shall we say less impacted.
The retail obviously that's been hit pretty hard. We're watching that to see obviously see if they're still in business and we understand where they are and where they are not working closely with our borrower. And again in some of it depends on precisely which subset of retail they're in. In many cases, we are in, retail enterprises that have not been hit very hard. And then the others get pretty small. I mean we do have one theater relationship, which you can imagine, that's a little bit challenging and we're working closely through that one. So that's the bulk of it.
Steve Moss -- B. Riley FBR -- Analyst
Okay. That's helpful. And then perhaps on the other way in terms of business activity, kind of curious as to what you're seeing for commercial finance opportunities kind of how you -- what that kind of pipeline it looks like if you will?
Brett Pharr -- Co-President and Chief Operating Officer of MetaBank
Well, so if you think about pure commercial finance, especially the ABL and factoring our existing client balances, as you can see in the numbers or declining simply because of some declining sales and you understand that self-liquidating, so our exposure in that is is much, much more limited. We are starting to see the very early signs of some deals that are popping up. We're obviously being very, very cautious and very selective in that. If history is consistent, as we've seen in this industry from the past, for the next 24 months to 36 months, we could see some meaningful business development in that, but we are in the very early stages of that. And as I said, you have to be very careful and selective upfront.
Steve Moss -- B. Riley FBR -- Analyst
Just on the ABL and factoring, with as is liquidating here. Does that continue to liquidate to this point or have we come close to bottoming out on those balances?
Brett Pharr -- Co-President and Chief Operating Officer of MetaBank
If you think about the public economic trends that we're seeing and some things that are coming back and transaction volumes, etc., I think it's safe to say that our balances are seeing a similar kind of pattern.
Steve Moss -- B. Riley FBR -- Analyst
Okay. Thank you very much.
Brad Hanson -- Co-President and Chief Executive Officer of Meta Financial Group, and Co-President and Chief Executi
Yeah. Thanks, Steve.
Operator
Thank you. And our next question comes from Frank Schiraldi with Piper Sandler. Your line is now open.
Frank Schiraldi -- Piper Sandler -- Analyst
Good afternoon, guys. Just wanted to ask on the significant growth just outside of the direct treasury stimulus. It seems like, I mean I guess that's just income that's been pushed down the road, in terms of keeping -- not making much money off it sitting in cash balances, obviously, but at some point you will get a piece of those fees as those are spent down. So is that a fair way to think about it? And just wondering what your expectations are in card fee growth here in the near term?
Glen Herrick -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of Meta Financial Group and MetaBank
Yeah. That's correct, Frank. I guess the first part of your question, so some of our program partners are seeing -- saw some nice growth in deposits funds that were loaded outside of the direct EIP cards that we issued. So folks got a stimulus or unemployment and went and loaded it on a GPR card or a gift card or something else. That's why you're seeing that deposit growth as well as just normal card programs since folks are spending at a little lower rate or saving at a higher rate. We would expect those to pick up here at some point that should certainly help some fee income. Again our depending on the partner relationship where those fees are split between us and a program partner. But yes, that's an accurate observation.
Brad Hanson -- Co-President and Chief Executive Officer of Meta Financial Group, and Co-President and Chief Executi
However, on the EIP payments, those are some fees are being waived and we don't really expect there as we said in our prepared remarks there to be much of a financial impact to us from that program.
Frank Schiraldi -- Piper Sandler -- Analyst
Sure. Understood. And then on the EIP, is there a point where if these cars are not activated or spent down, is there a line in the sand where the treasury just take this money back and tries to find another way. Is that been decided? And then does the EIP in any way given that you have more balances than you anticipated at this point? Does that limit flexibility at all just given where it reduces leverage ratios too?
Brad Hanson -- Co-President and Chief Executive Officer of Meta Financial Group, and Co-President and Chief Executi
There are terms with the government as you can imagine on how those deposits will be handled. And I'll let Glen respond to the leverage ratio.
Glen Herrick -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of Meta Financial Group and MetaBank
Yeah. So it's really that treasury's call on when they might pull back fund. So we don't want to speak for them are try to determine. They're still seen how this progresses. Yes, certainly we have more liquidity than we can use right now. We don't -- it's a $2 billion today, we don't expect it to stay at that number, it's probably less than that at this hour now obviously. And so we do expect it to get back into a more manageable thing, which will allow us to have lower wholesale funding. So in the short term, our leverage ratios are certainly depressed, artificially temporarily depressed, but we're not concerned about longer term of the impact of these deposits.
Frank Schiraldi -- Piper Sandler -- Analyst
Okay. And then if I could just one last one on credit. On the increase in NPA balances, think Brad mentioned it was in the equipment lease portfolio. Just kind of curious, wouldn't that -- I would think that for the most part given deferral period of up to 6 months that those would just continue to take deferrals and would remain I guess current on your books as opposed to falling into non-performing category. So I just wonder if you could talk a little bit more about how you're dealing with the deferrals and if -- as you go along here, some of these loans are falling into the criticized, classified and NPAs?
Brett Pharr -- Co-President and Chief Operating Officer of MetaBank
Yeah. So particularly around the leasing portfolio Crestmark has a fairly lengthy history and carefully monitoring on a regular basis equipment values. And of course depending on the equipment, it could have a relatively short life or it could have a very long life. Understanding that equipment value and whether you have a shortfall or not is helping to inform the modifications. When you're dealing with equipment at some point you got to kind of call the question. Now, frankly, in the commercial equipment finance division, most of these are more liquid Fortune 1,000 companies and they are not having the stresses in many cases. They took modifications in abundance of caution, just to preserve liquidity because like everybody they didn't know what was going to happen. So I would say the key driver in the equipment view is the monitoring of the equipment values to make decisions, and we've got a team that are experts at that.
Frank Schiraldi -- Piper Sandler -- Analyst
Okay. All right. Great. Thank you.
Brad Hanson -- Co-President and Chief Executive Officer of Meta Financial Group, and Co-President and Chief Executi
Thanks, Frank.
Operator
Thank you. And this concludes the question-and-answer session. I will now turn the call back to CEO, Brad Hanson.
Brad Hanson -- Co-President and Chief Executive Officer of Meta Financial Group, and Co-President and Chief Executi
I'd like to close by thanking everybody for participating in Meta's quarterly investor call today. We truly appreciate your support and thank you for taking time to listen in. Have a great evening.
Operator
[Operator Closing Remarks]
Duration: 36 minutes
Call participants:
Brittany Kelley Elsasser -- Director of Investor Relations
Brad Hanson -- Co-President and Chief Executive Officer of Meta Financial Group, and Co-President and Chief Executi
Brett Pharr -- Co-President and Chief Operating Officer of MetaBank
Glen Herrick -- Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer of Meta Financial Group and MetaBank
Michael Perito -- KBW -- Analyst
Steve Moss -- B. Riley FBR -- Analyst
Frank Schiraldi -- Piper Sandler -- Analyst
